Review of Janet Holmes' Article "Men, Women and Politeness" Essays

No Works Cited
Length: 1022 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Purple      
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

The author of the article "Men, Women and Politeness" was Janet Holmes. It was published in 1995.
This article, intentionally, speaks about how women and men interrelate. The basis of her argument is
very simple and clearly expressed. Holmes tries to say that women are more polite than men, in the way
a person speaks. She says that women have ‘softened tones of disagreement’, whereas refers men to
being blunt and aggressive. . Holmes tries to say that the way in which women and men interact is
diverse. She also tries to say that the way in which they agree to things is also different. Holmes tries to
prove that all reactions of men and women are different, but all men and women act in the same way,
which makes them predictable. The article also states that in mixed sex groups, there are no differences
of communicating. Holmes uses a survey, by James Pilkington (1992), which is conducted on both men
and women working at a night bakery. The data from the survey, shows that women are more co-
operative then men. Also Holmes uses another survey results which was carried out by Maria Stubbe
(1991). That survey was done on eleven and twelve year olds. That survey also proves that women are
more agreeing, whereas, men are disagreeing.

Janet Holmes research concludes and proves that women are more polite and avoid using verbal abuse
and agree to statements, whereas men are negative. Men use more aggressive language, and have a
loud tone. The conclusions she has drawn are the conclusions to her findings and research, which is
reliable to a certain extent, but some elements of her conclusion are not explained properly, and cannot
be proved reliable.

Janet Holmes does her findings on a group with differen...

... middle of paper ...

...think that Janet Holmes has proper academic evidence as she has got them from academic
people, with proper references. However some references are missing and information provided is
outdated and can be biased. is considering and giving more priority to women, and not equal priority to
both men and women. In the article, Janet Holmes talks about the differences in men and women that
used to exist a long time ago, and does not exist anymore. The data collected, shown in the article, is
from the 1970’s and now it is the 20th Century. Data is outdated. Women and Men now interact
properly. Example: at workplace. There are both men and women at a workplace and they interact in a
proper manner. To a certain point, her reasons and research do not support the point, but there may be
some differences which were in 1970’s which may occur today.

Click the button above to view the complete essay, speech, term paper, or research paper

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

This essay is 100% guaranteed.

