Rules That Matter: Political Institutions and the Diversity-Conflict Nexus

Rules That Matter: Political Institutions and the Diversity-Conflict Nexus

Length: 1004 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Introduction and Summary
Many political studies on civil war have focused on the role that institutions play in ethnically divided societies. While 'constitutional engineers' have claimed that certain rules and institutional arrangements, like proportional representation or decentralization, help divided societies to maintain peace (Lijphart 1977, 1999; Fearon/Laitin 2003; Reynal-Querol 2005), political sociologists have argued that they only reflect the cleavage lines within such societies (Lipset/Rokkan 1967; Collier/Hoeffler 2004). However, most of the researchers' results are neither robust nor replicable across studies (Hegre/Sambanis 2006).
Examining this contradictory role of political institutions, Schneider/Wiesehomeier (2008: 184) state that, in general, institutions help to reduce conflict, but that this positive effect might be weakened by certain forms of ethnic diversity, namely by polarization, fractionalization, and dominance. They find that the impact of the three diversity indicators on the outbreak of civil war varies across different types of political regimes (ibid.: 199). In addition, Schneider/Wiesehomeier demonstrate that power-sharing institutions are able to relax tense intrastate relations in strongly divided societies (ibid.: 199). Furthermore, presidential systems seem to be the most war-prone institutional settings among the studied democratic regimes (ibid.: 184). Thus, they conclude that rules matter (ibid.: 199).
Although the idea and the way of exploring the research question are exemplary, the research design displays two critical problems, which will be portrayed below. Therefore, I argue that the authors' synthesis of the two conflicting schools of thought suffers from the incompleteness o...

... middle of paper ...

... Analysis of the Empirical Literature on Civil War Onset. Journal of Conflict Resolution 50 (4): 508–535.
Lijphart, Arend, 1977: Democracy in Plural Societies: A Comparative Exploration. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Lijphart, Arend, 1999: Patterns of Democracy: Government Forms and Performance in Thirty-Six Countries. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Lipset, Seymour M./Rokkan, Stein, 1967: Party Systems and Voter Alignments: Cross-National Perspectives. New York: Free Press.
Reynal-Querol, Marta, 2005: Does Democracy Preempt Civil Wars? European Journal of Political Economy 21 (2): 445–465.
Schneider, Gerald/Wiesehomeier, Nina, 2008: Rules That Matter: Political Institutions and the Diversity-Conflict Nexus. Journal of Peace Research 45 (2): 183-203.
Wolff, Stefan, 2006: Ethnic conflict. A global Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Effects Of Corruption On Australian Political Institutions

- Political corruption is a major issue in political science whose definition requires careful analysis and evaluation based on available evidence from multiple points of view. The two academic articles chosen for this paper include Balachandrudu’s (2006) paper on the nature of political corruption and McAllister’s (2014) paper on the effects of corruption on Australian political institutions. Balachandrudu (2006) provides a detailed analysis of the constituents of corruption, its various definitions, and the implications in the democratic Indian society as a case study....   [tags: Political corruption, Politics, Definition]

Strong Essays
1115 words (3.2 pages)

Essay Political Institutions Effect on Societies

- ... Some of he disadvantages of central governments are overall not business friendly, strain growth because its hard to restrain, and no hard money constraints. On the other hand, a decentralization process increases democratic process efficiency, economic development and tends to avoid ethnic conflict. Larry Diamond discusses the influence of smaller states versus bigger states. He asserts that local governments foster democratic vitality. It helps to develop democratic values and skills among citizens in other words, citizen development....   [tags: outcomes, efficiency, economic, conflict]

Strong Essays
907 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and Political Institutions

- How do political institutions affect foreign direct investment. The field of International Political Economy (IPE) have seen a tremendous amount continuous change in both the past and recent time. The climate and conditions within the theoretical and practical aspects of the field are ever-changing and have led to a volatile political and economic landscape to form. This essay will focus on one aspect of IPE that have relatively quickly risen to become imperatively influential and important for the developments in the field, that aspect is Multinational Companies (MNC) and their Foreign Direct Investments (FDI)....   [tags: Political Science]

