Retrospective Operation of the Bill Essay

Retrospective Operation of the Bill Essay

Length: 1305 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Publications (Immigration Issues) Bill 2014 (Cth) Issue
I. Issue

Does the government have the right to implement a Bill that operates retrospectively? If this occurs, many people, especially journalists and media companies, would likely be charged and arrested, even though their work could have been written up to two years ago, since under the Bill that is proposed to operate retrospectively, publications made in the last two years come under scrutiny.

II. Relevant Law
(a) Statutory Analysis of the Bill

If a modern approach of statutory interpretation was employed to construe this bill, the statutory principle of looking to the purpose of the government in writing the legislation would be applied. As Prime Minister Rick Grimes stated in his second reading speech of the Bill, the proposed law aims to provide protection for all Australian citizens from any public proclamation or record made about immigration or something alike that brings about unwelcoming and threatening feelings of hatred, or threatens the health and safety of the Australian people . As it was the Prime Minister who introduced the Bill into parliament to regulate media publications addressing immigration issues, this comment in the Parliamentary debate indicates the intention and purpose of the drafting of the Bill-that is, for it to operate retrospectively.

Further, in section 4 of the Bill, included in the definition of the term “declared materials” is the phrase “publically available or capable of being publically available” . Applying statutory principles of interpreting the meaning of words in their ordinary sense, this definition can be understood as referring to materials that are being published and accessed currently, or that have been published...


... middle of paper ...


...he principles in which would need to be heavily considered when making legislation that is ex post facto law.

IV. Conclusion

In following the principles of statutory interpretation when construing the Bill, it is clear that it is appropriately drafted in order for it to act retrospectively. Further, by looking at the case of Polyukhovich v Commonwealth and the decision made by the High Court, it is evidenced that laws can be implemented retrospectively and that it is possible to enforce laws created in the present that result in prosecution for past conduct. However, Putland’s article offers a different point of view in relation to this issue, providing reasons not to legislate ex post facto law. However, it is likely that this Bill will be passed due to the Australian Constitution allowing retrospective laws, and the fact that they have been passed previously.



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Bill Clinton Is A Good President Essay

- 15 Bill Clinton Bill Clinton, 42nd United States President, was a good president but made some wrong choices. The preview life of bill clinton is that he had rough childhood wasn’t the poorest or the richest but as time went on he had a good head on his shoulders.His parents are Mr.William jefferson Bylthe jr and Mrs.Virginia Dell Cassidy. His dad was a travelling salesman but sadly died in a car wreck just 3 months before bill was born. His mother had given bill to her parents to watch over while she went to school to be a nurse....   [tags: Bill Clinton, President of the United States]

Strong Essays
1261 words (3.6 pages)

Bill Gates : The Most Influential Man Essay

- Becoming the richest man in the world, Bill Gates is one of the most influential men. Not only is Bill Gates one of the most influential figures in the world, but he is also one of the most influential figures in the business world. Bill Gates was born on October 28, 1955, in Seattle, Washington. Gates was born into already well established family. “His father, William Henry Gates Jr., was a successful lawyer, and his mother, Mary Maxwell, was chairwoman of United Way International.”(Stevenson)....   [tags: Bill Gates, Warren Buffett]

Strong Essays
817 words (2.3 pages)

Operation Market Garden the Battle of Arnhem Essay

- After heavy defeats in Normandy in July and August 1944, the remnants of the German troops were retreating from France through Benelux to German borders. In German lines was spreading desertion. Units disintegrated in the fight were escaping in all direction from the front back to Germany. Fast progressing of western Allies caused difficulties in supply, as the fighting was getting away from beaches. The whole Allied troops were supplied through the Normandy beaches and harbor Cherbourg. The Germans knew about the Allies problems and tried to keep ports as long as possible....   [tags: operation, allied, aviation, command]

Strong Essays
1702 words (4.9 pages)

