Essay The Rise Of Museum Culture

Essay The Rise Of Museum Culture

Length: 1266 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The rise of museum culture in the 19th century was paralleled by an increased interest in the discipline of anthropology, and more specifically ethnology. Two individuals in particular - Augustus Pitt-Rivers from England and the German-born Franz Boas, who worked in the United States for the latter part of his career - had differing, sometimes even opposing views on how to approach the anthropological study of artifacts in the museum. In England, Pitt-Rivers adopted the concept of cultural evolution and created decontextualized artifact displays which supported this concept. Boas, on the contrary, rejected the cultural evolutionary theory and looked to show how “primitive” cultures were shaped by their environment. Their attempts to effectively display the progression of human civilizations differ in that Pitt-Rivers utilized a typological and functional approach to anthropology in the museum, while Boas used a more holistic and contextual method in how he studied and arranged the ethnographic artifacts.
In his approach to studying ethnographic artifacts, Pitt-Rivers was heavily influenced by the concept of cultural evolution. Inspired by the work of Charles Darwin, Pitt-Rivers believed that human civilizations evolved in different stages, and that the contemporary “primitive” cultures, like the Native American tribes in North America, were like windows into the ancient past of modern-day Western nations. As such, he thought that the technologies produced by the “savages”, as he would refer to tribal peoples, were examples of artifacts which fit into certain stages of evolution of that specific object. Older objects then served as evidence of cultural evolution when they were shown to be “simpler” than more modern specimens.
T...


... middle of paper ...


...e of Pitt-Rivers is in fact still grounded in the Boasian ideal of contextualized arrangements.
Both Pitt-Rivers and Boas believed their approach to anthropology in the museum to be the most effective, and each presents a convincing approach. Pitt-Rivers claims to present the development and evolution of particular ideas as they moved from people to people, shown in his typological sequence arrangements. These displays decontextualize the objects and allow for them to be compared easily to similar objects from other civilizations and across time periods. Boas on the other hand attempted to create dioramas in which objects were displayed in a contextualized tribal setting, emphasizing that the object is the result of its own history. Yet while both approaches were strong in their philosophical intent, both had shortcomings in their end result inside the museum itself.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Centre Pompidou: Museum Architectural Design Essay

- At the advent of Museum Construction, it was as if these structures were being filled almost religiously to educate individuals on art. These pieces of art were filling palaces, homes, and other public structures to educate individuals on the wealth of the beneficiaries as well as the theme of the art that the walls would contain. Since that time, museum architectural deigns and the art held within the structures have changed very drastically. There has been a large shift recently in the museum community with individuals coming to art museums not out of their drive to be educated and enlightened, but rather to be entertained....   [tags: architecture, museum model, visitors]

Better Essays
1297 words (3.7 pages)

History of the Museum Essay

- From as early as the 3rd century bc, there have been examples of museum concepts. Ptolomy Soter, known as “The Preserver”, founded the great Museon at Alexandria. After six centuries, it was destroyed, ending centuries of intellectual research and collected statues. In ancient Greece, temples of objects, including the Parthenon and the Acropolis housed cult statues in cellas, rooms dedicated to this purpose. A keeper, similarly to a curator, would oversee the temple activities. In addition, an early example of conservation is documented by the placement of oil vats by ivory statues to prevent drying out and cracking....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
885 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Canadian Culture

- Canadian Culture Canada is one of two countries located in North America and is the second largest country in the world. It is situated just north of the United States and constitutes the northern part of the country, excluding Alaska. Over the years Canada's culture has been influenced by European culture and traditions, mainly that of the French and British. Canadian culture has also been influenced by the countries' first people, the Aboriginals, as well as the newer immigrated population (Wikipedia, 2007)....   [tags: Culture Anthropology Canada Canadian]

Better Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about The Art And Culture Of The Roman Civilization

