Replacing Traditional Lectures Essay example

Replacing Traditional Lectures Essay example

Length: 2064 words (5.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Traditional lectures have long been part of our educational system. They present facts and information in a concise and direct manner, yet, according to some studies, they are inferior to more active teaching methods when it comes to a student’s performance and practical skills. In spite of this, lectures continue to be a large part of most college’s curriculum, were, albeit not used all of the time, still contribute to a big portion of what is being done in class. This presents a critical problem in Computer Science courses, where active solution seeking and team work play an important role in the student’s career. Although courses usually combine lectures with other active-learning activities (such as labs), the time spent in lectures could still be used to nourish the aforementioned skills. This paper compares lectures to two alternatives methods: Cooperative Learning and Practical Problem-Based Learning, and explains why any of them proves superior to the didactic lecture. The Cooperative Learning method—proposed and evaluated by Leland Beck and Alexander Chizhik—relies heavily on teamwork while the Practical Problem-Based Learning method—which effectiveness’ was measured by Barg et al.—relies more on self-discovery. This paper then tries to explain why such substitution would benefit students in Computer Science I courses and the importance of at least testing their efficiency in different classrooms. Being a Computer Science I student who is almost done with the course, I will provide some personal input as well.
Before explaining their shortcomings, it is important to note the advantages of using lectures. Having being used for a long time, lectures are one of the most traditional ways of teaching. Their positive character...


... middle of paper ...


...exander Chizhik. “Cooperative Learning Instructional Methods for CS1: Design, Implementation, and Evaluation.” Trans. Comput. Educ. 13.3 (2013): 10:1–10:21. ACM Digital Library. Web. 14 Nov. 2013.
Grissom, Scott. “Introduction to Special Issue on Alternatives to Lecture in the Computer Science Classroom.” Trans. Comput. Educ. 13.3 (2013): 9:1–9:5. ACM Digital Library. Web. 14 Nov. 2013.
Hake, Richard R. “Interactive-Engagement versus Traditional Methods: A Six-Thousand-Student Survey of Mechanics Test Data for Introductory Physics Courses.” American Journal of Physics 66.1 (1998): 64–74. scitation.aip.org. Web. 17 Nov. 2013.
O’Grady, Michael J. “Practical Problem-Based Learning in Computing Education.” Trans. Comput. Educ. 12.3 (2012): 10:1–10:16. ACM Digital Library. Web. 14 Nov. 2013.
Powell, Kendall. “Spare Me the Lecture.” Nature 425.6955 (2003): 234–236. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Are College Lectures Unfair? Essay

- Annie Murphy Paul’s “Are College Lectures Unfair?” is a well-written research based argument, but is it solid. In her article she questions “Does the college lecture discriminate. Is it biased against undergraduates who are not white, male and affluent?” She spends the rest of her essay providing evidence that active learning would benefit students who are “female, minorities and low income first generation college students”, while passive learning provides a bases for discrimination against the under- privileged....   [tags: Education, Educational psychology, Lecture]

Term Papers
1203 words (3.4 pages)

Should Students Learn More Through Technology Devices Or Traditional Lectures?

- earning can be defined as alteration in behavior due to experiences and by observing other individuals behavior (Boyd). According to Ya Ni, learning can be measured in three different ways: the students outcome (which can include information such as their test scores or final grades in their courses), the students satisfaction, and the students attitude. All three measures are equally important and interlinked through a positive correlation. In other words, if students have enthusiastic attitudes when learning the material, they are more likely to do well in their exams, and therefore, have a higher satisfaction rate....   [tags: Learning, Education, Chalkboard]

Term Papers
703 words (2 pages)

Adam Smith's Lectures on Jurisprudence Essay

- Adam Smith's Lectures on Jurisprudence Adam Smith, in his Lectures of Jurisprudence, makes an argument for the necessity of marriage through biological mechanisms. While superficially similar, his arguments seem to differ greatly from the modern notion of how labor is distributed within the household. Instead of examining the comparative advantages in production between the husband and the wife, Smith seems to focus on the importance of lineage and, more specifically, inheritance. The foundation of Smith’s argument for the necessity of marriage is rooted in children....   [tags: Economics Lectures Jurisprudence Essays]

