Representations of Native Americans in Dances with Wolves and The Searchers

Representations of Native Americans in Dances with Wolves and The Searchers

Length: 1386 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

“Film is more than the instrument of a representation; it is also the object of representation. It is not a reflection or a refraction of the ‘real’; instead, it is like a photograph of the mirrored reflection of a painted image.” (Kilpatrick) Although films have found a place in society for about a century, the labels they possess, such as stereotypes which Natives American are recognized for, have their roots from many centuries ago (Kilpatrick). The Searchers, a movie directed by John Ford and starred by John Wayne, tells the story of a veteran of the American Civil War and how after his return home he would go after the maligned Indians who killed his family and kidnapped his younger niece. After struggling for five years to recover his niece back, who is now a young woman, she is rescued by his own hands. Likewise, Dances with Wolves is a Western film directed and starred by Kevin Costner. It is also situated during the American Civil War and tells the story of a soldier named John Dunbar that after a suicide attempt; he involuntarily leads Union troops to a triumph. Then, by his request he is sent to a remote outpost in the Indian frontier “before it’s gone”. There, the contact with the natives is eminent and thus it shows how through those contacts this soldier is transformed into another Indian that belongs with the Sioux to tribe and who is now called Dances With Wolves. While both John Ford and Kevin Costner emphasize a desire to apologize to the indigenous people, they use similar themes such as stereotypes, miscegenation, and the way characters are depicted; conversely, these two movies are different by the way the themes are developed within each film.

John Ford’s The Searchers was giving the intention of ap...


... middle of paper ...


... due to the way their roles interact with the Amerind people in the film.

As a result, both films represent Natives Americans under the point of view of non-Native directors. Despite the fact that they made use of the fabricated stereotypes in their illustrations of the indigenous people, their portrayal was revolutionary in its own times. Each of the films add in their own way a new approach to the representation of indigenous people, their stories unfold partly unlike. These differences make one look at the indigenous not only as one dimensional beings but as multifaceted beings, as Dunbar say, “they are just like us.” This is finally a sense of fairness and respect by the non-native populations to the Native Indians.

Works Cited

Jacquelyin Kilpatrick , Celluloid Indians. Native Americans and Film. Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press, 1999

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Native Americans and Their Intrinsic Relationship with Western Films Essay

- Dances With Wolves, directed by Kevin Costner, and The Searchers, directed by John Ford, looks into the fabric of this country's past. The media has created a false image of the relationship between Native Americans and White men to suppress the cruel and unfortunate reality. Both directors wanted to contradict these stereotypes, but due to the time period the films were created, only one film was successful. Unlike The Searchers, Dancing With Wolves presents a truly realistic representation of Native Americans....   [tags: Native Americans ]

Strong Essays
941 words (2.7 pages)

The Native American Native Americans Essay

- ... Secondly, Columbus and Hariot both believed the natives to be “simple in war-like matters” (Document 1). When it came to the type of weapons, Native Americans, “they had no edged tools or weapons of iron or steel to attack with, nor did they know how to make them. The only weapons they possessed were bows made of witch hazel, arrows made of reeds, and flat-edged wooden truncheons, which were about a yard long. As for defense, they wore armour made out of sticks that were wickered together with thread, and carried shields made out of bark” (Document 2)....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1188 words (3.4 pages)

Native American And Native Americans Essay

- Over the past century, many Native American groups have experienced social and environmental change and have had to deal with a variety of contemporary issues. Although Native Americans may be associated with the past due to popular culture, many different American Indian groups are strongly affected by modern issues. For instance, while type II diabetes is a major issue in many communities, it disproportionately affects Native Americans. Beginning in the 20th century, Native American groups have been affected by diabetes, and they are currently one of the populations that are at particularly high risk for developing the disease....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
3303 words (9.4 pages)

Stereotypical Images Of Native Americans Essays

- ... However it has subconsciously influenced its readers with the stereotypes of the Native Americans, mainly the idea that the natives are a vanishing race which is exemplified by the death of Uncas (p340) leaving his father Chingachgook as the last of the Mohicans. Native Americans nowadays are far from gone but the myth of the vanishing race make people believe that it is harmless to have stereotypes of them since there is a low chance that they would successfully retaliate. Edward Curtis ' self-approved photographs of Native Americans were influential as it garnered interested for the supposed vanishing Native American race at the time....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1395 words (4 pages)

Essay about Native American And Native Americans

- ... The Paleo-Indian Era can be dated back to 10,000 B.C, until around 7,000 B.C. which began the Archaic Period Native American during this time had developed knowledge to build basic shelters, make stone weapons, and stone tools. Around 1,000 AD began the Woodland period which included the Adena Culture this culture consisted of the building of mounds, burial complexes, and the use of ceremonial systems. The Woodland Era saw the introduction of pottery and the beginnings of settled farming communities, the Native Americans began the construction of burial mounds....   [tags: Cherokee, Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1079 words (3.1 pages)

Native American And Native Americans Essay

- ... The women were usually the clan leaders of the tribes. The Iroquois also held many festivals which eventually became a ritual that lasted several days to give thanks for the food, clothing, health and happiness. The Iroquoians had a few problems with certain people who were their enemies, namely, the Algonquians and the French. The French became an Iroquoian enemy because there was a mishap about a fur trade. The Iroquois had gotten into a war with the French, which had lasted about 70 years....   [tags: Iroquois, Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
2245 words (6.4 pages)

Native American Culture : Native Americans Essay

- ... Natives of the great plains built tepees made of buffalo skin. The Pueblo Natives of the south-western part of America used sun-dried bricks to make houses. As we are used to eating unhealthy cheese burgers and pizza. Native americans Ate mostly healthy foods, those who lived on the plains of the central united states ate the meat of buffalo. The Pueblos of the south-western part lived on corn, beans and squash. Native Americans in Alaska and Canada were fishers and hunted deer and other wild animals in the forest....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Oppression Of Native American Americans

- ... Some of the Spaniards were accepting of the Indians, wanting to learn more about their culture. Priests would go into Native American tribes, learn the local Indian language, and begin to preach the gospel, persuading the Indians to build a new village based around the belief of Christianity. By forcing the Indians to conform to the Christian religion, the Spanish were stripping the Natives of their own beliefs. The exploration of the New World was a colossal task taken up by England in hopes of generating wealth and benefitting the mother country....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
2038 words (5.8 pages)

Native Americans and Alcohol Essay

- Native Americans as a whole have been typecast as drunks ever since the coming of the white man’s “fire water.” TS Naimi, MD et al. reports that alcohol is responsible for 11.7% of all American Indian and Alaska Native deaths, compared to 3.3% for the U.S. general population (939). This disturbing discrepancy reinforces the age old notion of the “drunk Indian.” Generalizations aside, is there some truth to this stereotype. Are Indians more likely than other races to be drunks. Of all the races, “Native Americans have the highest prevalence (12.1%) of heavy drinking…A larger percentage of Native Americans (29.6%) also are binge drinkers” (Chartier and Caetano 153)....   [tags: Native Americans ]

Strong Essays
2257 words (6.4 pages)

The Native Americans Essay examples

- ... It seems appropriate to begin this essay appreciating the complexity and diversity of Native American societies pre-Columbus, in contrast to what historians previously thought of them. The diversity of the Native Americans stems from their distinctive ideas about religion, which largely influenced their political systems. Some communities were ruled by a single person, as in chiefdoms, others were ruled by several leaders, as in confederacies, and some had no underlying political organization at all....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1762 words (5 pages)