Research Findings of Both the Benefits and Limitations of DAP Testing Essay

Research Findings of Both the Benefits and Limitations of DAP Testing Essay

Length: 1295 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Research Findings of Both Benefits and Limitations of DAP Testing

This paper focuses on research information of Draw A Person (DAP) testing in both its original form of Children’s Human Figure Drawing created by Florence Goodenough, it’s limitations, and it’s current form of function as DAP testing of today. DAP is typically used to identify cognitive strengths and limitations among primary aged youth through the evaluation of the drawn human figure. However, there is some evidence that suggests DAP could be of therapeutic benefit in other areas of function. Florence Goodenough first published findings in 1926 that revealed children’s drawings of a man can be correlated to their level of intelligence. Goodenough spoke of the human figure drawing task as being “useful in the analysis of specific mental functions and in the study of the development of conceptual thinking during early childhood” (Goodenough, 1926). Even though the Goodenough Draw-a-Man test was established as being a good measure of non-verbal cognitive ability, there are elements of this test that suggest:
1. In order to raise test validity, it may need to be used in conjunction with other means of measurement.
2. Lower socioeconomic status and/or limited access to structured programs have a significant effect on scoring outcome.
3. Scoring criteria and interpretation may be devised and utilized depending on the purpose and field of study.
The research that is focused on in this paper covers these three issues.
Goodenough-Harris Draw-a-Person Test Valid?
The Goodenough-Harris Draw-a-Person Test has been criticized by some for being outdated and the scoring instructions have been found to be laborious and imprecise ...


... middle of paper ...


...as measures of intelligence: the comparative validity of three scoring systems. Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment. 2001. Pg 19.
Ayres, A.J. & Reid, W. The self -drawing as an expression of perceptual motor function. Cortex 1966; pg 254
Goodenough, F.L. Measurement of Intelligence by Drawings. Chicago, Ill: World Book Company: 1926, pg.13
Litterick-Briggs, A. & Broadley, G. Smart start with PMP: implementation, management and evaluation. Teaching and Learning 2005; pg.21.
Naglieri, J.A. Draw-A-Person-A quanitative scoring system. San Antonio, Tx: The Psychological Corporation.
Oakland, T. & Dowling, L. The Draw-A-Person Test: Validity Properties for Nonbiased Assessment. Learning Disability Quarterly 1983; pg 6
Offman, H.J. & Bradley, S.J. Body Image of Children and Adolescents and its Measurement: an overview. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry. 1992; 37:6.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Benefits of Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Essay

- Introduction Random drug screening involves the experimental analysis that utilizes specimens such as saliva, hair, blood or urine in order to determine the presence of certain drugs or their metabolites. These tests are usually done to ascertain the presence or absence of prohibited drugs or steroids. On the other hand, the state welfare assistance/ government assistance is a government funded program that was started in 1930 during which period US citizens and the rest of the world were facing the great depression (Welfare Information, par.1)....   [tags: Drug Testing Public Assistance]

Strong Essays
1315 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Genetic Testing: Benefits and Burdens

- Genetic Testing: Benefits and Burdens Thesis: The field of genetic testing is rapidly expanding. Numerous ethical issues are arising, within genetic testing, such as privacy issues, the potential of discrimination or eugenics, and how to convey the information properly. Background: Today we live in a very technologically advanced society. Scientists are continually discovering new things about the world and the way things work. "In the 1980ís, it was becoming increasingly apparent to many scientists that an understanding of basic biology would be greatly enhanced if the detailed structure of DNA was understood" (Mehlman, 1998)....   [tags: Genetic Testing Research Papers]

Strong Essays
4995 words (14.3 pages)

