Saussure's System For Evaluating Linguistics Essay

Saussure's System For Evaluating Linguistics Essay

Length: 895 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In “Course in General Linguistics”, Saussure does two things to develop his system for evaluating linguistics: he chooses language as his linguistic object and he only incorporates factors into his model that can be said to be true of all languages over all time. The net result is a very high level and flexible classification structure, which is more intent on making a developmental framework for evaluating linguistics than necessarily providing tremendous insight into it’s more concrete aspects: rudiments like structure, meaning, morphology, syntax, or phonology.
Others, including Levi- Strauss in “Structural Anthropology”, have used
Saussure’s methodology to develop their own models for study in different aspects of
human society. But Levi- Strauss takes the methodology one step further by explicitly
trying to answer the anthropological questions based on Saussure’s work: which in the
case of linguistics would be “Why does language exist?” and “What do the differences
we distinguish between languages tell us about the people who use it?”
The answer to the first question for Saussure, I speculate, is human desire to
communicate. When evaluating linguistics, Saussure makes an extremely convincing
argument that there is an arbitrary relationship between the signifier and the signified,
and that it is language itself that evolves over time to develop those distinctions and
provide signs their own relative values. In doing so, he disregards the need to even try to
develop a system that maps actual tangible examples of language use against one another
because, as Saussure mentions, there are always counterexamples. But Saussure never
tries to explain why those tangible differences exist or why, despite these differences,...

... middle of paper ... English signs may also have been
affected? And what conclusions can we draw from these changes about the English speaking
people over this time period?
This becomes an engineering design problem if we take the vantage point that
society is the engineer. Going back to the Levi-Strauss model, English speakers wanted
to maintain an effective and convenient way to express the idea of feet, but because of
some change, society felt a need to adjust the sign’s meaning. As a modern linguistic
engineer, we might ask ourselves what led to this specific change and what possible
conclusions can we draw from this about English society?
The structuralist method developed by Saussure has a lot of potential
applications that could be a very effective tool in many fields of study. I just mentioned a
few possible implementations and possible results that could come of it.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Saussure Used On Language And Speech

- An important distinction that Saussure used was between language and speech. Language (langue) is a system, an universal structure and arrangement of rules shared by a community with principal linguistic patterns, as seen in forge in languages. Speech (parole) is the use of language individually, any particular act of language that is experienced in everyday life. It is diverse, it varies, it changes and is manipulated by time, social groups and the generation using it. A simpler way to put it is “if langue is the whole of language, parole is the part, or parts, which operates within the whole” (Kearney 241)....   [tags: Linguistics, Structuralism, Ferdinand de Saussure]

Better Essays
898 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about The Semiotic Theory Developed By Ferdinand De Saussure

- Ferdinand de Saussure is one of history’s greatest contributors to both modern linguistics and structuralist semiology. Semiology can be understood as the analysis of sign systems. Prior to Saussure’s theory, “linguistics was principally diachronic and he was the one who inaugurated the synchronic study of language and the way meaning is structurally generated” (Potter, 2015). Additionally, semiology can also be interpreted as the attempt to study reality as a text. There is not a single part of our reality that cannot in some way, shape or form be considered part of a text....   [tags: Linguistics, Ferdinand de Saussure, Semiotics]

Better Essays
822 words (2.3 pages)

Linguistics and Its Pioneers Essay

- Linguistics, as defined by Edward Finegan, is the systematic inquiry into human language-into its structures and uses and the relationship between hem, as well as into the development and acquisition of language. Language, as defined by the Collegiate Merriam-Webster Dictionary, is a body or system of words and phrases used by a large community or by a people, a nation, or a group of nations. Most contemporary linguists work under the assumption that spoken language is more fundamental, and thus more important to study than writing (Linguistics)....   [tags: Linguistics]

