Rhetorical and Fallacies in the Article “The Media Violence Myth” by Richard Rhodes

Rhetorical and Fallacies in the Article “The Media Violence Myth” by Richard Rhodes

Length: 1504 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In 2000, Pulitzer-winning journalist Richard Rhodes published an article titled “The Media Violence Myth,” through the “American Booksellers Foundation for Free Expression,” a liberal establishment dedicated to the protection of the First Amendment right to free speech. Despite coming from a background plagued with violence and abuse, Rhodes has studied nuclear history and weapons use for over 20 years and has developed a unique opinion about the media’s effect on public violence. In “The Media Violence Myth,” Rhodes aims to convince his readers that the media does not contribute to violence through its portrayal. He attempts this in discrediting his key opponent, Dave Grossman, through ad hominem, red herrings, and violent diction. These strategies are likely effective for his left-leaning, first amendment-protecting primary audience, which would get caught up in the emotion of the arguments. However, for the more skeptical, moderate audience, these rhetorical devices are likely inefficient.
Rhodes uses the ethical fallacy “ad hominem” in attempt to quickly discredit Grossman, his key antagonist, and therefore boost his own credibility. For example, he describes Grossman in the very first sentence of his article as looking “a little goofy in a bad suit,” while later praising his supporter, David Sohn, as “a bold, savvy psychologist.” It is clear that in employing this tactic Rhodes is attempting to decrease Grossman’s credibility; in placing this judgment in the first sentence of the essay he is trying to make a vivid first impression, one that will stay with his readers through the last page. The image of an ill-dressed man causes the audience to cast negative judgments that will taint anything the subject has to say. On the o...


... middle of paper ...


...g, war-fearing primary audience.
Rhodes’ use of ad hominem, red herrings, and violent diction in attempt to convince his readers that the media does not contribute to violence is likely effective to the primary audience through evoking compelling emotions and detracting from Grossman’s authority; however, the secondary audience, which values logic over emotion, can likely see through the loaded arguments, making them ineffective. An implication with this result is that politics largely requires an appeal to logos more than to pathos or ethos. Winning over moderates, a key aspect of securing an election or passing a ballot measure, necessitates a primarily sophistic approach. If one were looking to be persuaded either way regarding an issue, it would be in his or her best interest to not waste time with Rhodes, but rather move on to more experienced rhetoricists.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Logical Fallacies Of An Argument Essay

- Logical Fallacies of an Argument Logical fallacies are the most common argument a writer may encounter to attack the opposition intelligence and its understanding. Logical fallacies can be argued on internet and off internet. A logical fallacy can be defined as a type of argument that has a good reason, but is recognized as bad. Sometimes, finding logical fallacy in an argument does not mean it is untrue. Logical fallacy can be formal and informal. Formal fallacy is an invalid argument because people can persuade by the conclusion....   [tags: Fallacy, Argument, Logical fallacies]

Powerful Essays
1442 words (4.1 pages)

John Livingstone Seagull By Richard Bach And The Myth Of The Cave Essay

- A young seagull who loves to fly is banished from his flock, but after mastering flight, returns to share these new discoveries with his old flock. A man kept imprisoned in a dark cave is introduced to the outside world, and later returns to the cave to tell his fellow prisoners about it. On the surface, both Jonathan Livingstone Seagull by Richard Bach and “The Myth of the Cave” by Plato have almost childishly simple plots. In both, a character leaves his home, learns something, and returns. However, these stories gain a deeper significance when the reader views them as allegories....   [tags: Jonathan Livingston Seagull, Richard Bach]

Powerful Essays
1094 words (3.1 pages)

Informal Fallacies Of An Informal Fallacy Essay

- During the first week of class we discussed informal fallacies. An informal fallacy is defined as a logical mistake. Five of the informal fallacies discussed were equivocation, ad hominem, straw man, appeal to authority, and secundum. Each of these fallacies are comparable to what happens in everyday life conversations. Through analyzing, one should be able to determine how these fallacies connect with our everyday lives. Equivocation is a fallacy known for having two meanings of an ambiguous word over a course of an argument....   [tags: Fallacy, Logical fallacies, Ad hominem, Straw man]

Powerful Essays
820 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Informal Fallacies Of An Informal Fallacy

