The Role of Ethics in Bringing Extinct Species Back to Life Essay

The Role of Ethics in Bringing Extinct Species Back to Life Essay

Length: 1182 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Bringing Them Back to Life, an article written by Carl Zimmer for National Geographic April 2013 edition, discusses the possibilities in modern science to clone and revive species that have been driven to extinction in the past ten thousand years (445). Throughout this article, the author makes use of the rhetorical devices logos, ethos, and pathos to argue to an audience that humans have an obligation to revive species which have been driven to extinction directly due to human influences. Though the author acknowledges the benefits of species revival, and attempts to rebut his own arguments, the author’s use of fallacies takes away from the credibility of the article.
The role of ethics in modern genetic species revival is an arguable topic which takes on different stances depending upon who the author’s audiences are. In this piece, the author’s primary audience would be people who share the belief that it is ethical to revive such species. These people could include scientist, conservationists, and/or government officials because of their direct correlation to efforts similar to those that the author describes. Though there are people share the author’s beliefs, the secondary audience to this piece would include those who disagree with the author’s claim. People such as scientists, and government officials could also fall into this category, as they may disagree with the author’s claim. As a tertiary audience, the general pubic could be considered because of either their agreement, disagreement, or neutrality on the author’s claim that it is the ethical responsibility of humans to revive species which have become extinct directly due to human influence.
Arguing his claim that humans have an obligation to revi...


... middle of paper ...


...e author’s established credibility through the use of ethos. Through the use of appeals to logos, ethos, and pathos, the author attempts support his claim that humans have an obligation to revive species which have been driven to extinction directly due to human influences. Though the author establishes his credibility to the audiences in agreement with his claim , the author’s use of fallacies within his arguments proves that the article lacks credibility. Therefore, the argument that humans have an obligation to revive species which have been driven to extinction directly due to human influences is ineffective and not a credible argument.



Works Cited

Zimmer, Carl. "Bringing Them Back to Life." Good Reasons With Contemporary Arguments. 6th ed. Ed. Lester Faigley and Jack Selzer. San Francisco: Pearson, 2014. 445-451. Pearson eText. Web. 5 Feb. 2014.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Should Humans Bring Back Extinct Species? Essay

- Cheating Nature: Should Humans Bring Back Extinct Species. Modern-day genetic technology has granted mankind with the opportunity to bring back extinct species from the dead. If humans have come to possess the DNA from an extinct animal population, it is possible to create an identical clone of the animal in question, effectively “bringing it back from the dead”. Many ethical dilemmas surround the practice of de-extinction, and rightfully so. Recreating an extinct species could produce groundbreaking scientific breakthroughs, generating exciting opportunities for future genetics-based research....   [tags: Endangered species, Extinction, Plant, Evolution]

Strong Essays
1119 words (3.2 pages)

The Cloning of a Mammoth Essay examples

- The Pleistocene epoch spanned from 1.8 million years ago to 10,000 years ago [1]. Many genera and even species such as conifers, mosses, flowering plants, insects, mollusks, birds, and mammals from that era still survive today [1]. Others, such as the long-horned bison, saber-toothed cats, giant ground sloths, and the mammoth did not survive [1]. The woolly mammoth was commonly found during the last ice age [2]. These animals were similar in size to today’s elephants but were adapted for living in the extremely cold conditions typical of an ice age [2]....   [tags: mammoths, ice age, extinct, climate]

Strong Essays
2247 words (6.4 pages)

The Ethical Implications Of Cloning Extinct Endangered Species Essay

- Hank Greely, a Stanford professor who publicly supports de-extinction, acknowledges that there are important risks that should be taken into consideration before reviving lost species. Issues of animal welfare, health, environment, politics and morality should all be carefully deliberated on to determine that the good would outweigh the bad5. Many ethical drawbacks and arguments have been raised against the support of de-extinction alongside the arguments that many have against the process of cloning....   [tags: Extinction, Endangered species, Thylacine, Cloning]

Strong Essays
1394 words (4 pages)