Term Papers
632 words (1.8 pages)

Online Vs Traditional Classes Essays

- Online Vs Traditional Classes In today’s Era, students now have the advantage of choosing to attend a College University or achieve their degree through college online courses. However, some major concerns associated with this major life decision, beginning with the difference in the learning styles. Even though most people would consider taking an online course because it’s flexible to your schedule and students would have additional time to complete the assignment that their giving, other than in traditional classes....   [tags: oline classes, traditional courses]

Term Papers
656 words (1.9 pages)

Traditional Learning Environment for Adults Learners Essay

- ... All the required assignments were relative to the literature that was required by the class, and that is the just of the literature being beneficial as well. The weekly quizzes, two major tests, and the final were all loosely based on the lectures themselves. The problem was that the delivery of the lectures was monotone and lifeless. Imagine that you are sitting through a lecture delivered by a computerized voice; not that the instructor was a computer, that makes it impossible to take notes and keep focus....   [tags: andragogy, self-directing, traditional]

Term Papers
1072 words (3.1 pages)

The Conflict with Traditional Culture Essay

- The conflict with traditional culture The general people consider Hong Kong as an international city because a lot of cross-cultural enterprises choose Hong Kong as a landing base to enter into Chinese market and even Asian market.As a result ,the conscientious of women leadership can be brought into the working ecology through the expending of multinational firms. Nevertheless, it is misleading that the concept of women leadership can wholly be applied to companies in general and help increasing the number of women leader....   [tags: Traditional Culture, Hong Kong]

Term Papers
1643 words (4.7 pages)

Japanese Traditional and Continued Arts Essays

- The controversy of developments and beliefs between northern and southern Japan are known by natives and foreign experts. Researching about their history and talking with a native from off the soils of Japan. The north and the south may share the land but both have very different views (Hiroshi). While the south is continuing to become the new techno-logic age, the north is content with staying with the original and converted traditional life. Developments that differentiate each side are dealing with but not limited to technology....   [tags: traditional morals, beliefs, japan]

Term Papers
1902 words (5.4 pages)

Traditional Healing Vs Western Medicine Essay

- Cultures around the world offer different perspectives on the relationships between spirituality, healing and illness from that of mainstream Western culture (Mark & Lyons, 2010, p.1756).The coexistence of both traditional and biomedical healing systems is commonplace throughout the world and finding a place where only one method is relied upon exclusively is particularly difficult (McGrath, 1999, p.484) Medical pluralism within societies, as Stoner (1986) notes, “is the rule not the exception the world over” (p.44)....   [tags: Traditional Healing Essays]

Term Papers
2120 words (6.1 pages)

Traditional Chinese Medicine Essay

- One important aspect of Chinese culture is Traditional Chinese Medicine, also known as TCM. Chinese medicine has been around for quite awhile, and is still around today. In the United States, we see it as acupuncture and massage. TCM is still widely popular in its home country where it is still practiced as it was a few centuries ago. Chinese medicine is evolving to our modern day times, but it is keeping close ties to its roots. Chinese medicine is also becoming more affluent in different parts of the globe....   [tags: chinese culture, traditional medicine]

Term Papers
1135 words (3.2 pages)

Listening in Lectures Essay

- Listening in Lectures Lectures are the main way of communicating knowledge in the classroom setting, so being able to listen well is an essential to success in one’s education. There are many different techniques that once practiced and mastered, can lead to success. The first step to good listening skills in lectures is to be prepared. By reading the chapter being covered, or re-reading notes it is easier to listen. Because the content is not being introduced for the first time, it is easier to comprehend it....   [tags: essays papers]

Term Papers
830 words (2.4 pages)