The Rebellion That Never Happened : A Review Essay

The Rebellion That Never Happened : A Review Essay

Length: 912 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Insurrection That Never Happened: A Review
In Stephen Nissenbaum’s article, “ An Insurrection That Never Happened: ‘The Christmas Riots’,” he presents a somewhat convincing analysis of the social inequality, lack of government unison, and political movements to prove reconstruction was never completed. He does this by first explaining an example of the christmas riots, then continues to show its relevance and interpret it in the more general history of the time. Nissenbaum states, “The story of the ‘Christmas Riots’ of 1865 is a microcosm of the entire period that became known as reconstruction, the years between 1865 and 1877. It was a period of great hopes for the freedmen, hopes that were dashed, then raised, then dashed once again.” (15).
His arguments for his thesis can be grouped into political, economic, and finally social areas. Socially, acts such as the black codes, vagrancy fines, and the ku klux klan proved the majority of the whites society’s goal was to keep racial inequality where it was. Economically speaking, refusing to grant the slaves land after freedom, the 14th and 15th amendment which both having to be passed in order to allow adult males to vote, and the lack of education available for them made a steady income difficult. Finally, Mississippi and Texas refusing to sign the 13th amendment, the split congress which refused to accept nominations for political elections, and Mississippi being denied military assistance during elections proved that the efforts to put forth legislation was politically challenging. These were strong points because they were historically verifiable facts that supported the argument in his thesis.
The motive behind writing this piece is largely assumed, but also slightly ins...

... middle of paper ...

...essages and vague roundabout statements tends to lose the reader. For example, “For the first time in Southern history (and, as it happened, the last time for another century), black people were exercising real political power.”(16). This raises the question of what he considers all of southern history, why it hasn 't happened for another century, and what the real power is. This leads the reader on tangents which he does not follow up with.
Overall, Nissenbaum’s article, “An Insurrection That Never Happened: The ‘Christmas Riots’ of 1865” was a meaningful, but poorly executed message. It lost many readers with the odd structure, and confused many with the contradictory evidence, but the thesis was clear and the idea was successfully planted in the audience’s head. I feel that the main point of writing is to spread ideas or information, so, I consider him a success.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Review of the Article “How the West was Lost” Essays

- In the article review “ How the West was Lost” the author, William T. Hagan explains that in a brief thirty-eight year period between 1848 and 1886, the Indians of the Western United States lost their fight with the United States to keep their lands. While nothing in the article tells us who Hagan is, or when the article was written, his central theme of the article is to inform us of how the Indians lost their lands to the white settlers. I found three main ideas in the article that I feel that Hagan was trying to get across to us....   [tags: native americans, american history]

Better Essays
1092 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Wikipedia: A Reliable Source for Information?

- Wikipedia, an online information center, has significantly changed the face of encyclopedias and scholarly journals over the last ten years. It is quickly taking books, journals, and money out of the equation for research. Wikipedia has created a new way to gather information, social network, and do research. Although Wikipedia has its positive uses it is not always a reliable source and is best used as a starting point for research. In March 2000 Wikipedia started out as with a review board of experts....   [tags: Website Review]

Better Essays
1021 words (2.9 pages)

What It Has Never Happened? Essay example

- “From my experience they seek acknowledgment of their presence. We can provide encouragement for them to move on, but ultimately, it is their choice whether to leave or stay. If they need help with an unresolved issue, that’s where I come in. “As far invading a person’s environment, I did hear from a psychic in our group who had a spirit take control of her body. She said it was a momentary occurrence, but a frightening one. I don’t know how long a spirit can remain in a living body or how it happens in the first place....   [tags: Want, Need, WANT, 2004 singles]

Better Essays
1465 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Rebellion for Change

- In life there are many situations where rebellion is required for change and improvement. Some are simple, like growing up and learning not to do certain things and others are more complex like when a group of people stand up for what they believe, for example, women’s rights and black’s rights. I believe that rebellion is healthy for any growing society. There are many things that we do not agree with, whether it is the law or our parent’s instructions. By rebelling we can change our society and/or ourselves for better....   [tags: rebellion, teenagers,]

Better Essays
1253 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on The War that Never Happened: The Aroostook War

- The Aroostook War never happened, but it certainly mattered. To the west, a few thousand New England militiamen walked north through Maine, some funding was appropriated, and one militiaman died of measles. To the east, New Brunswick moved some troops up the Saint John River and mobilized some local irregulars itself. Administrators of the disputed area from both sides were arrested, and confined, respectively, in Houlton and Fredericton. Fighting never broke out, and by the end of the winter of 1839, both American and colonial forces had withdrawn from the area....   [tags: Daniel Webster and Lord Ashburton's treaty]

Better Essays
1572 words (4.5 pages)

The Columbine Shooting Might Never Have Even Happened Essay

- I believe that one theme of this book is, that you should always watch what you say, how you act, etc. around others. You never know what someone may be going through or what might be going through their head. Eric and Dylan were not born craving murder, throughout their lives people turned them to be that way. Imagine if even only one person stepped up, and decided to invite the “outcasts” to social events or reached a hand out to those who seem in need of a friend. Maybe something as small as a smile could have changed Eric and Dylan’s plan, the Columbine shooting might never have even happened....   [tags: Columbine High School massacre]

Better Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Revolution That Never Happened

- 1789 marked a historic year in the struggles against slavery in the French colony of Saint-Domingue. The French Revolution played an important part in influencing the Haitian Revolution of 1791; it gave way to the Haitian Revolution which consisted of many other separate revolutions that occurred at the same time. Saint-Domingue, now known as Haiti, had the most wealth in terms of crops that could be excavated by black slaves. Toussaint l’Overture was a former black slave who was forced to pick up these crops; little did he know he was the person who sparked the Haitian Revolution....   [tags: International Conflict ]

Better Essays
1202 words (3.4 pages)

The Future Never Just Happened, It Was Created Essay

- The Future Never Just Happened, It Was Created My philosophy on education is that it is important to instill values and knowledge into our children at an early age to ensure a great future for them as well as enhancing their contributions to society. Will and Ariel Durant famous for several quotations on life and civilization summed up how important education is for the future of our children and society. "We have to help children take advantage of education so they can have the best future possible for themselves and the rest of society." I have a strong belief that education is the key to a prosperous happy future for our children and the future leaders of tomorrow's society....   [tags: Teaching Philosophy Education Essays]

Free Essays
829 words (2.4 pages)

Essay The Boxer Rebellion in China

- The Boxer Rebellion in China “China never wanted foreigners any more than foreigners wanted China men, and on this question I am with the Boxers every time. The Boxer is a patriot. He loves his country better than he does the countries of other people. I wish him success. The Boxer believes in driving us out of his country. I am a Boxer too, for I believe in driving him out of our country” – Mark Twain, Berkeley Lyceum, New York, Nov 23, 1900. The Boxer Rebellion soul purpose was to liberate China from foreign influence....   [tags: Boxer Rebellion Chinese History Essays]

Better Essays
1394 words (4 pages)

Book Review of Rebellion in the Backlands by Euclides da Cunha Essay

- Book Review of "Rebellion in the Backlands" By Euclides da Cunha Rebellion in the Backlands is set in the Northeastern backlands of Brazil. It is basically, a historical narration of a period of time (1896 and 1897) where the government of the Republic of Brazil decided to wage war against a religious group of people of about 5000. This group of people, lead by a charismatic religious leader named Antonio Conselheiro, did not accept the Brazilian government as their legitimate government and was therefore deemed a threat to the rest of the country....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
837 words (2.4 pages)