The Role of a Good City Thinking: Utopia, Dystopia and Heterotopia Essay

The Role of a Good City Thinking: Utopia, Dystopia and Heterotopia Essay

Length: 2454 words (7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Good city thinking
The following essay addresses the discourse around the good city, trying to understand the importance of having a thinking on the topic rather than providing solutions for a good city.
Providing solutions for the good city pose questions such as: good for whom? what is good? etc. These questions prompt that good and city are two words that form more questions than answers. In these nebula of questions urban design plays an important role because its nature is in the urban and therefore in the city. As Madanipour points out, urban design occupies a potentially strategic place in shaping the city of the future (Madanipour, 2006).
Madanipour uses two words that are fundamental in this conversation: city and future. It is therefore important that urban design is concerned not only with the present but also with a long term thinking about cities: the future that is open-ended, even though not infinitely malleable (Friedmann, 2000).
The questions that arise are: What does thinking about the future means? How is possible to imagine something in the future? What is the role of this exercise?

City and Society
When thinking about the good city naturally every person imagines a physical condition to be improved but the physical environment is not the only force that shapes the city. For example, city and urban society cannot be detached (Lefebvre, 1970/2003). Hence the urban society is, combined with the city, an important force in urban development.
“Thus, no discussion of the good life can ignore the particularities of the urban way of life” (Amin, 2007, p.1012).
To aim for a good city therefore a good society has to be formed.

Towards a better view: Utopia and its importance
'Good society for a Good city' ...

... middle of paper ...

...temporary Nigerian novels 1" in Journal of Postcolonial Writing, Routledge, 2008, Vol. 44(4), pp. 321-332.

Boyer, M. Christine, 2008, "The many mirrors of Foucault and their architectural reflections" in Michiel Dehaene & Lieven De Cauter, Heterotopia and the city: public space in a postcivil society, Routledge, London.

Prozorov, Sergei, 2010, " Why Giorgio Agamben is an optimist" in Philosophy and Social Criticism, Vol. 39(9), 2010, Sage, University of Helsinki, Finland.

Wilkinson, Julia, 1993, "A Chinese Magistrate's Fort", in Greg Girard, Ian Lambot, City of Darkness: Life in Kowloon Walled City, 1993, Chiddingfold: Watermark.

Greg Girard, Ian Lambot, City of Darkness: Life in Kowloon Walled City, 1993, Chiddingfold: Watermark.

Kipfer, Saber, Wieditz, "Henri Lefebvre: Debates and controversies", in Progress in Human Geography, 37(1), 2013, Sage, pp. 115-134.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Utopia and Dystopia in The Future City Essay

- Throughout history man has always felt the need to envision and design ‘the future city’, whether it being one inspired by the concept of Utopia, ruled by technology or one that would go beyond the terrestrial limit of the earth. For a long time in western architecture there has been a fixed connection between utopia and architecture, in particular within the idealization of a ‘The Future City’. Its tradition to consider the Platonic discourse which treats of the idyllic city (the republic) as the first Utopia in this cultural thread....   [tags: futurism, futurology, Thomas More]

Research Papers
2580 words (7.4 pages)

Essay on The United States: A Modern Dystopia

- Content I. Introduction: 1. The two dystopias 2. Why the United States is a mix of both II. Body: 1. Announcing the War 2. Synthesizing Unity 3. Silencing Opposition 4. Dehumanizing the Enemy III. Conclusion: 1. The Hypocrisy of Modern Society In English literature, two versions of dystopia exist. The first is the one George Orwell presented in his famous novel 1984.1 It is a dystopia in which the government engages in misinformation of its citizens, where the dictator is idealized and almost worshipped....   [tags: Modern Dystopia Essays]

Research Papers
2742 words (7.8 pages)

Essay on Hong Kong as a Multicultural City

- HONG KONG AS A MULTICULTURAL CITY Whenever people mention Hong Kong in the context of where it stands on a global front, they always talk about it being a colonial city that worked its way through post colonization and successfully established itself as a world-renowned city. Or they talk about how it has recognized itself as a world-class city by excelling on the economic fore front and becoming one of the worlds leading international financial centres. However, people barely associate Hong Kong with being a multicultural city....   [tags: world class city]

