Reform Models in Collegiate Sports Essay

Reform Models in Collegiate Sports Essay

Length: 1187 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Over the past 100 years, college sports have attracted controversy pertaining to how they should be treated, that is, as business opportunities or academic vocation. Different reforms have been initiated, with academicians and researchers coming up with different models explaining how college sports and sports people should be treated. These models seek to understand and give directions on the need for balancing education with commercialized sports. Three key conceptual models have been initiated to reform college sports by scholars such as Craughron, Benford, Smith and Gerdy (Sack, 2009). In addition, Roy, Graeff & Harman (2008) underscore that these models include the intellect elitism, the athletes’ rights and academic capitalists. These three models represent varying views pertaining to the role of commercialized college sports in today’s learning education or higher education. This understanding portends that the major focus, despite their contrasting views, is on revenue generating sports, emphasizing the increasing stakeholder’s roles, including college athletes and institutions of higher learning. However, they vary on their interpretation of the relationship that exist academic values and sports commercialization, athletic scholarships legal status and educational impact and finally on higher education’s mission.
Intellectual elitism reformers are of the view that highly commercialization of college athletics negatively affects the higher education in America, as sale of athletic programs by universities to corporate sponsors or television networks leads to the trumping of academic values by television ratings (Sack, 2009). As a result, they argue that commercialization of college athletics make universities to admit stu...

... middle of paper ...

...ducation sector, and encouraged to balance their academics with sporting activities.

Works Cited

Roy, D. P., Graeff, T. R., & Harman, S. K. (2008). Repositioning a university through NCAA Division IA football membership. Journal of Sport Management, 22, 11-29.
Sack, A. (2009). Clashing Models of Commercial Sport in Higher Education: Implications for Reform and Scholarly Research. Journal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics, 2, 76-92
Slaughter, S., & Rhoades, G. (2004). Academic capitalism and the new economy: Markets, state, and higher education. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Sobocinski, E. J. (2000). College athletes: What is fair compensation? Marquette Sports Law Review, 7, pp. 257-294.
Svare, B. (2004). Reforming sports before the clock runs out: One man’s journey through our runaway sports culture. Delmar, NY: Bordalice Publishing.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Need for Reform in Collegiate Sports Essay

- The Need for Reform in Collegiate Sports The current institutional structure of intercollegiate athletics is attempting to maximize educational quality and athletic excellence simultaneously. Each of which will inevitably impinge on one another. Universities claim that their athletes are amateurs who are attending college for academic achievement and play sports in their free time. This is an impossible task for anybody. Higher education has entered the arena of big business with its athletic programs and with it many problems have emerged for coaches, athletes, and the athletic system itself....   [tags: science university athletics Essays Papers]

Strong Essays
1680 words (4.8 pages)

Collegiate Infractions Essay

- The NCAA and its student-athletes deal with much more than are seen by the general public. The coaches and players always have hidden agendas. Scandals or infractions are committed every year in collegiate sports and are left unnoticed. The NCAA does its best in trying to keep this under control but have difficulty doing so. Student-Athletes receiving improper benefits and breaking NCAA rules are a common group and information on these atrocities must be brought to light. The receiving of improper benefits expand over a wide range of topics and areas....   [tags: Collegiate Sports]

Strong Essays
1352 words (3.9 pages)

Collegiate Athletes Should be Paid? Essay

- For about a decade, the debate between whether collegiate athletes should be paid while playing has been contemplated. Now, the focus has moved from all sports to two specific areas, football and men’s basketball. Sprouting from many court cases filed against the NCAA to some ugly sandals dealing with the athletes themselves. In the 2010 – 2011 time frame, this controversy really sparked up chatter; eventually leading the current pled for sport reformation. Our student athletes are the ones who are at the expense here stuck in between this large argument....   [tags: ncaa, college sports, student athletes]

Strong Essays
1557 words (4.4 pages)

Collegiate Sports Essay

- Weston (2006) provided a more focused approach in describing the value of foreign signings in collegiate competition. However, instead of focusing on the financial gains associated with sustained success in division 1 competition, Weston discussed the benefits of international recruitment to collegiate sports as a whole to promote globalization and integration in collegiate sports. The term international student-athletes was used by Weston in referring to any foreign born student recruited by a university to play a specific sport in exchange for a college scholarship....   [tags: NCAA]

Strong Essays
1911 words (5.5 pages)

The Evolution and Corruption of Collegiate Sports Essay

- The twenty-first century has produced a society driven by economic success, capitalism, and class and power disparity. Social institutions reflect these ideologies. The world of sport, in particular, has been severely impacted by the corporate mentality, transforming it from a game run by athletes to a big business where the decision-making rests in the hands of national organizations and flows towards the sources of revenue. Sports have become more like work than play, with the primary emphasis being placed on winning rather than playing....   [tags: Current Events]

Strong Essays
1977 words (5.6 pages)

Literacy Models and Instructional Reform for Educators Essay

- ... Used correctly, balanced literacy has the potential to meet the needs of all students at their own individual level. All components of reading, including phonics, phonemic awareness, vocabulary, fluency, comprehension, speaking and listening, and writing are taught using this framework. Balanced literacy provides instruction by various methods. The use of read aloud, shared reading, guided reading, independent reading, word study, and writing are all used to provide students with a release of responsibility model in which they go from guided to independent work (Frey, 2005)....   [tags: reading comprehension, common core, leadership ]

Strong Essays
789 words (2.3 pages)

What’s Do To The Collegiate Athlete Essay

- What’s Do To The Collegiate Athlete Recently Duke University’s head basketball coach, Mike Krzyzewski, was the recipient of one point three million dollars in salary. The Duke University basketball program is amongst the best in all of college basketball. But, where do we draw the line. Where do we decide that the players, the ones actually out on the court deserve to be rewarded in the way that their coach is rewarded. It is not infrequently that we see a young man who has great basketball talent skip the collegiate ranks, and head straight for the professionals simply because they cannot afford to be a college student with no money....   [tags: Sports Education Finances Papers]

Strong Essays
683 words (2 pages)

Essay about Why Athletes are Good Role Models

- Why Athletes are Good Role Models Ever since the ancient years, we have admired athletes and the hard work that they do to achieve their goal of winning. We idolize them and wish we were more like them. What happens though when the realization sinks in that they are human too and that some of them do get greedy and selfish. A lot of athletes are model citizens that you should really look up to, but there are also some bad apples in the bunch that ruin it for everyone. Athletes can inspire young people to work hard so that their efforts can pay off, but no one is pure and flawless....   [tags: Athletes Athletics Sports Role Models Essays]

Strong Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Corruption in College Sports Essay

- Corruption in Collegiate Athletics Collegiate athletics in the United States, in particular N.C.A.A. (National Collegiate Athletic Association) Division I basketball and football, have become one of the most prominent forms of sports entertainment today. Like their professional counterparts, the economic stability of many university and college sports programs relies on the success of its teams. As a result, coaches and team officials have been subject to a great deal of criticism, as many have been using improper methods to recruit athletes for their teams....   [tags: Corruption in Collegiate Athletics]

Free Essays
902 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Sports Media

- Sports of old were merely competitive activities rooted in heroism and romanticism. Sports activities today, however, have no such innocence or simplicity. Currently in America, the activities that make up our sports culture is not only the competitive events themselves but the processes and issues that underlie and surround them. Entwined in our sports culture is the giant business of mass broadcasting. Indeed, sports and the media go hand in hand like peanut butter and jelly, like Mickey and Minnie, Darth Vader and Luke....   [tags: Sports]

Strong Essays
1050 words (3 pages)