- During the first week of class, we discussed informal fallacies. An informal fallacy is defined as a logical mistake. Five of the informal fallacies discussed were equivocation, ad hominem, straw man, appeal to authority, and secundum. Each of these fallacies is comparable to what happens in everyday life conversations. Through analyzing, one should be able to determine how these logical mistakes connect with our everyday lives. Equivocation is a fallacy known for having two meanings of an ambiguous word over the course of an argument....   [tags: Fallacy, Logical fallacies, Ad hominem, Straw man]

Powerful Essays
824 words (2.4 pages)

The Rhetorical Appeals And Fallacies By Mortimer J. Adler 's Article Analysis

- In Mortimer J. Adler’s article “How to Mark A book,” he argues that you should mark up your book to note significant information. Mortimer argues, through the rhetorical appeals and fallacies, that as you write in a book it becomes “absorbed in your bloodstream,” and allows you to fully own the book. As readers searching for these techniques we can become, in a way, immune to the fallacies and observe the argument for what it truly is. This article, however,has relatively few fallacies. "How to Mark A book," uses all of the rhetorical appeals (ethos, logos, pathos) to convince you the reader to mark up your book....   [tags: Rhetoric, Logic, Argument, Mortimer J. Adler]

Powerful Essays
724 words (2.1 pages)

Use of Myth in Watership Down by Richard Adams Essay

- As you grow up, you have always been told stories to either scare you into not doing something, like if you don’t go to bed, the boogeyman will come and get you; or stories that give you hope, inspire you, make you dream, or help you to the next step in your life. You’ve heard these stories from your parents, your grandparents, your aunts and uncles; you’ve practically heard a story from everybody in your family down to the old lady who lives down the street. People just want you to learn from their mistakes or to let you know that things will always work out....   [tags: Richard Adams]

Free Essays
1613 words (4.6 pages)

Fallacies In Advertising Essay

- Fallacies in Advertising According to Bassham et al. (2002), a logical fallacy is “an argument that contains a mistake in reasoning” (p. 140). There are two types of logical fallacies, fallacies of relevance, and fallacies of insufficient evidence. Fallacies of relevance happen when the premises are not logically relevant to the conclusion. Fallacies of insufficient evidence occur when the premises do not provide sufficient evidence to support the conclusion. Though there are several logical fallacies, four logical fallacies commonly found in advertising are amphiboly, appeal to authority, appeal to emotion, and non sequitur....   [tags: Marketing Advertising Fallacies]

Free Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)

Fallacies And Assumptions Essay

- Fallacies and Assumptions People around the world encounter logical fallacies on almost a daily basis. This paper will look at three common logical fallacies. I will define each of the three fallacies, explain its significance to Critical Thinking, and discuss its general application to Decision Making. I will also show organizational examples that illustrate each one of my chosen fallacies. Fallacies and Assumptions Encyclopaedia Britannica (2006) defines a fallacy in logic as "erroneous reasoning that has the appearance of soundness." Generally, when we think about making decisions, most people believe that they are making logical decisions....   [tags: Logical Fallacies Misconceptions Human Nature Stud]

Free Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

Use of Rhetorical Appeals and Diction in Richard Wright’s Autobiographical Work, Black Boy

- Use of Rhetorical Appeals and Diction in Richard Wright’s Autobiographical Work, Black Boy In his autobiographical work, Black Boy, Richard Wright wrote about his battles with hunger, abuse, and racism in the south during the early 1900's. Wright was a gifted author with a passion for writing that refused to be squelched, even when he was a young boy. To convey his attitude toward the importance of language as a key to identity and social acceptance, Wright used rhetorical techniques such as rhetorical appeals and diction....   [tags: Richard Wright’s Black Boy]

Powerful Essays
535 words (1.5 pages)

Fallacies Essay

- Fallacies are all around us. Every time we turn on a TV, or a radio, or pick up a newspaper, we see or hear fallacies. According to Dictionary.com, a fallacy is defined as a false notion, a statement or an argument based on a false or invalid inference, incorrectness of reasoning or belief; erroneousness, or the quality of being deceptive (www.Dictionary.com). Fallacies are part of everyday and become a staple in certain aspects of life. Political campaigns and reporters would be lost without the use of fallacies....   [tags: Literature Literary Fallacies]

Free Essays
1581 words (4.5 pages)