- When entering the Eaton gallery of Rome at the Royal Ontario museum, it is clear that the presentations of the ancient Rome discoveries are diverse from decorative artefacts to sculptures indicating the rich cultures and influences of that era. The ancient Rome flourished from 900 BC to AD 476. This gallery highlights the ancient civilization of the Mediterranean world that extends as far a Britain and Ireland to north and south Roman Egypt. The ROM has collaborated with the Government of Canada for the exhibit based on the legacy of the Roman Empire....   [tags: Ancient Rome, Roman Empire, Roman Republic]

Better Essays
989 words (2.8 pages)

Ainu: The Disappearing Culture Essay examples

- Uncontacted tribes and small-scale societies are becoming a thing of the past. The world is rapidly growing and small-societies going against the grain are being pushed aside by people, claiming their presence inhibits progress. With more than seven billion people inhabiting this planet, space is becoming more valuable and the outsiders are being forced to endure the regions that no one else desires. Eventually, societies mix, borders are blurred, and another unique society/culture is lost within the masses....   [tags: Japan, small-scale societies]

Better Essays
1400 words (4 pages)

Challenging Competence: Quality for this Century Essays

- “The adventure of modern art is over. Contemporary art is only contemporary of itself… Nothing differentiates it from technical, advertising, media and digital operations. There is no more transcendence, no more divergence, nothing from another scene…”(Baudrillard, 89.) ________________________________________________________________________ The apples from the last tree standing in the orchard of the art world have grown toxic with the sewage of the art market landfill in which it is planted. High art at the dawn of the 21st century is confined, controlled and contrived by the fiscal pursuits inherent in free marketeering....   [tags: Culture ]

Better Essays
2525 words (7.2 pages)

Essay about Over Done Imagery During The Counter-Culture Movement

- Psychedelic posters were not the first time that the world was fascinated by unintentional artwork. Earlier, during the nineteenth century the world was swept up by posters plastered across cities that advertising everything from magical remedies to bicycle bells. The posters created by Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec transported even the most poverty-stricken folk to faraway places, but as the belle époque gave way to a much harsher reality that would become littered with wars and social unrest, the beautiful poster eventually become a forgotten art....   [tags: psychedelic posters, hippie]

Better Essays
1804 words (5.2 pages)

“The Rise and Fall of the Ancient Library at Alexandria” Essay

- The ancient Library of Alexandria is acknowledged as the capital of education in the ancient world, the vanished library was not the initial library in the world; however, it stands out because of its legacy. It lasted over six centuries, and was the globe’s first research center. Her founders were Alexander the Great and Ptolemy II Soter, but it was organized by Aristotle’s student Demetrius of Phaleron. The library was abundance with books and scholars from all over the world. Even though the library was confuted and damaged, there are some pieces that have survived like Letter of Aristeas that where possibly a translation of the Hebrew Bible....   [tags: Ancient Greece ]

Better Essays
1521 words (4.3 pages)

Exploring The Natural History Museum Essay

- The Natural History Museum is extraordinary place to explore and learn. It’s fun and breathtaking. The museum served as an agricultural fairground from 1872 until 1910. The original structure of the building from the 1913 and today’s structure are combined with a blend of many styles. Like a Spanish Renaissance ornamentation in the terracotta trimmings. There is a Romanesque style in the arched windows and the brick walls. The Beaux-Arts tradition is a T-shape floor plan. The building measures 75 feet in diameter with three wings....   [tags: Museum]

Better Essays
2048 words (5.9 pages)

Essay about Oriental Institute Museum

- I had an opportunity to visit the oriental institute museum . During my visit to the museum I was made aware of its location and the importance of it to chicago. The museum housed many exhibits of historical value dating civilization back to the paleolithic period of 2,500,000-100,000 B.C. Below you'll find examples of mans rise through the use of tools and refined skills from cave living to structured living throughout evolution. This is an experience that has grounded me to a new interest in structures that we have devised to become the homes we use today for the rest of my life....   [tags: Museum]

Better Essays
994 words (2.8 pages)