Title Length Color Rating  
Janet Jackson's Career Analysis Essay examples - It’s no question that Janet Jackson is one of the most iconic and influential artist of all time. She has sold over 100 million albums; her tours have had some the highest selling debuts of all time, not to mention the chart topping hits she has created over the past 30 years. Janet’s presence alone is iconic. She has left an unforgettable impression on the music industry as a whole. Her music has affected fans and music lovers all around the world. Her influence is simply not a question it is a salutation to a musical icon that has embedded her legacy into musical history....   [tags: janet jackson, music industry, janet album] 574 words
(1.6 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Paint It Black By Janet Fitch Essay - Paint It Black By Janet Fitch First came White Oleander, Janet Fitch's earliest successful novel, and then came Paint It Black, a tale no less mesmerizing. The story is set in the 80's Punk scene in LA and follows a young girl named Josie Tyrell as she copes with the suicide of the only person that she ever truly loved. Josie was just white trash before Michael Faraday entered her life. He read her poetry, taught her how to dream, and filled her with a light that she never knew existed, but then it was gone, and she was left in the dark, alone....   [tags: Janet Fitch] 885 words
(2.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
A Letter To Sherlock Holmes Essay - Dear Holmes, I hope you are doing well, and I continue to pray that your health stays in tip top shape so that we can successfully conclude this investigation. My main reason for writing you this letter is to keep you up-to-date with all the goings on at Baskerville Hall. In our carriage, I and Sir Henry were treated to some mental stimulus in the shape of serene meadows and farmers tending to their amply sized cows. I never imagined that after travelling through such tranquil and heavenly landscape we would be greeted upon arrival by a barrage of soldiers....   [tags: Sherlock Holmes] 714 words
(2 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Holmes on Conversation Styles Essay - Holmes (2000: 300) stated that : It seems possible that for men mock-insults and abuse serve the same function – expressing solidarity and maintaining social relationships – as complements and agreeing comments do for women For the writer, he agrees with this statement because for male counterpart; it’s hard to find and identify the equivalent for men towards women’s gossip. Men tend to discuss and focus on things and activities, rather than feelings and also personal experience as the main topic for conversation....   [tags: politeness in language, men and women differences] 1203 words
(3.4 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Movie Review of Of Mice and Men Essay - Movie Review of Of Mice and Men In this, the third and latest movie version of John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men, screenplay written by Horton Foote and directed by Gary Sinese, the audience is introduced to a variety of underdogs who are faced with a variety of unfortunate predicaments. We must first note that the title Of Mice and Men comes from a Robert Burns poem means “the best laid schemes of mice and men often go awry”. This theme follows the plot line through out the movie. The audience follows two men, George (Gary Sinese) and Lennie (John Malkovich), through a brief point in time in their lives during the Depression era....   [tags: Films, Review, Steinbeck] 325 words
(0.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Blade Runner Review Essay - According to Janet Maslin, in a review for “The New York Times” written shortly after Blade Runner’s release, “The view of the future offered by Ridley Scott's muddled yet mesmerizing 'Blade Runner' is as intricately detailed as anything a science-fiction film has yet envisioned” (par. 1). Although Blade Runner isn’t as popular when it came out as it is now, it has become an acclaimed and classic sci-fi film. Based on the novel, “Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?” by Phillip K. Dick, Blade Runner is a dramatic and unique look into a dark and twisted future....   [tags: Janet Maslin, The New York Times]
:: 8 Works Cited
1359 words
(3.9 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Essay about Young Sherlock Holmes - ... For example, Watson found Sherlock’s intelligence to be interesting. Watson and Sherlock became friends right away. Watson is a new student, and is studying to become a doctor. But he is caught up on Sherlocks curiosity. Watson and Sherlock get into trouble when they are mixed up with an egyptian cult. The leader of this cult is no other than professor and fencing teacher, Rathe (Ehtar). Sherlock looks up to Rathe as a mentor and a friend. (Wiki) Rathe always tells Sherlock to control his emotions because if he doesn’t they will be his downfall....   [tags: film review, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle] 977 words
(2.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes Essay - The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes As my first point I would like to comment on the use of Watson as a narrator. I think that the writer does this to show how clever Sherlock Holmes is compared to an ordinary person. We see this as Watson often gets confused and doesn't know what's going on, where as Holmes always seems to be in control. An example of this is in the story 'The Blue Carbuncle', before the mystery has even come to light, Sherlock Holmes deduces certain things from a battered hat....   [tags: Sherlock Holmes Essay] 655 words
(1.9 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Music For Torching by A.M. Holmes Essay - Music For Torching by A.M. Holmes A.M. Holmes’ critique of the American dream’s malfunction in modern suburbia examines contemporary domestic life through a variety of socially realistic metaphors. No metaphor is a stronger critic of the dark domestic world she presents than the recurring theme of clothing as a mask which her characters use to hide their true identities. The novel focuses on the importance of “socially acceptable” clothing as an expression of each character’s overall desire to reach a state of normalcy, if not perfection....   [tags: Music Torching Holmes Essays] 2056 words
(5.9 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay on Sherlock Holmes - Sherlock Holmes … . I propose to devote my declining years to the composition of a textbook which shal focus the whole art of detection into one volume. Sherlock Holmes: The Adventure of the Abbey Grange Sherlock Holmes is sometimes compared to a bloodhound. He smels out clues, folows them, and catches criminals. He is very good at this, and although he sometimes fails (as in The Yelow Face) his success rate is very high. Now there is an art in doing this, which Sherlock Holmes cals the art of detection, and he is an expert in this art....   [tags: Sherlock Holmes Essays Detective] 2107 words
(6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]