Same-Sex Parents and Their Struggle with Adoption Essay

Same-Sex Parents and Their Struggle with Adoption Essay

Length: 1536 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The California UPA has a unique function, which allows a mother to establish parenthood through the provision that fathers use to establish paternity. The California Supreme Court recognized that the Court of Appeal made an error, by ruling, “California law recognizes only one natural mother”, in interpreting a statement from a prior California Supreme Court ruling in Johnson v. Calvert. The Attorney General, representing “the public interest in establishing, modifying, and enforcing support obligations,” contended that the statement from Johnson, cannot be used to deny children of same-sex parents the benefits that children of opposite-sex couples receive when only two parties are entitled to parentage. California’s enactment of the UPA provides “insofar as practicable,” the provision used to establish fatherhood can also establish motherhood. California acknowledges that a man can establish fatherhood by living with the child and holding the child out as his own. The provision applies to gay and lesbian parents as well, providing protection of their parental rights.
California’s enactment of the UPA lays some of the framework in providing protections for gay and lesbian parents. In Elisa B. v. Superior Court, the court held the former lesbian partner was a parent under the UPA and recognized her obligation to support the children, through child support. The court reasoned that the she supported the artificial insemination, she received and held the children out as her own, and she supported her former family after the couple separated. Furthermore, the court reasons that this, like others, is not a case to rebut paternity because doing so would leave the children without the benefit and support of their second parent....

... middle of paper ...

...y and Visitation Rights and Child Support Obligations of De Facto Parents, Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Family Law § 7:14, Dec. 2013.
ALI Principles § 2.03 (b) (2000).

Miller, quoting rule 1401 (a)(8)of the Juvenile Court Rules of the California Rules of Court.
In re Guardianship of Z.C.W., 84 Cal.Rptr.2d 48,
See In re Guardianship of Z.C.W., 84 Cal.Rptr.2d 48 (Ct. App. 1999) (holding a lesbian parent is not entitled to custody of a child conceived during a same-sex relationship); Curiale v. Reagan, 272 Cal. Rptr. 520 (Ct. App. 1990) (holding that a non-parent had no standing to seek custody against a child’s natural parent.)
William Reppy, Jr. & Cynthia Samuel
Palazzo v. Mire
Alan Duke. Hawaii to become 16th state to legalize same-sex marriage.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Same Sex Marriage Should Be Legal Essay

- In todays society we see same sex couples having more rights when it comes to marriage. The aim of this is to determine whether, ‘same sex couple today have greater rights then they did in previous generations’. The method to do this is to research about the topic and follow the guiding questions. Although many countries have now accepted and approved same sex marriage, Australia is not one of them. There hasn’t been much gentleness or wisdom surrounding the same-sex marriage debates in the Australian parliament....   [tags: Same-sex marriage, Homosexuality, Marriage]

Powerful Essays
1318 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Same Sex Marriage Should Be Legal

- Attention Getter: It is unbelievable that there is even a debate about same-sex marriage. This is really a no-brainer After all this is the year 2015 and we are still having the same debate about wheth-er or not same sex couples should be allow to have equal protection under the law. Do not be fooled. This is not about morals; this is not about ethics; most of all, this is not about God; this is about civil rights. II. Thesis: Gay citizens deserve the right to be treated equally. This is way gay marriage should legal....   [tags: Homosexuality, Same-sex marriage, Marriage]

Powerful Essays
1630 words (4.7 pages)

Should Same-Sex Couples Be Allowed to Adopt? Essay examples

- ... In the article, Gay and Lesbian Adoptive Parents: Resources for Professional and Parents, it states that social workers are hesitant to allow same-sex adoptions because they wonder how the child will be raised and how the child will feel about themselves and the parents being homosexual. It is also stated in the article that conservative political and religious groups show how same-sex adoption have negative effects on children (“Gay and Lesbian Adoptive Parents”). There have been cases where the courts have taken in the fact that a child adopted by homosexual parents could be teased because of the parents and did what was the best interest for the child....   [tags: happiness, rights, family, illegal]

Powerful Essays
839 words (2.4 pages)