Better Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

Speech Errors as Presented in the Literature of Linguistics

- Introduction: Speech errors serve as a window to investigate speech production and arrangement of language elements in the brain. Gary S. Dell and Peter A. Reich (1980) said that one of the best way to find out how a system is constructed is if that system breaks. Speech errors as a linguistic phenomenon has been the topic of many linguistic researches. It can be investigated as an evidence for linguistic change as well. Bussmann and Hadumod (1996) in the Routledge dictionary of language and linguistics defines speech errors as " (Latin: lapsus linguae), is a deviation (conscious or unconscious) from the apparently intended form of an utterance." (449)....   [tags: Linguistics]

Better Essays
1927 words (5.5 pages)

Understanding How Translation Studies And Linguistics Essay

- According to Catford, “General Linguistics is, primarily, a theory about languages work.” and “Translation is an operation performed on languages … [so] any theory of translation must draw upon a theory of language - a general linguistic theory. ” (1965:1). This article discusses mainly the research process of understanding how Translation Studies and Linguistics are related to each other and in what specific aspects these two disciplines contribute to each other. Sources cited are either digital online articles or hard copies from the school library....   [tags: Linguistics, Translation, Applied linguistics]

Better Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Language, Linguistics And The Importance Of Studying Language

- What is language, linguistics and the importance of studying language. It is a staggering thought to imagine an existence without language. To be restricted to basic forms of communication or to have none at all is an unimaginably condition. Language, in simple terms, is the manner in which people express themselves and the understanding of communication presented to them . The phenomenon of language is confined to mankind and is an intricate and vital element in the complex framework of human beings....   [tags: Language, Linguistics, Historical linguistics]

Better Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

The Is The Fundamental Principle Of Language, Psychology And Philosophy Essay

- The term ‘logocentrism’ is a neologism used to refer to the attitude that logos is the fundamental principle of language, psychology and philosophy. Derived from the Greek verb legō, logos encapsulates the meaning of speech, reason, thought and law. The term stems from the 1920s having been coined by the German philosopher Ludwig Klages who believed the logos to be a supreme principle that gives meaning to all discourse and organises all differences in an intellectual system. Logocentrism essentially rejects writing as an appendage to speech and, in agreement with Aristotle, purports that while spoken words are the symbols of “mental experience”, written words are merely the symbols of that...   [tags: Linguistics, Ferdinand de Saussure]

Better Essays
1183 words (3.4 pages)

Structuralism Developed by Ferdinand de Saussure Essays

- Structuralism was developed by Ferdinand de Saussure in the mid-twentieth century (Cuddon and Preston 923). This creation was brought on, in part, by the French existentialism period and is often combined with the semiotic theory of literary criticism; both are the source of development for other literary criticisms from the formalist schools of thought. As the name suggests, structuralism examines the structure of the work, investigating the ramifications of the organizations of literatures (McManus, 1998)....   [tags: literary theories, french existentialism]

Better Essays
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Modern Linguistics And Its Effects On Human Language Essay

- As each new language that is studied reveals more exciting and unanticipated linguistic features, a shift away from the dominant view of language universality is gradually taking place. Evans and Levison (2009) suggest this generative position, which has pervaded modern linguistics since Chomsky’s proposal of Universal Grammar, be replaced by the functionalist position that heralds language variation as the key to natural human language. This change is concurrent with that of another more specific view that has also restricted linguistic theory for decades, stemming from Saussure’s principle of the arbitrariness of the linguistic sign....   [tags: Linguistics, Language, Language family]

Better Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

The Journal Of Linguistics, By Paul Sidwell Essay

- Throughout the 37th volume of the Journal of Linguistics, Paul Sidwell gathers evidence from the sources presented and makes an argument surrounding the idea that the ancient technology of language has shaped the evolution of human cultures greatly, and supports that and further defines his argument with several examples. Throughout Sidwell’s article in the Journal of Linguistics, it’s apparent that the focus is on the technology of language and the effect it’s had on the development of human cultures....   [tags: Culture, Linguistics, Historical linguistics]

Better Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)