As Socrates states, those who practice justice do it unwillingly and because they don’t have the resources it takes to do so otherwise. The traditional story in accordance to this belief is of Gyges, who was the ancestor of Croesus the Lydian. Gyges was the shepherd who worked for the king of Lydia, one night a huge thunderstorm had struck , and the earthquake had created a opening in the earth. Gyges walked towards the opening, where amongst many things he found a dead body of stature, who had nothing on but a gold ring; which he decided to take with him. Shepherds were all getting together with the king to discuss the monthly report, when Gyges came into their assembly with a ring on. After experimenting with it, he realized that when you turned the ring inside his hand, he instantly became invisible to others, and when he turned the ring ou...
... middle of paper ...
...ve the reputation of being injust, who would barely ever commit injustice in these circumstances. These type of individuals would rarely ever go to the extreme of raping or killing another individual. Nonetheless, they might be he ones to steal food here and there, if the individual and his family were starving and had no means of being able to buy the necessities. Thus, it doesn’t qualify as following the same path as Glaucon states the just and unjust do take. It’s not possible to think an individual could possibly act unjust to the necessity, or actuality, of it. It’s not sound to differentiate between the ‘can’ and ‘will’. Even if Glaucon was able to come to the conclusion that human nature is valid, there still isn’t any necessity that would make a just person act as unjust as the most unjust one would.
Even though our necessity, and will to commit unjust acts
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- When relating Plato’s “Ring of Gyges” to the culture that we live in now, he explains that persons are selfish and egoistic. The reason is that people do not always do the unfair things because they fear of being caught and harmed. As a human being, everything we do is coherent. When it comes to Cultural relativism, it is our beliefs, customs, and ethical virtue that relate to our social context. The main purpose is that most people do the right or wrong things that affects the society. The story explains the meaning behind what Glaucon is saying about his culture and what he had to go through and it contradicts his egoism.... [tags: Morality, Ethics, Individualism, Justice]
1356 words (3.9 pages)
- Justice and knowledge are not easily explained; however, Plato, uses thought experiments to capture vivid images of what the two words actually mean. The Ring of Gyges and the Allegory of the Cave both enlighten the hazy ideas of the true meaning behind knowledge and justice. These readings stretch made me stretch my brain and think about things that have never crossed my mind before. Plato is a wonderful philosopher that explains things vividly so that his readers can fully understand the meaning and his view.... [tags: Plato, Philosophy, Ring of Gyges, The Prisoner]
1717 words (4.9 pages)
- An Exploration of Plato’s Story: “The Ring of Gyges” Plato, a classical Greek philosopher and mathematician, had a way of persuading and explaining his theoretical beliefs by creating stories that demonstrated his point. The allegory of “The Ring of Gyges” appears in the second book in Plato’s The Republic as a means to prove that being moral is in our long-term interest, because it is the only way to be truly happy. In Plato’s book, the character Glaucon tells the story of a Sheppard, Gyges, who comes across a ring one summer, while watching over his sheep as they grazed in the mountains.... [tags: Ethics, Virtue, Plato, Justice]
1620 words (4.6 pages)
- In order to observe justice completely, Glaucon and Adeimantus challenge Socrates by saying it is better to be unjust than just. To defend himself, Socrates explains that they must look at justice in a city before they can understand justice in man. By defending justice, Socrates constructs an imaginary city, which internally happens to be a parallel to the tripartite soul, to gain a better understanding of justice as a whole. Although Glaucon does not agree with Thrasymachus’ idea that being unjust is more advantageous than being just, he sides with this argument for Socrates to be able to come to a conclusion in the face of an opposition.... [tags: Plato, Soul, Philosophy, Socrates]
1069 words (3.1 pages)
- Susan Wolf presents two different versions of the Moral Saint in order to show that a perfectly moral person does not live a desirable life. A saint is someone who lives a perfectly moral life according to a given ethical system, and “a necessary condition of moral sainthood would be that one’s life be dominated by a commitment to improving the welfare of others or of society as a whole” (Wolf). Is a Moral Saintliness even a humanly possible. Susan Wolf’s description of a Moral Saint is virtually a fictional being.... [tags: ring of gyges, moral life, saints]
1044 words (3 pages)
- In The Republic Plato constructs his argument through an analogy between a city and the soul on what justice means to him. The two main questions that drive the dialogue between philosophers are, “What is justice?” and “Is justice preferable to injustice?” Plato’s thesis of The Republic is that justice is about one’s inner harmony with the tripartite of the soul and this is seen through his analogy of the city. Instead of allowing equal value to each virtue, Plato makes the virtue of wisdom the most important, causing people who possess the other virtues seem less valuable.... [tags: Virtue, Plato, Justice, Ethics]
990 words (2.8 pages)
- In Plato’s Republic, the main argument is dedicated to answering Glaucon and Adeimantus, who question the reason for just behavior. They argue it is against one’s self-interest to be just, but Plato believes the behavior is in fact in one’s self-interest because justice is inherently good. Plato tries to prove this through his depiction of an ideal city, which he builds from the ground up, and ultimately concludes that justice requires the philosopher to perform the task of ruling. Since the overall argument is that justice pays, it follows that it would be in the philosopher’s self-interest to rule – however, Plato also states that whenever people with political power believe they benefit f... [tags: Plato, Justice, Philosophy, Political philosophy]
1440 words (4.1 pages)
- The question asked is using Plato’s theory of human nature, knowledge and political order explain and evaluate the answer to this question: Why is being just good for me. Before I can answer the question posed I have to answer a sub question what is being just even mean. To us in modern times being a just person means if I hit a parked car I leave my insurance and contact information or I see a person who is in need of something and I help them well if someone’s watching you. In my opinion all being just means today is nothing more than doing the right thing when a camera is pointed in your direction, when someone is watching you, when you can benefit from it or you can tweet or post it on F... [tags: Plato, Soul, Virtue, Morality]
872 words (2.5 pages)
- Both Plato’s Republic and Aristotle’s Politics deal with the issue of justice. In both of these pieces of writings, the authors are trying to determine what is the perfect city, and how justice plays a role in the city, and in turn how justice is present in both society and individuals. While some similarities may be present between Aristotle and Socrates’s thinking, they approach the situation completely differently. Socrates first builds what would be a perfect city to him. He then examines what makes the city perfect and relates it to the individual.... [tags: Soul, Plato, Same-sex marriage, Socrates]
1647 words (4.7 pages)
- Plato The first degree of belief are physical objects, as the second degree of belief are shadows and images of the physical objects. In the last book, Plato criticizes poetry and the fine arts. Plato feels that art is merely the imitation of the imitation of reality, and that poetry corrupts the soul. Socrates says that artists merely create things. As an example, if a painter draws a couch on his canvas, he is creating a couch. But the couch he creates is not the real couch, it is nothing but a copy of an ordinary, physical couch which was created by a craftsman.... [tags: Philosophy Philosophers Essays]
1643 words (4.7 pages)