The Revolution Of The Reign Of Nicholas I Essay

The Revolution Of The Reign Of Nicholas I Essay

Length: 1607 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Astolphe de Custine, a French Marquis who visited Russia during the reign of Nicholas I observed, “Under an absolute despotism, it is the government which is revolutionary; for the word revolution signifies arbitrary system and violent power” (Custine 574). This remark was true not only for Tsarism, but also became true under the Revolutionary leadership of Lenin and then Stalin. When Tsarism ended in Russia, the people as well as the new leadership thought a new and better state would emerge. Communism was supposed to launch Russia into the future in a radical way. What actually emerged was a state very similar to the autocracy under Tsarism. Tsarism, Leninism, and Stalinism were all different theories and instances of rule but there are major similarities between them. However, there are also key differences. Although not by original intention, Stalin, and Lenin before him, was extremely similar to Tsar Nicholas I, the “Iron Tsar” with Tsarism and Communism not seeming too different to the people of Russia.
Nicholas I was the “Iron Tsar” and ruled from 1825-1855. He came to power by crushing the Decembrist Rebellion. He was a military man never meant to be Tsar because he was the youngest of his brothers. He was very intelligent but also narrow-minded, orderly, and precise. Nicholas I was not originally a total reaction. Even though he came to power after crushing a rebellion, he did not become thoroughly reactionary until after the Polish rebellion in 1830-1831. Before the Polish rebellion, he even wanted to abolish serfdom, but afterwards all liberalism stopped and oppression increased. Nicholas II’s beliefs about ruling Russia created an awkward situation for Russia in relation to the rest of Europe. Following the d...

... middle of paper ...

... against the will of the proletariat? No it cannot and must not” (Service 171). Obviously, Stalin’s opinion changed between when he wrote that and when he came into power over that very party dictatorship. The power structure that Lenin had left behind almost required the selection of a new dictator. When Stalin claimed that role, the Politburo was already accustomed to blindly follow the leader and not question his policies. More importantly, the rest of the country was used to absolute law from the Politburo, whether it was coming from Lenin or Stalin did not really matter. Overall, despite some key differences, Stalinism and Leninism were not that much different and I think Lenin would have been proud of Stalin’s U.S.S.R. Both men were ruthless dictators who did not tolerate opposition and believed they knew best what the proper fate was for Communist Russia.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Extent to Which Nicholas the Second was the Cause of the 1905 Revolution

- The Extent to Which Nicholas the Second was the Cause of the 1905 Revolution Nicholas II faced many problems at the beginning of his reign which were magnified because of his incomplete training in becoming tsar. The main problems facing him were that the zemstvas wanted more power and a growth in opposition. He rejected the first “problem” and as such, a number of political parties, both moderate and violent came into being. The 1905 revolution had two catalysts which were Bloody Sunday and the fact that Nicholas II only offered the liberals a consultative assembly when they wanted a legislative assembly as well....   [tags: Free Essays]

Free Essays
384 words (1.1 pages)

The French, Russian, and Scientid Revolution Essay

- During the French Revolution 1,800 people were beheaded at the Guillotine. Guillotine is where people watch other people get beheaded, this action lead to the reign of terror. The reign of terror lasted 10 months, most of the killing happen because Robespierre was ordering it (Reign of Terror1). You cannot make a revolution with silk gloves” (Joseph Stalin) does represent a powerful statement resulting in a violent revolution. During the French revolution the storming of the bastille happen on July 14th, 1789....   [tags: revolution, violent, change]

Better Essays
628 words (1.8 pages)

The Russian Revolution Of September 1917 Essay

- The Russian Revolution The Russian Revolution of March 1917 is one of the most widely studied areas of history. As such, this leads to many discussions of the events surrounding the revolution and leaves a bit of a dispute in how it came to be, as there are many aspects we must question in order to answer this. For instance the role Tsar Nicholas II played in the collapse of his authority in which he exercised poor judgement and an inability to rule during this time (Orlando Figes, pg 19); the extreme discontent from peasants who had long grown tired of the pitiful rations and the oppressive Tsarist regime (S....   [tags: Russian Empire, Russia, Nicholas II of Russia]

