The Relationship Between Art and Philosophical Ethics Essay

The Relationship Between Art and Philosophical Ethics Essay

Length: 1298 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The relationship between art and philosophical ethics can be divided into a dichotomy of two, radical understandings: aestheticism and moralism. Aestheticism prioritizes, if not entirely isolates, the artistic and technical value of an artwork over its moral implications. The aesthetic tradition asserts that art ought to be composed solely “for art’s sake,” hinging this position upon the assumption that only the essential component of an artwork—the sense to which the artwork is intended to appeal—is relevant in its critique (Peek, “Ethical Criticism of Art”). Within classical aesthetics, this conception of artistic value is epitomized by Enlightenment-era rationalist Immanuel Kant’s Critique of Judgment, in which he argues that one’s judgment of art must be of inherent “disinterest,” unconstrained by concepts of utility and morality. Kant suggests that art ought to be judged only upon its formal properties, such as design and composition, instead of for its perceived practical or moral worth. In this way, Leonardo da Vinci’s Mona Lisa, for example, would not be judged based upon da Vinci’s perceived psychological neuroses nor for the paintings modern relevance and fame, but on its arrangement: the use of contrapposto, pyramidal perspective, curved and straight lines.
This perspective is rivaled by Moralism. The Moralist theory emphasizes that the aesthetic value of an artwork is determined, or at least influenced, by its ethical premise. This school of thought formed the foundation of the modern philosophical study of art, making the discipline of recurring interest and debate since Plato’s aesthetics. To reference his “Parable of the Cave,” Plato interprets the arts not as shining indications of the enlightened world beyond the ...


... middle of paper ...


...and ethics remain modernly relevant, still intersecting in our popular culture.




Works Cited
Peek, Ella. "Ethical Criticism of Art" Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ISSN 2161-0002, Martin: University of Tennessee, 2005. Art, Ethical Criticism of. Web. 19 Jan. 2013.
Kant, Immanuel. Critique of the Power of Judgment. Trans. Paul Guyer. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ., 2009. Print.
Devereaux, Mary. "The Philosophical Status of Aesthetics." 1997 Annual Meeting of the American Society of Aesthetics. New Mexico, Santa Fe. 1997. Speech.
Plato. Plato, Complete in Twelve Volumes. Trans. Harold N. Fowler et al. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ., 1978. Print.
Simon Schama’s Power of Art. Dir. Clare Beavan. Perf. Simon Schama. BBC, 2006. DVD.
Maritain, Jacques. “The Responsibility of the Artist.” The Responsibility of the Artist. University of Notre Dame, 2010. Web. 21 Dec. 2013.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay The Art of Governing

- In Foucault’s idea, the art of governing is to bring economic considerations into political practice; to govern a country is equivalent to handle the economy of the entire country, aimed at promoting the economic development of the country and the welfare of people. Application of governmentality also exists in current education system; a series of management strategies is applied for controlling the education of students, this is not only simply from the government authority, but based on the globalized competition in education....   [tags: Foucault, economy]

Strong Essays
2454 words (7 pages)

Ethics : Ethics And Philosophical Ethics Essay

- What is ethics one may ask, well according to the oxford online dictionary ethics is moral principles that govern a person 's behavior or the conducting of an activity. That is what a person may view as right or wrong and good or bad. Ethics is very important in one’s society and each society as its own moral and principles governing certain issues and religion and philosophical ethics is no different. For centuries religion and religious principles has been criticized by different denominations across the world....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Religion, Philosophy]

Strong Essays
860 words (2.5 pages)

Ethics : The Philosophical Study Of Morality Essay

- Ethics is the philosophical study of morality. These days our society is changing due to advanced technology, hence the study of ethics is very important than the previous decades. In fact, the study of ethics is not a new issue but Socrates and Plato used ethical reasoning to explain different unjust issues before 2000 years. Ethics is one of the major issues, which does have not any guideline to a particular activity that is morally good, bad or neutral. However, everyone has different understanding and judgment about ethics depend on their cultural, economical, and family back ground....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Happiness, Philosophy]

