Rhetorical Analysis Of. Eliot 's ' The Metaphysical Poets ' Essay

Rhetorical Analysis Of. Eliot 's ' The Metaphysical Poets ' Essay

Length: 2437 words (7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

T.S. Eliot, in his The Metaphysical Poets, claims that it is a pity the poets since the seventeenth century have experienced a “dissociation of sensibility”, from which they have never recovered (Eliot 64). For Eliot, poetry is a union of opposites, the reconciliation of which needs a unified sensibility. By this sensibility, a poet can amalgamate desperate experiences, fuse into a single whole the varied and disparate, and synthesize the sensuous and the intellectual. This synthesis thus enables poetry to be widely read because humans are mentally chaotic. However, poets since the seventeenth century can either feel or think, and this poetic degradation to more elevated language but cruder emotions shackles the development of the modern poetry.
Eliot applauds John Donne, stating that “a thought to Donne was an experience; it modified his sensibility” (Eliot 64). This appreciation of the precursor from a belated poet, however, is described as an “over-idealized imagination” by Harold Bloom (9). Bloom believes that the relationship between precursors and ephebes is in fact, in the Freudian term, a “family romance”, in which the strong son/ephebe should try to overcome the influence imposed by the father/precursor in a fight to the death (Bloom 27). Readers can indeed notice some intended deviations from Donne in Eliot’s poems, but it is hard to tell whether or not these deviations result from the anxiety due to Donne’s influence. Eliot’s apostasy from Donne can only demonstrate his dissatisfaction or disagreement with part of Donne’s ideology, but Donne’s influence at the same time is welcomed by Eliot, serving as a source of Eliot’s own literary sensibility and as representation of Eliot’s own poetic intelligence.
Bloom’s argument...


... middle of paper ...


...ence: if Eliot disagrees with Donne on the ideology, there should be no repression from Donne and thus no anxiety. Donne’s success makes Eliot lose nothing because they have already been in different realms of believing. The anxiety is from influence, but not non-influence.
Donne’s influence on Eliot is constructive rather than destructive; it has nothing to do with repression but instead a stage for Eliot’s creation. Eliot, through his imitation of Donne, gets keen sensibility and a sense of maturity, and his deviation is the result of disagreement or dissatisfaction rather than anxiety of influence. Bloom says ephebes regain their solipsism through revisionary ratios, but Eliot never loses his independence of writing. Eliot is of great poetic intelligence, and fortunately he also has a wonderful teacher. To him, the influence is not anxiety, but invaluable treasury.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Metaphysical Poetry By John Donne

- While metaphysical poetry consists of a specific style with expected patterns, different poets emphasize different aspects of as much, choosing to highlight the importance of the conceit, the intermingling of the spiritual and the physical, the need for meditation, and so on. For example, John Donne tends to worry himself with metaphysical conceits to the ends of the universe and back, overdeveloping extended metaphors to the point where the specific object that another is being compared to is referred to in every line....   [tags: Metaphysical poets, John Donne, T. S. Eliot]

Better Essays
1213 words (3.5 pages)

Metaphysical Poetry in The Seventeenth Century Essay

- Metaphysical wit and conceit are two of the most famous literary devices used in the seventeenth century by poets such as John Donne. Emerging out of the Petrarchan era, metaphysical poetry brought a whole new way of expression and imagery dealing with emotional, physical and spiritual issues of that time. In this essay I will critically analyse the poem, The Flea written by John Donne in which he makes light of his sexual intentions with his lover. In the first stanza of the poem, Donne tries to convince his lover to have sexual intercourse with him....   [tags: Poetry Analysis, John Donne, Poets]

Better Essays
885 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about John Donne And George Herbert

- John Donne and George Herbert: the Metaphysical Brothers of Poetry Although not an official or formal school of poetry Metaphysical Poetry is widely present in 17th century English poetry. According to the Norton Anthology of English Literature, English poets such as Herbert, Vaughan, Crashaw, Marvell, Traherne, and Cowley can all be attributed as Metaphysical poets (1262). Coined by critics such as Samuel Johnson and William Hazlitt, Metaphysical poetry contains complex conceits and self-conscious leaning (1262)....   [tags: Metaphysical poets, John Donne, T. S. Eliot]

Better Essays
1294 words (3.7 pages)