Strong Essays
2674 words (7.6 pages)

MMP: Improving Politcal Diversity and Contrasting FPP Essay example

- It is evident that the diversity of New Zealand Parliament has increased both socially and politically since the introduction of the Mixed Member Proportionality (MMP) electoral system in 1996. The first part of this essay will focus on the mechanisms of how MMP significantly improved the political diversity in different areas. I will explain this by examining the key differences between MMP and its predecessor, First-Past-the-Post (FPP). The second part of this essay will explore the reasons why social diversity and minority representation in parliament has improved under MMP, with reference to the interesting effect of ‘macrocontagion’....   [tags: Political Science]

Strong Essays
1469 words (4.2 pages)

The Nexus Between Religion, Violence, And Terrorism Essay

- One of the goals of this week’s class is to understand “the nexus between religion, violence, and terrorism.” I will focus my discussion on the connection between the first two: religion and violence. Throughout our readings, multiple solutions are proposed for how to reduce religiously inspired violence in the Middle East. I will address two contradictory solutions: one that aspires to reduce religion’s public role and the other which seeks to increase it. To be sure, the two proposals I will be analyzing are not the only solutions, nor do I believe that are they the best....   [tags: Islam, Religion, Middle East, Christianity]

Strong Essays
894 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on A Country Is Democratic And Political Institutions

- The reason many developing countries began with “bad” early institutions has to do with political institutions. Fukuyama states that there is a strong connection between the richest countries and the countries that have strong institutions. Strong political institutions generally have an effective institution that is mostly uncorrupt, enforces its laws, has transparent laws and open entries to legal and political institutions. Fukuyama gives an example that if a country is ruled by the elites who want the resources for their own use and if property rights are not given and if a country does not have consistent policies or does not educate its citizens, then if rich natural resources l...   [tags: United States, Indigenous peoples of the Americas]

Strong Essays
1002 words (2.9 pages)

Political Institutions And The Foundation Of Civilization Essay

- Political institutions serve as one of the integral components for the foundation of civilization. The break down of governments can rot the core of a country and cause severe global issues. Several instances of broken down political institutions, ranging from Egypt to Uganda, has lead to massive corrosion of civilizations, and has disturbed the functioning peace within many countries. The weakenging, or full on collapse of an institution can leave the country crippled, and will open up the opportunity for there to be massive corruption and greed....   [tags: War, World War II, United States, Democracy]

Strong Essays
1747 words (5 pages)

The Evolving Nexus between Islam and Iran Essay

- The Evolving Nexus between Islam and Iran The nexus between Islam and Iran is a complex one. Islam was brought to Iran via Arab-Islamic conquest in 650 AD and has played a shifting, anomalous role in this nation-state ever since. The ideas of nationalism, secularism, religion, and revolution are unique in this Muslim country. Iranians, unlike many of their neighbors, hold on very strongly to their pre-Islamic roots and achievements; sentiments of nationalism are apparent throughout Iranian history and in the everyday conversations of Iranians....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Strong Essays
5566 words (15.9 pages)

Political Institution Essay

- A political institution is a system of politics and government. It is usually compared to the law system, economic system, cultural system, and other social systems. It is different from them, and can be generally defined on a spectrum from left, i.e. communism and socialism to the right, i.e. fascism. Linz’s argument is on the description of Totalitarian and Authoritarian Regimes, which brings the main and important argument of explaining both Presidential and Parliamentary systems. Another important author whose thoughts were referred to political institutions is Seymour Martin Lipset....   [tags: Government Structure Political Science]

Free Essays
1336 words (3.8 pages)

Diversity in Colleges Essay example

- Traditional Diversity At UC-Berkeley, the course description for "Politics and Poetics" (Fall Course 2002) stated that "conservative thinkers are encouraged to seek other sections." (SAF 1). Though the instructor later apologized for the description, this is the sort of encouragement conservative-minded students are greeted with many times during their college experience. It is said that in class, students are taught that their country -- and Western culture in general -- is tainted by racism, sexism, and oppression (Stearn 2)....   [tags: Race Sex Diversity]

Strong Essays
2683 words (7.7 pages)