Research Papers
980 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about A Dystopian City in the Movie Metropolis

- Metropolis is a film that is set in an urban dystopian city. This dystopian city clearly demonstrates a social crisis between workers and owners, thus clearly revealing the concept of capitalism. Capitalistic communities are those with an economic and political structure in which a country’s production is governed by private owners for profit, rather than by the state. Karl Marx was a theorist who fabricated the concept of capitalism. Max Weber, another theorist, also focused on this concept, but viewed capitalism from a different angle....   [tags: film analysis, social crisis]

Research Papers
1327 words (3.8 pages)

Dystopian Societies Essay

- A dystopia the darkest form of government, a utopia gone wrong, a craving for power, struggling for fewer rules. The dystopia is factual the worst possible form of a government. Its the struggle to be so perfect that it fails. There are typically two types of dystopias first a monarchy. A monarchy is a group of people controlled by a king or queen, and they make every last decision. What they want they get. A monarchy is typically born like this example from lord of the flies. “He became absorbed beyond mere happiness as he felt himself exercising control over living things....   [tags: Dystopia Essays]

Research Papers
875 words (2.5 pages)

The Horror of Dystopia Revealed by Neuromancer Essay

- The Horror of Dystopia Revealed by Neuromancer When William Gibson's futuristic novel Neuromancer  was first published, it seemed farfetched that technology could reach the level of sophistication he described. Science fiction movies have since repeated and expanded upon this theme, portraying corporate anxieties and paranoid fears of people to be controlled by aliens, man-made machines and artificial intelligence. Neuromancer takes us into the subculture of cyberpunk, a dystopia of an amoral society ruled by abstract powers....   [tags: Neuromancer Essays]

Research Papers
1583 words (4.5 pages)

Characters of Dark City Essay

- Characters of Dark City                          I did my book report on Dark City by Frank Lauria.  The main characters in the book were John Murdoch, Mr. Hand, and Mr. Book.  Since Murdoch woke up in the icy bathtub in a strange room, he has been suspicious of everything. He is wanted for a series of brutal murders which he can’t remember committing.  He later finds out that he posses a power called tuning, which allows you to stop time and alter peoples perceptions.  Sort of like brain manipulation.  He soon finds out that he is being pursued by an alien race who call themselves the Strangers.  They want him because he is immune to their brain manipulation, so he is a threat...   [tags: Dark City]

Free Essays
781 words (2.2 pages)

The Tomorrow City by Monica Hughes Essays

- The Tomorrow City by Monica Hughes The plot of this book centres around two adolescents, David and Caro and an evil supercomputer which aspires to control the futuristic city of Thompsonville.  Dr. Henderson, Caro's Father creates the "perfect" computer designed to solve all of the problems of Thompsonville by gaining almost complete power of the city.  The computer then begins to make rash decisions of it's own. It decides that humans are incapable of making decisions of there own and soon devises a method of controlling the minds of everyone in the city....   [tags: Hughes Tomorrow City]

Free Essays
574 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Materialistic Dystopia

- Max Barry's Jennifer Government and William Gibson's Neuromancer each depict a dystopian image of the world. In both novels, greed and consumerism become the vice that plagues humanity. Materialism is no longer abstract, but a way of life in these alternate realities. Corporations maintain control over the products they sell as well as the individuals they solicit to. Characters in each novel become victims of corporate tyrants when production precedes compassion. Jennifer Government and Neuromancer portray mass consumerism and human exploitation resulting in a societal dystopia....   [tags: Comparative, Literary Analysis, Barry, Gibson]

Research Papers
1702 words (4.9 pages)

Savage Contradiction in Heterotopia Essay

- Savage Contradiction in Heterotopia During the 1930's, the myth of "the people" was born. This myth stressed the importance of unity, and glorified the notion of "average," as evidenced in a prize-winning essay describing "the typical American boy," written by an eighth grader named Alfred Roberts, Jr., for a contest sponsored by the 1939-40 Fair New York World's Fair. This document, which claims that a typical American boy should be courageous, dependable, and loyal to his beliefs, was "clearly reflective of the values the Fair held dear" (Susman, 1980, p....   [tags: Culture Cultural Essays]

Free Essays
896 words (2.6 pages)