Essay about The Rejection Of Proof And Reality

Essay about The Rejection Of Proof And Reality

Length: 1363 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A common adage applied and used by historians is that they ‘must find the truth’, and that there is one truth, one chronological series of events that they must endeavour to find and thus make sense of. Even the narrative style of history determines itself by drawing from the truth, drawing from tried and tested research methods, and from ‘reliable’ sources of information. But the historians style of narrative that draws on truth, was “developed in the cauldron of fiction… [and] becomes at once the sign of proof and reality”. The rejection of ‘truth’ and ‘reality’ accounts for the notion that the history is a form of constructed narrative, and not an account of historical truth. With that in mind, when questioning truth with specific relation to fact and fiction, it is possible so see it blurs the line of such; it also allows to not only question what truth can be defined as, but also the relevance it has to historical narratives. A useful method of addressing issues of truth is too first look at an essay by Isaiah Berlin titled The Hedgehog and the Fox. In this essay, Berlin describes the Hedgehog as viewing the world through the lens of one idea, while the Fox draws on a wide variety of experiences; and to which their world cannot be viewed through one singular lens. Berlin argues that Tolstoy was both a fox and a hedgehog, in other words, Tolstoy longed to put all reality into one great system, but his faithfulness to his own remarkable sense of perception led him to see everywhere the fine distinctions and individual differences which constitute his own richly varied world. It is important also to note that Tolstoy was a fox in his writing, he understood that the question over truth was problematic and important; to which he c...

... middle of paper ...

... historical narrative would seem more outright wrong (in the conservative view of history). Films by Michael Winterbottom such as Welcome to Sarajevo challenge and create discussion on whether Films, as a medium, can be considered of importance in the field of history; and challenge genre definitions of historical movies as whole. It is important that such discussions take place, considering War and Peace as a historical narrative allows for such discussions to continue, Tolstoy 's genius and ideas on historiography show his tact for creative and open thinking that was not constricted by what novels, at the time, were meant to be defined as. Even as contemporary ideas are applied on his famous novel, it still holds up to scrutiny and creates an interesting debate that resounds with poststructuralist and postmodern debates of literary fiction and historical narrative.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Marlow's Rejection of Colonization Essay

- When the Europeans first colonized Africa, they encompassed nothing more than moral intentions. They wanted nothing more than to free them from their savagery and bring them into the circle of civilization. Marlow believed in this moral intention, though, he found later that these weren't the main intentions of the colonizers. Marlow later finds that this foremost reason was just a pretense: both false and deceitful. Their underlying reason was exploitation, something he had come to notice and hate as a result....   [tags: European Literature]

Free Essays
487 words (1.4 pages)

Essay about The Ontological Argument For God 's Existence

- Intro Throughout this essay, a question will present itself as to if the ontological argument can be accepted. To accomplish the task at hand, we shall analyze; firstly, the ontological argument from both Anselm and Descartes. Secondly, we shall discuss the argument for the existence of Fido, and why it does and does not look reasonable (which will answer (i)). Afterwards, questions (ii) and (iii) will be answered, followed by a rejection of the ontological argument from Gaunilo, and then an argument in the defence of the ontological argument from the Internet....   [tags: Metaphysics, Ontology, Existence, Reality]

Better Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)

Who Bears the Burden of Proof in Tax Litigation Essay

- Involved in federal civil tax litigation. Wondering who has the burden of proof in litigation. Burden of proof is the responsibility to prove the entries, deductions, or statements made on a taxpayer’s return. In order to deduct certain expenses they are substantiated by proof. When the burden of proof is on the taxpayer, the taxpayer keeps adequate records to prove their expenses or has sufficient evidence to support statements. Generally, documented evidence such as receipts, canceled checks, or bills is used to support expenses....   [tags: federal, civil, taxpayer, law, proof]

Better Essays
2684 words (7.7 pages)

The Rabbit Proof Fence Is A Symbol Of Love, Home, And Security Essay

- The Rabbit-Proof Fence to some was a source of employment, others was a division to keep rabbits from continuing to reproduce but “For the three runaways, the fence was a symbol of love, home, and security” (109). These three runaways were half-caste children, meaning their mothers are Aborigines and their fathers are white. The Australian government believed they were doing the right thing by removing these half-caste children from the Aborigine community, and stripping them from their families....   [tags: Indigenous Australians, Rabbit-Proof Fence]

Better Essays
1120 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about A Short Note On Feelings And Rejection Of Rejection

- Feelings of Rejection Discuss a time when you were rejected. This time when you were rejected should be something that was emotionally upsetting to you because the time you were rejected had important meaning to you. After the loss of my husband, my mother-in-law and I had disagreements that ended our relationship and I felt emotionally upset and rejected by her because of all the things she said. In addition, another incident was having an argument with my brother and he basically rejected me when I needed him the most....   [tags: Emotion, Feeling, Feelings, Psychology]

Better Essays
971 words (2.8 pages)

The Reality Of Reality Television Shows Essay

- Reality TV Show The beginning of reality television started with competition shows and with the time reality television shows began to appear more and more. There are many different types of reality shows, such as game competitions, cooking contests, talents, or real family life. That means there are many viewers have been increasing and they like these types of shows because it is fun and many people get interested to know what will happen next. Every reality television show has been known to every family and county but not all people like it, but it has advantages are more than disadvantages....   [tags: Reality television, Television]

Better Essays
809 words (2.3 pages)

The Reality Of Reality Television Essay

- The Effects of Reality Television The entertainment world is a billion-dollar industry that primarily focuses on generating future celebrities and addicting television series purposely created in order to increase viewers. Because of the creation of outrageous and unique television series, society has become strongly dependent on technology for their endless entertainment. Reality television has become so prevalent in today’s society, and it needs to be discussed on a more in depth level. Should reality television be restricted by any exterior forces....   [tags: Reality television, Television program]

Better Essays
1574 words (4.5 pages)

Essay about The Reality Of Reality Television

- Reality television is a very popular form of entertainment these days. Something about watching seemingly normal people make friends, make enemies, and fight on television really pulls the average American in. However, this could actually be very terrible. Researchers say that watching these reality television shows could actually be teaching people to overreact in reaction to normal, everyday occurrences. In fact, if this love of reality television keeps up, the nation may be facing a huge problem: people will actually start to believe that overreacting is the norm....   [tags: Reality television, Television, Aggression]

Better Essays
936 words (2.7 pages)

Rejection Essay

- Someone once told me that life is not always fair; that some days are better than others are. Men do not care for this rule and we want everyday to be great, perfect and full of joy; but deep down we know it cannot be. We refuse to accept the unfairness of life though; we resist in our own unique ways to every bad thing that happens in our lives. We have been known to resist violently, lashing out at others in rage; and we have been known to bear the pain ourselves without rage and violence....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1757 words (5 pages)

Proof Essay example

- Proof Proof. What is it and why does this simple term cause such a stir among mathematics educators and mathematics students. If you were to ask a young child to prove a mathematical fact, they would be happy to show you many examples of how it works. This does not constitute a proof but it is a step in the right direction. If you were to ask a high school student or first year college student to do a proof, you will most likely be met with groans and feelings of disgust. Students at this age have probably encountered proof in a geometry class where they were expected to follow a strict format without much freedom to express proofs on their own....   [tags: Math Education Papers]

Free Essays
3358 words (9.6 pages)