Medical Beneifits Of Animal Testing Essay

- Argument Essay Where would we be Without Animal Testing. Is the use of animals in research justified. Should animal experimentation be permitted. Should these animals be liberated. A logical person would say the benefits justify the research. Without animal testing, products would be based on theory. No one would want to use something, which may damage eyes, be poisonous, cancerous, and cause birth defects. Animals used in testing are not from the endangered species list; also many of the types of animals used are killed each year by rat or mouse traps, animal control, exterminators, and animal shelters....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
390 words (1.1 pages)

Benefits And Benefits Of Genetic Testing Essays

- Recommendations If genetic testing is to provide benefits, it is important to ensure that those offered testing understand the risk information and the advice given. By providing informed consent prior the BRCA1/2 genetic test, physicians give patients the information necessary to understand the scope and nature of the potential risks and benefits in order to make a decision. Patient required an explanation for their disease if they were to be able to assign meaning and order to help with adaptation and coping....   [tags: Health care, Patient, Decision theory]

Strong Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

The Benefits of Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation Essay

- Animal rights are held entirely too high in regard. Many activist do not realize the benefits of testing on animals. They claim that it is "unethical" or "cruel" to perform experiments on such creatures. The truth is, the world as a whole has advanced tremendously in the past century due to animal experimentation. We are affected every day by at least one thing that has been influenced by animal testing. Many of the things we take for granted would not exist if it were not for experimenting with animals....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]

Strong Essays
2788 words (8 pages)

Against Drug Testing In The Workplace Essay

- Abstract The issue of drug testing in the workplace has sparked an ongoing debate among management. There are many who feel that it is essential to prevent risks to the greater public caused by substance abuse while on the job. However, others believe that the costs far outweigh the benefits and that it is an invasion of privacy. Putting all ethical issues aside, evidence presented in this paper supports the latter. The costs of drug testing are excessive and only a small percentage of employees are actually found to be substance users....   [tags: Essays on Drug Testing]

Strong Essays
1742 words (5 pages)

Pros and Cons of Drug Testing Essay

- From workplace to school, from professional sports to the armed forces, the advent of drug-testing procedures has stirred debate and controversy. The issue of drug testing in athletics seems to be the most prevalent debate. An incident that really brought drug testing into the spotlight is the track and field event in the 1988 Summer World Olympic Games. The two competitors in the limelight were Carl Lewis and Ben Johnson, both excellent and very emulating runners who have beaten each other in past competitions....   [tags: Essays on Drug Testing]

Free Essays
1249 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Controversial Findings

- On July 28, 1996 a human skull was found along the banks of the Columbia River at Kennewick, Washington. This skull would lead to the discovery of a complete skeleton with characteristics of a Caucasian male. The significance of this discovery is that it's dated to between 9,300 and 9,600 years ago, making it one of the earliest skeletons found in the United States and the second oldest found in Washington. With this great archeological find controversy was soon to follow. The skeleton was found on a portion of the Colombian River maintained by the United Sates Marine Corps of Engineers, but also part of the traditional home of the Umatilla tribe....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
759 words (2.2 pages)

Animal Testing Essay

- Animal Testing As history shows man has endured and overcome many diseases and illnesses. These diseases killed many people and caused many to suffer. Most of these diseases have been cured do to mans medical research. Medical research has improved people’s lives along with increased life expectancy greatly. These medical breakthroughs have helped mankind in many ways, but in order to achieve these advances in medicine many animals suffered through testing. These test done to animals have improved the lives of many humans who would have suffered themselves....   [tags: Animal Testing]

Strong Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)

Animal Testing Essay

- Animal Testing In the 1880’s, Louis Pasteur conducted one of the most unpleasant series of animal experiments in the history of the fight against infectious disease. Unable to see the organism that causes rabies with the microscopes available, he convinced a skeptical medical community of the microorganism’s existence and also the possibility of vaccinating against it. He did this by doing work on rabbits and dogs. In 1885, after much heart searching, he tried out his rabies vaccine on a nine-year old boy, Joseph Meister, who had been bitten 14 times by a rabid dog....   [tags: Animal Testing]

Strong Essays
686 words (2 pages)