Essay on Ruse on a Biological Foundation for Ethics

Essay on Ruse on a Biological Foundation for Ethics

Length: 1367 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Michael Ruse argues that "The Biological Sciences Can Act as a Ground for Ethics." (p.297) He begins with a distinction between the normative and the meta-ethical, and then sets out to lay the foundations for normative ethics as a biologically driven adaptive function. He then moves on to justifying why we ought to behave as biology influences us to do, where he runs into a problem.

People feel certain ways about what is right and what is wrong, Ruse begins, and these feelings are what become the moral maxims we follow (p299). We feel this way and obey our feelings because "it is in our interest to do so." (p.299) Ruse explores Rawls's theory of justice, citing game theory as a reason why fairness becomes normative. People don't know which position in life they'll end up with, so it's in their interest to choose a society that treats everyone fairly (p299-300). Ruse quotes Rawls, who says that fairness promotes both group stability and individual longevity within the group [which would tend to favor continued reproduction] (p300).

Ruse then illustrates how emotional response influences what we come to believe is ethically correct behavior. A parent, he says, feels more attachment to his or her own child than to children in another country. Normally, a parent will tend to his or her own child before attending to a stranger. And when a parent does the opposite, Ruse says, we tend to look on that person as being neglectful of his or her duty to family. That emotional attachment to family is biological, and so it makes sense that we would consider it the moral thing to ensure family welfare before general welfare (p301). Ruse expands on this, citing Singer's allusion to two moral dilemmas, in which the proposed action is logic...

... middle of paper ...

...stinction error, he's essentially removed the ethics from ethics. Behavior that doesn't have any more compulsory basis than eating, sleeping, or excreting doesn't seem to me to qualify as ethical in nature. Ruse doesn't seem to view this as much of a hurdle; he seems to feel that if one thinks his behavior is ethical, then it is ethical. Philosophically speaking, however, a system without any foundation can never leave the arena of the descriptive. Ruse may be comfortable with his argument as it is; however, I do not think that one can claim that there is no ground and then say in the same breath that Biology or any other science is the ground, for ethics or any other branch of reasoning.

Works Cited
Ruse, M. (2010). The Biological Sciences Can Act as a Ground for Ethics. In F. Ayala & R. Arp (Eds.), Contemporary Debates in Philosophy of Biology, Wiley-Blackwell.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Ethics: The Foundation of Good Business Essay

- According to the Hutchinson Unabridged Encyclopedia business ethics is the moral principles defining how businesses and business professionals should act toward each other, employees, and the public. Some professions such as law and medicine clearly have defined codes of professional ethics. In other areas appropriate behavior has been established over time by practice. Business ethics involves the role of a company in our society. Complex and contentious areas of business ethics would include the effect a petrochemical company's actions have on the environment or the obligation of a pharmaceutical company to make its drugs available to developing countries....   [tags: Business Ethics]

Strong Essays
674 words (1.9 pages)

The Foundation Of Ethics Is Instilled Essay

- The foundation of ethics is instilled in a person during childhood. Children are usually taught at an early age, right from wrong, not to take what is not theirs, and to always speak the truth. The simple definition of Ethics is basically knowing right from wrong and believing in morals. I will always be grateful to my mother for teaching me to never be mean or make fun of people. There was a classmate of mine that was burned in a house fire and was lucky to be alive, because his sister and mother were killed in it....   [tags: Ethics, Thought, Family, Nursing]

Strong Essays
1177 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about The Foundation of Traditional Ethics

- In “Abolition of Man”, author C.S. Lewis discussed the foundation of traditional ethics by embracing the Chinese word Tao, meaning “the Way.” Lewis declares that people today have assumed a place outside the Tao. This position involves, according to C.S. Lewis, a choice between two evils; and one or the other evil is our destiny if we believe that the Tao isn’t real. But aside from such everyday thoughts, there are hypothetical problems to this belief. The demand to abandon traditional ethics is frequently related to what is thought to be a new and rational set of morals....   [tags: tao, cs lewis, abolition of man]