Rights of Same-Sex Couples as Parents Essays

- Finding the perfect mate, getting married, having children; as a child, many fantasize about the big events to come in their adult life. How would you feel if those events weren’t something that you could experience because of government laws. Of the fifty states in the U.S., only six allow same-sex couples to get married, even fewer allow same-sex couples their full rights as parents. State laws aren’t the only laws to blame; some federal laws also inhibit same-sex marriage, benefits, adoption, and parenting rights....   [tags: American Society]

Powerful Essays
1422 words (4.1 pages)

Same-Sex Marriage Essay

- For over four hundred years, African Americans have faced discrimination in the United States, and it took them more than ten years to find some sort of equality. Women have also faced discrimination for hundreds of years and it took them over fifty years to earn minimal rights. While the issue of homosexuality is relatively new to our country, the fight for rights started almost immediately, and people today are still struggling to earn civil liberties, like same-sex marriage. If some change isn’t made now, their struggle for rights could last even longer than other minorities have endured....   [tags: Discrimination, argumentative, persuasive]

Powerful Essays
1645 words (4.7 pages)

Adoption Is A Big Responsibility Essay example

- Adoption is defined “in legal sense as a process that allows for the transfer of the legal right, responsibilities, and privilege of parenthood to a new legal parent or parent.” (Schaefer 308) Adoption is a big responsibility and is becoming very common nowadays. People turn to adoption for many different reasons and the many different reasons lead to people wanting to have a child or an addition to their family. Adoption agencies however are sometimes biased and restrict certain group of people based on their sexual orientation....   [tags: Sexual orientation, Homosexuality, LGBT, Gender]

Powerful Essays
2028 words (5.8 pages)

SameSex Couple and Adoption Essay

-   Introduction Adoption is not about finding children for families, it’s about finding families for children” (Joyce Maguire Pavao). Same sex couples should have the same options as heterosexual couples. Who says that a gay couple can’t raise a child and they come out perfectly fine. Many same-sex couples, after a lot of struggle, have been able to adopt and have changed a child’s life.Allowing same-sex couples to adopt is a powerful step towards success and it helps in many ways, which is why same-sex couples should be able to adopt....   [tags: Families, Orphans, Heterosexual Families]

Powerful Essays
1038 words (3 pages)

Homosexual Adoption Rights Essay

- New Jersey’s statewide parenting legislation espouses a progressive stance on the matters of same-sex parenting and child care in the processes of adoption and foster parenting. The Garden State allows for same-sex adoption; allows single homosexuals to adopt; and allows second parent same-sex adoption (“Same-Sex Adoption Laws,” n.d.). New Jersey has passed progressive laws and policies that prohibit discrimination charged against gay individuals in the adoption process (Sudol, 2010). New Jersey state law also bans discrimination against gay individuals in the foster parent process (2010)....   [tags: Legal Issues, New Jersey, Foster Care ]

Powerful Essays
2526 words (7.2 pages)

Parents And Same Sex Adoption Essay

- If you were to Google the definition of the word family, you would see “a group consisting of parents and children living in a household” or “a person or people related to one and so to be treated with a special loyalty or intimacy.” In my opinion, family is a group of people, no matter their race, religion, or sexual orientation, who love each other and will do anything to protect them. However, there are people in this world who believe family should be limited to parents of opposite genders. Mitch and Cam Pritchett are the power couple when it comes to same-sex adoption, even though they are fictional....   [tags: Homosexuality, Same-sex marriage]

Powerful Essays
1714 words (4.9 pages)

Gender Inequality : Are All Men The Same? Essay

- A question that is often asked by many women is “are all men the same?” The answer is no. One position about what it is to be a man is that society often stereotypes all men as sex driven beings, this is partially because men under certain circumstances may feel a social pressure. While this is for the most part physically and psychologically accurate, many men over time grow and change their beliefs or feelings towards sex. A second position is that a man’s environment can affect who they are, and momentarily or in some cases, for an extended period of time can determine their level of “masculinity”....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Man, Gender identity]

Powerful Essays
1350 words (3.9 pages)