Cloning Endangered Species Essay

- Fierce, magnificent, and free. On June 20, 1782 the bald eagle was unofficially declared as the representative of the United States of America. Instead of protecting the national emblem, “on July 4, 1976, the US Fish and Wildlife Service officially listed the bald eagle as a national endangered species” (History of…). The representation of the country’s freedom, strength, and beauty lies heavily on this bird; if it were to become an extinct species, what would that say for the United States. There is a very realistic and near-future solution: cloning....   [tags: extinction, extinct species, technology]

Strong Essays
1180 words (3.4 pages)

Evolution Of Extinct Species Is Ethically And Environmentally Sound Essay

- Technology in today 's age has suggested that recreating extinct species is feasible. Development in this area brings up the questions of whether or not reintroducing extinct species is ethically and environmentally sound. Human expansion and invasion destroyed the lives of many creatures, and some people believe it is their obligation to return the species back to the wild. However, their habitat is no longer what it once was. Arguments are being made to bring back species that humans have inadvertently eradicated, but the opposition has a rebuttal for every argument that can be made....   [tags: DNA, Gene, Organism, Genetics]

Strong Essays
848 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about Endangered Species: Keystone Law or Waste of Money?

- When the congress passed the Endangered Species Act (ESA) in 1973, it recognized that ecological and scientific valued our nation and its people. It also expressed concern that many of our nation’s native plants and animals were in danger of becoming extinct. The purpose of ESA is to protect and recover species in their ecosystems, for which they have lived on. Under the ESA, species are specified into two categories; endangered or threatened. ‘Endangered’ means a species that is in danger of becoming extinct and has exceeded all of its range....   [tags: Endangered Species Act, effectiveness, extinct]

Strong Essays
1408 words (4 pages)

Essay about Endangered Species

- Humans are destructive. Not a lot of us think about how what we do affects the world around us. We almost act like we are the only ones on this planet. We go around polluting and destroying our world with no regard for our actions. The things that live out in the wild are paying the price for it. Every day that passes there is another animal or plant that is placed on an endangered list. This is happening at an alarming rate. Because of man’s desire to expand and conquer their surroundings, there are animals and plants that are on the brink of extinction that will not be around for our kids and future generations to enjoy if something is not done about it now....   [tags: Biology, Extinct Species]

Strong Essays
2010 words (5.7 pages)

Role Of The Aquarium Trade As An Alternative Vector For Non Indigenous Species

- Conversely, the role of the aquarium trade as an alternative vector for the introduction of non-indigenous species is a recognised problem. In a report by Semmens et al. (2004), SCUBA sighting data from the year 1999 documented a total of 16 different non-native species around the coast of Florida. Most of these are native to the Indo-Pacific region and it was concluded that unknowing aquarium owners were to blame. While the ecological implications for these releases appear at the moment to be minimal, with the exception of the lionfish mentioned previously, it does highlight the potential for added introductions in the future....   [tags: Invasive species, Introduced species]

Strong Essays
1188 words (3.4 pages)

The Endangered Species Act Of 1973 Essay

- The Endangered Species Act of 1973 Our world is very unique. We share the world with all sorts of creatures from animals of all sizes, and shapes. Creatures that crawl, slide, run, swim, fly, or burrow. As scientists expand their knowledge about the world they unmask many types of species living on this planet. Scientist has discovered about 1.7 million species, and 13,000 more species are being found every year. It is very rare to know that there are many unknown animals, such as large birds or even mammals, but there could be million little creatures wanting to be discovered such as insects, spiders, shellfish, and even worms....   [tags: Endangered species, Extinction, Species, Hunting]

Strong Essays
2418 words (6.9 pages)

Essay on Endangered/Extinct Species

- Ecology is the study of relationships among organisms and the environment within an ecosystem. (Hoefnagles, 2012) In other words, ecology is all living things together in a specific environment, such as the plants and animals of the rainforest, and how they interact. Mankind has had many impacts on the ecosystem – rapid development, depleting natural resources, overhunting, and pollution of various kinds- all of which have resulted badly for other species within our world. There are also natural occurrences which can affect species – acid rain, natural selection, predators, disease, and asteroid/cosmic radiation....   [tags: ecology, ecosystem, environment, extinction]

Strong Essays
1354 words (3.9 pages)