Strong Essays
1511 words (4.3 pages)

The Philosophical Concept Of Human Self Interest And The Relationship Between Ethics, Altruism, And Rationality

- Egoism is the philosophical concept of human self-interest and the relationship between ethics, altruism, and rationality (Robbins). Psychological egoism and ethical egoism are the two concepts or positions that explain how one is or ought to be motivated to obtain their self-interest. The difference between ethical and psychological egoism is that the former deals with how a person should act and the latter deals with a universal concept practiced by all. With the theory of psychological egoism, selfishness proves it to be false; thus, can true ethical egoism be possible....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Individualism, Ethical egoism]

Strong Essays
1157 words (3.3 pages)

Philosophy and Technology Essay

- Philosophy and Technology ABSTRACT: This paper deals the place of technology in contemporary culture, and the relationship between science and morality. A definition of technique as a social process has to emphasize the fact that technique means developing and enabling different fabricated material systems; it is also the action of environment transformation according to human necessities. The area of culture is not limited to classical values, conceived with traditional meanings, arts and human sciences, but also covers the values of the natural and technical sciences as well as the whole set of values implied by technique and technology....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Papers]

Strong Essays
3480 words (9.9 pages)

Philosophical Views Of Animal Ethics Essay

- Philosophical Views of Animal Ethics For this essay, I chose to look at Immanuel Kant’s and John Stuart Mill’s views on the human treatment of non-human animals, specifically in the case of animal testing. I will look at Kant’s and Mill’s views separately, then the issue of the testing of animals, and finally, the philosophers’ views on the issue. I believe that both philosophers would come to the same conclusion, that animal testing is unethical in most cases. Immanuel Kant has a deontological view of ethics....   [tags: Ethics, Philosophy, Morality, Immanuel Kant]

Strong Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)

Ethics : A Philosophical Issue That Is Wrong Or Wrong? Essay

- Ethics is a philosophical issue that is controversial today. Ethics recommends, systemizes, and defines the concepts of right and wrong behavior in our society. One’s ethics can raise the question, “What is the correct way to live in our society?” It investigates what is considered good or bad. Ethics resolves questions over human morality that ultimately dictates what is wrong or right. It does it’s best to explain what evil and good actions for human beings may look like. Many people view good moral actions interchangeably with ethics....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Religion, Argument]

Strong Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

Aristotle, Kant, And Royce Ethical Works Essays

- What is "good" depends solely on the one judging. For someone to be labeled good they must maintain their judge’s approval in every task, quite difficult I would think. The character Stevens from The Remains of the Day remained a good human being to his employers in every task, so it appeared in the book. I want to explore in this essay if indeed Stevens remained a good human being by use of philosophers Aristotle, Kant, and Royce ethical works. I personally believe Stevens is a good human being my reasons compile to his honor to his work and the respect given to others....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Human, Virtue]

Strong Essays
795 words (2.3 pages)

Ethics of the Student and Professor Relationship Essay

- When discussing the importance of professional boundaries in mental health work, most people think first of relationships between psychotherapists and clients. However, similar boundary considerations are relevant for professor–student relationships, supervisor–supervisee relationships, consultant–consultee relationships, and researcher–participant relationships. Although different dynamics are at play, the relationships psychologists have with each other, with other professionals, and with the general public have boundaries that warrant ethical consideration as well....   [tags: Ethics ]

Strong Essays
1544 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on The Art and Philosophy of Balance at Constantin Brâncusi

- The Art and Philosophy of Balance at Constantin Brâncusi Motto: "All dilemmas can be solved by unifying the contraries" (Brâncusi) ABSTRACT: Our paper intends to be an attempt of making evident the joining of the art and the philosophy of Constantin Brâncusi, the most outstanding representative of sculpture in our century. The way of approaching this topic was suggested to us by the great artist and thinker himself, who urges us that we should not make difficult what he expressed in a simple way....   [tags: Art Philosophical Sculture Essays]

Strong Essays
3110 words (8.9 pages)