Strong Essays
1047 words (3 pages)

The Biological Factors, And The Free Will Essay

- When looking at a person’s life, there are many factors to consider, social strains, biology, free will, and up-bringing to name a few. Each of them is very important, but today I will e discussing the biological factors, and the free will. Free will is the ultimate or final decider of one’s life path, and although factors of determinism might give one their foundation or starting point, free will takes you the rest of the way. That being said, it is important to remember that free will and determinism are not mutually exclusive....   [tags: Free will, Determinism, Biological determinism]

Strong Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

Chemical and Biological Weaponry Essay

- Chemical and Biological Weaponry Introduction: A Modern Day Trojan Horse Although the envelope resembled a letter from a fourth grade student, the contents addressed to Senator Tom Daschle were life threatening. Laced within the envelope was a form of the bacteria known as Bacillus Anthracis, bacteria more commonly known as anthrax. When exposed to humans, an anthrax infection leads to the release of toxins, which if not properly treated are fatal ( Around the same time of Senator Daschle’s threat, other cases of anthrax exposure were publicized....   [tags: Biological Warfare Nuclear Weapons Ethics Essays]

Free Essays
1329 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Ethics : Ethics And Ethics

- Short Paper: Ethics Introduction “The term ‘ethics’ can commonly refer to the rules and principles that define right and wrong conduct of individuals” (Robbins, Bergman, Stagg and Coulter, 2003, p.150). Ethical Behavior is accepted as “right” or “good” in the context of a governing moral code. Virtually all societies have developed rules and regulations about how business should be transacted and how business organizations should be managed. In concept, business ethics is the applied ethics discipline that addresses the moral features of commercial activity....   [tags: Ethics, Business ethics, Morality, Applied ethics]

Strong Essays
1587 words (4.5 pages)

Philosophical Foundation of Ecological Ethics Essay

- Philosophical Foundation of Ecological Ethics ABSTRACT: Principles of Buddhist philosophy central to the formation of an ecological paradigm of mentality include a dynamic vision of the world, a system of relative truth apart from dogmas, a moral foundation for scientific knowledge, an emphasis on nonviolence and the absence of repressive scientific methods, and the progressive movement of the intellect to Universal Consciousness which postulates the unity of microcosm and macrocosm. The comparative analysis of laws and principles of modern ecological science and basic Buddhist thought points to their common intentional direction....   [tags: Ecology Ecological Philosophy Papers]

Free Essays
1413 words (4 pages)

In Search of a Methodological Foundation for Applied Ethics Essay

- In Search of a Methodological Foundation for Applied Ethics ABSTRACT: The problems that face contemporary applied ethics are indissolubly related to some characteristics of postmodern civil society. In this paper I will try to take a stand in the discussion between a proponent of a particularistic approach and one who favors a universalistic approach to the present difficulties that accompany human action. Karl-Otto Apel combines in his ethics of discourse a focus upon universal and normative structures of communication with a Kantian transcendental method of thought....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Papers]

Free Essays
3383 words (9.7 pages)

Moral Philosophy as Applied Science by Ruse and Wilson Essay

- Moral Philosophy as Applied Science by Ruse and Wilson Ruse and Wilson in "Moral Philosophy as Applied Science" give the example of brother-sister incest avoidance as being an ethical code motivated by an epigenetic rule that confers an adaptive advantage on those who avoid intercourse with their siblings....   [tags: Moral Philosophy Genetics]

Free Essays
1900 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on University Foundation

- University Foundation The presentation I choose to summarize is Greg Gissendanner’s presentation on the university foundation. Like most of the other presentations in class, Greg used the standard outline of presenting the unit’s history, mission, organizational structure, funding and financial concerns, and current issues. History. Greg showed that while many foundations look fairly similar today, the history of foundation development took on many different forms at different institutions....   [tags: University Foundation Education Essays]

Free Essays
2665 words (7.6 pages)