Better Essays
710 words (2 pages)

Essay on Tsar Nicholas 2nd's Survival of The 1905 Revolution

- Tsar Nicholas 2nd's Survival of The 1905 Revolution There are several factors that help our understanding of how the tsar and his regime endured the turmoil of the 1905 revolution. However, one thing is for sure, after the uprising and swift, brutal suppression of the revolutionaries on the 22nd of January 1905 outside the gates of the Winter Palace, the Nicholas 2nd and his administration received a drastic wake up call. Even though the monarchy received a hard slap on this day, the tsar himself was in no immediate danger; the ignorance of the instigator, Father Gapon, ensured that he didn’t even know that the tsar was not occupying the Palace at this time....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Essay Tsar Nicholas II

- Tsar Nicholas II was the first to abdicate in the line of the Romanov Dynasty. In his reign in Russia from 1894-1917 he encountered many obstacles. Tsar Nicholas II decision to go into the Great War which led to the February revolution in 1917 could be seen as the facilitator [awk] that led to his eventual downfall. This essay will look at the some of the issues that played a role in his abdication. Prior to Tsar Nicholas II becoming the Emperor, Russia had gone through some radical and political changes....   [tags: Romanov Dynasty, Russian History]

Better Essays
1203 words (3.4 pages)

Animal Farm: Czar Nicolas II and Farmer Jones Essay

- ... He refused to take it seriously and did not help his people, instead, he “carried on playing dominoes for several hours”(Vogt 102) while his people were starving and dying. Nicholas was eventually forced to abdicate. Mr. Jones was forced to leave the farm after the Rebellion since he wasn’t taking care of his animals and they were starving. After the Rebellion Mr. Jones goes to live in the Red Lion in Willingdon since he cannot go back to the farm (Orwell 54). Czar Nicholas stays in Russia and is forced to live in Alexander Palace (Vogt 104), and like Jones, he does not have any control over the government anymore....   [tags: leadership, reign, exiled, government]

Better Essays
634 words (1.8 pages)

Nicholas Is Foreign Policy Essay

- Maintaining Order The Reign of Nicholas I has been marked with war. He grew up in a time when war was the accepted norm of Russia. As a child he saw his brother fight against the evil, which was Napoleon. With war being part of Nicholas everyday life he quickly became infatuated with it. “He always remained an army man, a junior officer at heart, devoted to his troops, to military exercises, to the parade ground, down to the last button on a soldiers uniform (Riasanovsky, 323)” Nicholas time growing up in Russia had an immense influence on him....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1487 words (4.2 pages)

Nicholas I Essay

- Nicholas I Nicholas I has been portrayed, and perhaps rightfully so, as a strict and reactionary tsar. Indeed, his internal policies were often repressive -- he sought to nip any liberalism in the bud, often brutally. His approach to solving problems in the Empire and keeping control was to create the "Nicholas system", a bureaucratic system defined by and completely based on absolute monarchy. Nicholas revamped govermental structure by strengthening and centralizing bureaucratic structures to an unprecedented degree....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1286 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Czar Nicholas II

- On May 6, 1868, an event happened that would change the fate of monarchy in Russia. Czar Nicholas Alexandrovich Romanov II was born in the Blue Bedroom of the Alexander Palace. Ominously, this occurred on the Orthodox day of feast for St. Job the Sufferer. This omen would prevision the never-ending trials he would face in his lifetime. In 1894, Nicholas's father, Czar Alexander III, died from a liver disease called nephritis. At age 26, Nicholas felt that he was not ready to rule Russia. However, he believed that his autocracy was a God-given right....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
719 words (2.1 pages)

Russian Revolution Research Paper : Russia

- Russian Revolution Research Paper Countries with a considerable amount of resources, weapons and soldiers are most optimal to fight in a war. A government that entered into a conflict at a disadvantage of resources and strategy has a higher chance of a negative outcome. Russia showed to be a prime example of a disadvantaged country, as it was not industrialized compared to its opponent countries such as Germany, which was better equipped and stocked with soldiers and proved to be a challenge for the Russian military....   [tags: Russian Empire, Russia, World War I]

Better Essays
1140 words (3.3 pages)