Techniques Used in the Writing of Metaphysical Poetry Essay

- The ideas and techniques of the metaphysical poets were much different from those of some of the earlier poets we have read. This type of poetry was established in the early 17th century England. In metaphysical poetry, an obvious use of sex and sexual innuendos is prevalent, as opposed to earlier times when it was rarely even mentioned. It also was a more realistic variety of poetry and was much less fairytale or fantasy. Another technique of metaphysical poetry was the constant use of intellect and metaphors....   [tags: Jonathan Swift, John Gay, Poets]

Better Essays
595 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Death Presented in Metaphysical Poetry

- Death Presented in Metaphysical Poetry Death is presented in metaphysical poetry in a number of different ways. However, from the glorified object of desire in Henry Vaughan’s ‘They are all gone into the world of light’ to the way in which John Donne mocks the personified death in ‘Death be not proud’, there are also a lot of common points which are made. The historical context of the pieces is clearly an influential factor. With all the changes happening during the 16th and 17th centuries (the time in which most metaphysical poetry was being written) the only thing one could be certain of in life was death....   [tags: Death Metaphysical Poetry Poems Essays]

Better Essays
2392 words (6.8 pages)

The Genius Of T.S. Eliot Essay

- T.S. Eliot’s impact on poetry is unrivaled in the 20th century. Although his work was criticized because it was unlike the others of his time, his differences are seen as the beginning of what is called “modern poetry.” His distinct style was influenced from his American heritage, mental breakdown, and his readings of the Italian Renaissance, and French Symbolists. His unique views of society and literature gave him a fresh perspective, causing him to become a very influential poet and critic as he pioneered the modern poetry movement....   [tags: T.S. Eliot Poems]

Better Essays
2370 words (6.8 pages)

William Wordsworth and T.S. Eliot Essay

- William Wordsworth and T.S. Eliot are both excellent and admirable poets from different time periods that have very distinct views on what it means to be a true poet. On one hand Wordsworth strived to be unique, romantic and sentimental in a time where people needed a poet as such. On the other hand, Eliot lived in a time where romanticism and sentimentalism did not satisfy readers that needed something less elevated and more realistic. Although they had opposing views neither is right or wrong and can only speak for the poets of their specific time period, yet one should not dismiss one or the other because each of their perspectives are equally valuable when deciding what it takes to be th...   [tags: ideal poets, romantic period]

Better Essays
822 words (2.3 pages)

A Comparison of Andrew Marvell's To His Coy Mistress and John Donne's The Sunne Rising

- A Comparison of Andrew Marvell's To His Coy Mistress and John Donne's The Sunne Rising Both poems "To His Coy Mistress" and "The Sunne Rising" were written by metaphysical poets, this is one of many similarities in the poems. However, there are also a number of differences between them. In both poems, there is an obvious link to the theme of "Carpe Diem" which simply means "seize the day". The poems relate to time and that of how it's running out. They seem to be in a rush. The content of the poem is Marvell writing a poem to his love partner....   [tags: metaphysical poets]

Better Essays
1926 words (5.5 pages)

Herbert's Metaphysical Poems Essay

- Herbert's Metaphysical Poems In the first portion of The Temple, specifically Perirrhanterium, Herbert prescribes the didactics necessary for the instruction of the catechumen in a simple, straightforward manner. As the reader moves into the main section of The Church, the author’s poetic wit becomes more complex in both its style and depth of topic. Although the starkness of the messages in Herbert’s metaphysical poems is not as palpable as those of the Church Porch, their ability to teach both abstractly and visually affords them a didactic nature much like the parables of Christ....   [tags: Herbert Metaphysical Poems Essays]

Better Essays
3456 words (9.9 pages)

Essay about Biography of T.S. Eliot

- Biography of T.S. Eliot T.S. Eliot changed the face of poetry. He has been regarded as the most celebrated poet of his era. This Nobel Prize winning poet is credited with viewing the world as it appears, without making any optimistic judgements. Despite the ire of Mr. Eliot, it would be safe to regard him as a prophet of doom. His works reflected his frustration with mankind, and the seeming need to be released from this cold world. It was once said, “How unpleasant to meet Mr. Eliot.” (Time 1) His rather cynical view of man’s accomplishments leads one to regard him as a pessimist who prophesies nothing but doom for mankind....   [tags: Thomas Stearns Eliot Writers Poetry Essays]

Better Essays
4125 words (11.8 pages)