The Rights of Those Who Practice Polygamy
The unblemished notion of what the American family should be has been deeply rooted in our culture and it was not until recently that those views have been challenged. Same-Sex marriage is a topic of interest and has been one for the past several years. With many victories under the proponent’s belt it seems that the United Sates is heading toward national recognition. Same-Sex marriage is paving the way for other non-traditional families to gain footing and rights in the American legal system. One example of this is plural marriage families such as polygamous families, where a husband has more than one wife or polyandry families where a wife has more than one husband.
Recently there have been several websites, interest groups, and television mini-series examining the merits of polygamy. For example, an attorney, Elizabeth Joseph, wrote an opinion piece in the New York Times describing her own polygamous marriage. She claims that polygamy offers women a realistic answer for “successfully juggling career, motherhood, and marriage.” Home Box Office (HBO) in 2007 produced a television series entitled Big Love, that sympathetically depicts a fictional middle-class polygamist family, consisting of a husband and his three wives, who live in Salt Lake City. With the modern approach towards acceptance of broader family diversity the arguments against polygamous marriages are no longer effective, thus the practice should no longer be illegal. Section II of this article will go through the historical development and background of polygamy. Section III will discuss the constitutionality of polygamy and the arguments that support its legalization which are: fir...
... middle of paper ...
In 1878 the court upheld the criminalization of polygamy against the argument that it violated the First Amendment by punishing religious conduct. The court in that case reasoned that there was a difference between belief and act. The First Amendment allowed for a person to believe as they wished but they could not act on the beliefs if that action would be “in violation of social duties or subversive of good order.” The court concluded that polygamy was plainly offensive to good order:
Polygamy has always been odious among the northern and western nations of Europe, and, until the establishment of the Mormon Church, was almost exclusively a feature of the Life of Asiatic and African people. At common law, the second marriage was always void, and from the earliest history of England polygamy has been treated as an offense against society.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Introduction This essay analyzes the gender inequality, human rights, and legal context of polygamy. This essay examines Canada’s law that prohibits polygamy and assess why polygamy in not considered a religious right. Additionally, the harms and inequality of women in polygamous relationships will be discoursed, with a review of Canada’s obligation to the International Women’s Convention. Lastly, the negative psychological, health and educational impacts on children being brought up in polygamous families will be examined.... [tags: Outlawed, Women]
1816 words (5.2 pages)
- Polygamy is an ongoing controversy both in Canada and around the world. Polygamy is referred to as a form of marriage or social practice in which a male individual has more than one spouse or wife (Campbell, 2005). The act of polygamy is illegal and against the law in many countries, though this marriage structure still rarely occurs in some societies or families. Worldwide, the cultures and societies that have accommodated the act of polygamy are well aware that emotional, societal, economic, and physical factors are inflicted upon the well-being of women along with their families.... [tags: International Law, religion, canadian studies, ma]
2594 words (7.4 pages)
- Polygamy is defined as “a marriage that includes more than two partners.” There are different types of polygamy, these include: polygyny, where a man has multiple wives, polyandry, in which a woman has multiple husbands, and group marriage, where a family consists of multiple husbands and wives. Of these different types of polygamy, polygyny is definitely the most popular of the three. In America, the practice of any form of polygamy is illegal and due to this law, many adherents of the lifestyle stay hidden ("What is Polygamy?").... [tags: Marital Issues]
1486 words (4.2 pages)
- The topic has a close connection to the Humanities and Social Sciences field as it raises an issue of women’s marginalization and oppression being a part of polygamy implementation in society. In contemporary world when the women rights movements and feminism ideology play a prominent role in the international community, polygamy and its effects on women cannot remain unnoticed. Functioning on a base of religious beliefs, culture or traditions, polygamy in many communities is considered as an inevitable part of people’s lives.... [tags: humanity, social science]
1884 words (5.4 pages)
- In the Middle East, women’s roles in society have been confused with the different interpretations of the Qur’an and different influences the regions have had from pre-Islamic times until the 21st century. Women’s roles in marriage in the Qur’an is equal and loving but has been twisted and altered due to different interpretations of what marriage means in the regions. Tunisia is a significant country in the Middle Eastern region as far as women’s rights go. It is important to distinguish what “women’s rights” means in the Middle East versus what the Western world perceives, and often times expects, of those societies.... [tags: Islamic Influence, Polygamy]
1390 words (4 pages)
- On June 26th of this year, a historic ruling was made in the Supreme Court of the United States that would grant constitutional rights to same-sex marriages. Supreme Court Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, one of the authors of the historic ruling, was quoted in his reaction to the voting; “No union is more profound than marriage, for it embodies the highest ideals of love, fidelity, devotion, sacrifice, and family. Their hope is not to be condemned to live in loneliness, excluded from one of civilization’s oldest institutions.... [tags: Marriage, Polygamy, Polygyny, Same-sex marriage]
1090 words (3.1 pages)
- What do you think about a marriage system called polygamy. Polygamy is the meaning will be “often married”. A man can marry as many women as he wants. Do you agree if your boyfriend or husband has other girlfriend or wife. Most women think polygamy is absolute nonsense and insincere sentiment, and some men think so too. On the other hand, some men think it sounds too good to be true because they can have an affair and cheating in state. Saudi Arabia, Myanmar and Bali agree polygamy. In this circumstance, there are many Muslim people in these countries, and polygamy is not a serious matter under the doctrine of Muslim.... [tags: Marriage, Polygamy, Family, Gender]
1845 words (5.3 pages)
- Safa Rigby is a Muslim woman who found out that her husband of 14 years had married two other women in Toronto while she was out of the country. Being Muslim does not mean that Safa Rigby practiced polygamy. In this case, the issue is that her husband married other women without her consent, resulting in a decline in her health . The Imam, religious scholar, that conducted the marriage ceremony is known to have conducted over 20 polygamous marriages. Despite this knowledge, no action has been taken against him even though polygamy is illegal and he was aware of that when he conducted the marriage ceremonies .... [tags: Polygamy, Marriage, Polygyny, Family]
2125 words (6.1 pages)
- The article Breaking the Cycle Mother, Daughter Find It Can Be Difficult to Leave Polygamy behind Polygamy: It 's Tough to Break the Cycle by Joan O 'Brien is about a mother’s experience leaving a polygamous marriage. This mother, Betsy Barlow of Salt Lake City also inspired her daughter, Ellen to do the same thing. It is explained that Mrs. Barlow felt that being a part of a polygamous marriage was defeating for women and herself. O’Brien states, “Barlow believes that in practice, polygamy ``suppresses ' ' women”.... [tags: Marriage, Family, Polygamy, Wife]
802 words (2.3 pages)
- "I never wanted to just be married to a man," "I always wanted sister wives," says Christine, star in the hit television show “Sister Wives” who is pregnant with Kody's-her polygamous husband- 13th child (Hall, 2010). She's glad to be his third wife because she never wanted to be alone with a husband and the third wife balances out the tension between the first two. she says.The first sighting of Polygamy began during the biblical era where Lamech cleaved to two wives, Adah and Zillah. Today, Polygamy is considered a poor representation of Christianity as the lord said “It is not good that man should be alone; I will make him a helper comparable to him.” Sparking the argument that the lord a... [tags: christianity, bible, polygamy, morality]
1163 words (3.3 pages)