Use of Information Technology in Operation Management Essay

- TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction Analysis Conclusion Reference Introduction This report is to write about how Operation Management is employing more and more information technology, and in general this is being done to improve how organisations respond to the five objectives of Operations such as speed, flexibility, dependability, quality and costs. In this assignment, there will be an analysis of the technology available in different areas of the operation in the organisation choosing and will be providing a critical evaluation on how the organisation are achieving the goals is employing it for....   [tags: Operation Management Essays]

Strong Essays
1626 words (4.6 pages)

A Retrospective on Rebirth Essay

- There is a certain fascination in life when humans at a certain time become retrospective. The Renaissance or rebirth in Italy during the Quattrocento period epitomized this phenomenon. Throughout history and only during Renaissance have humans been able to embed a sense of urgency to relearn the ideas and culture of antiquity. Among the city-states on the Italian Peninsula, the Florentine Republic was on the verge of being the most prominent center of the Renaissance. Many contributing factors such as the influential families, the various guilds, politicians, and learned men propelled Florence to new heights of achievement; these include artistic expression, philosophical views—not seen sin...   [tags: The Renaissance]

Strong Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Operation ANVIL Essay

- General Blaskowitz, the Army Group G Commander’s assigned objective was to maintain possession of the Southern coast of France at all costs. The ability to counter the threat of an Allied invasion of Southern France would require reinforcement and fortification of Army Group G units, which, together, constituted the German Center of Gravity in the Southern France Theater of Operations. Army Group G’s leadership attempted to accomplish this task in a number of ways: The factor of Force bore heavily on the German defensive capabilities....   [tags: Operation OVERLORD, France, Germany]

Strong Essays
1011 words (2.9 pages)

William Jefferson 's Bill Clinton Essay

- In a period of an election, people look around and about for a candidate that has policies that will favor them. Most candidates, unfortunately, use this as a leverage to raise false hopes and promises. The people of America deserve better than that. A candidate should be realistic and not just for the sake of power, throw dust into the eyes of the people. William Jefferson "Bill" Clinton was the 42nd present of the United States and the first Democrat to serve two terms in office since FDR....   [tags: Bill Clinton, Hillary Rodham Clinton, Arkansas]

Strong Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

A Bill of Rights Essay

- A Bill of Rights A Bill of Rights is a statement of values and standards, of rights and responsibilities. It is a 'higher law' than those which Parliament passes, and a standard by which to judge these laws. It sets out our rights and responsibilities as individuals. Arguments for a Bill of Rights * a Bill of Rights gives you the chance to fight for your rights in court * if a Bill of Rights is 'entrenched', Parliament must make sure that laws take account of those rights included in it * a Bill of Rights can give protection to vulnerable minorities * human rights education is easier if there is a sin...   [tags: The Bill of Rights Essays]

Free Essays
392 words (1.1 pages)

Bill Gates Leader Report Essay

- Bill Gates Leader Report My favorite leader is William Henry Gates III, or Bill Gates to most people. Bill Gates is a computer engineer and world-class entrepreneur. He founded Microsoft Corporation in 1975 with a high school friend named Paul Allen. The leadership role that he serves is chairman and chief software architect of Microsoft Corporation. Up until 1998, Gates was CEO of the company, but he relieved himself of those duties, and currently is only a software architect and serves on the Microsoft committee....   [tags: Bill Gates]

Strong Essays
1327 words (3.8 pages)

Retrospectives Essay

- Retrospectives I selected three autobiographical pieces and one analytical for the portfolio. The order is: "Multi-Threaded ThingTM," an autobiographical paper which took inspiration from the form of Susan Griffin's "Our Secrets," and represented my life by pseudocode written in different computer programming languages; "Autobiographical Comparison," which was a partially successful attempt to compare and contrast my beliefs with those of James Baldwin; "Virginia Woolf: Assertive or Introspective," an analytical assessment of Virginia Woolf's motives while writing her memoir A Sketch of the Past; and "The ideal Life," an autobiographical response to the fantasy life portrayed in Maxi...   [tags: Autobiographies Education Essays]

Strong Essays
1425 words (4.1 pages)