Reasons For Judgment Of The Second Full Court Essay example

Reasons For Judgment Of The Second Full Court Essay example

Length: 1114 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A. Reasons for judgment of the second Full Court

The second Full Court held that:

Mr Fernando could be ordered to pay the Commonwealth’s costs notwithstanding his disability.

Mr Fernando had been heard on the issue, notwithstanding counsel for the litigation representative’s claim to the contrary.

B. The costs order against Mr Fernando

The Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) [the Rules] draw no distinction between a mentally disabled person or minor:

person under a legal incapacity means: 

(a) a minor; or 

(b) a mentally disabled person.

mentally disabled person means a person who, because of a mental disability or illness, is not capable of managing the person’s own affairs in a proceeding.

The authorities relied upon by the Court

The Court relied upon three authorities that “suggest that a costs order may be made against Mr Fernando”: Fernando v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCAFC 181 at [16].

Rhodes v Swithenbank. In that case the Master of the Rolls gave two reasons why costs orders could not be made against the infant: she was impecunious, and apparently disabled for life. The latter could be seen as the more persuasive as the Court had been referred by counsel to earlier cases in which it had been held that costs could not be awarded against an infant. In Grave v Grave Cro. Eliz. 33 in 1653 it was held: “If an infant brings trespass by guardian, and afterwards he was nonsuit, he shall render no costs.” The same case was referred to with approval in Turner v Turner 2 P. Wms. 297; Str. 708 where in 1726 the Chief Justice said:

I do not find any case has been cited where an infant plaintiff has been obliged to pay costs either at law or in equity: and in Cro. Eliz. 33, Grave v Grave, an infant brought trespass...

... middle of paper ...

...Mr Ley as next friend: Rhodes v Swithenbank. He or she was not, however, a party to the action: Pink v J A Sharwood & Co Limited, per Eve J. He derived his authority from the Court, not Mr Fernando, and could have been removed if, for example, he had acted improperly, or was found to have had an interest adverse to that of Mr Fernando: Stephenson v Geiss; Simpson on the Law of Infants. Not only was he obliged by his appointment to act in the best interests of Mr Fernando, but also in a manner that might be unpalatable to him if he deemed that to be appropriate.

Dr Cameron, as he submitted to the Full Court, acted solely for Mr Ley, and did not, and could not have acted for Mr Fernando. In that capacity, he raised none of the issues, and referred to none of the authorities set out above. Mr Fernando was not heard prior to the costs order being made against him.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Summary Judgment Of The Supreme Court 's Ruling Essay

- This case is a summary judgment of the Supreme Court’s ruling. The Federal government enacted legislation (23 U.S.C § 131) to prohibit billboards within 600 feet of the right-of-way of federal interstate and major highways in 1958 and then strengthened in 1965. In rural areas, billboards were prohibited from been seen from highways. The Federal government allowed commercial and industrial areas “under agreements between the state and federal Secretary of Transportation.” The City of San Diego enacted Ordinance No....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)

The Court System And The Criminal Justice System Essay

- In this essay, I will be examining how the court system can fail to deliver justice for particular cases and people’s circumstances, as well as looking at alternatives to court, like circle sentencing, restorative sentencing and alternatives for children to the formal court system, as outlined in the Young Offenders Act 1997 (NSW). Crime is defined in the Oxford Dictionary as an action or omission which constitutes an offence and is punishable by law. On the other side of this is justice; the quality of being fair and reasonable....   [tags: Crime, Law, Criminal justice]

Better Essays
1519 words (4.3 pages)

The Debate on Gun Control and the Second Amendment Essay

- Guns have been around for a very long time. People love being able to have the freedom to do what they want, especially when they can possess something that make them feel superior. The introduction of the Second Amendment opens up the controversial, yet well anticipated opportunity for United State citizens to be able to own guns. Americans enjoy the benefit of being able to own guns for decades over people in other countries. People can buy guns and carry them around in public. They own guns for many reasons such as to hunt, to protect themselves, and simply to satisfy their desire of owning a gun, but in recent years, the issue of people carry guns has become a problem....   [tags: Gun Control Essays]

Better Essays
1119 words (3.2 pages)

International criminal court Essay

- ICC and America Over the past few years, the International Criminal Court (ICC or “the Court”) has been igniting controversy the world over. As more countries rallied behind it, more objections have been made, particularly from Americans, regarding what many view as fundamental flaws. I have chosen two papers to compare and contrast the different viewpoints taken by the authors when reflecting upon America’s involvement with the ICC. One calls for total rejection of the ICC, the other weighs the risks and benefits and calls for revision but acceptance....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Better Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Case Analysis : Florence Hayes

- Based on the relevant background, On May 31, 2005, Florence Hayes was 95 years old, and she was applied and admitted to go to Oakridge, a nursing home in Ohio. In the agreement contract, there was written for whoever signed this form, they agreed to submit any of future malpractice claims against Oakridge to arbitration and waive their right to recover punitive damages and attorney fee (2). Hayes alleged that she had suffered injuries from fall while she was a resident at Oakridge. She assumed directly it was the fault and/or recklessness of Oakridge and/or its officers (3)....   [tags: Appeal, Jury, Court, Appellate court]

Better Essays
729 words (2.1 pages)

Whalen v. J.P. Morgan Chase Essay

- Introduction Human Resources (HR) is responsible for monitoring employee job classifications. The framework of the job description and job analysis ensures a company is compliant and compensates employees fairly. Companies have two options for determining how to categorize their workers, based on the Fair Standards Labor Act (FSLA); employers must recognize an employee job classification as an exempt employee or non-exempt employee. The guidelines suggest the nature of the work performed by the employee determines which classification a company selects....   [tags: Overtime Pay Court Case]

Better Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Civil Rights Opportunity Commission Vs. Abercrombie And Fitch Store

- American civil rights are dedicated to protect citizens against all types of discrimination regardless a resident race, religion, background, this protection goes the same to public discrimination as well private discrimination and so forth. The case called Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Abercrombie and Fitch Store, Inc (religious case) illustrate the importance and power of civil rights defended by U.S Supreme Court as well its possible limitation to rule similar religious cases in different concept....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

The V City Of Cincinnati Essays

- Pembaur v City of Cincinnati Et Al. 475 U.S. 469 (1986) The decision was a 6-3 decision. The Justices that agreed with the ruling of the court were Brennan, Marshall, Blackmun, White, Stevens, and O’Connor. The Justices that did not agree were Powell, Berger, and Rehnquist. Facts: According to the case Pembaur v. City of Cincinnati (1986), an Ohio physician was being investigated for fraud. During the course of the investigation, it was necessary to interview two employees from his practice....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1297 words (3.7 pages)

Justice Clarence Thomas Essay example

- Justice Clarence Thomas was born in June 1948 and grew up in Georgia. He graduated at Yale Law School and served as the Assistant Attorney General in Missouri, practicing law in the private sector. In 1981 he was appointed Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights at the U.S. Department of Education one year later, Justice Thomas was appointed Chairman of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission by President Ronald Reagan. By 1991 Justice Thomas was nominated by Bush to fill Thurgood Marshall’s seat on the United States Supreme Court....   [tags: Supreme Court, Biography]

Better Essays
1384 words (4 pages)

Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

- In current society, legalizing physician assisted suicide is a prevalent argument. In 1997, the Supreme Court recognized no federal constitutional right to physician assisted suicide (Harned 1) , which defines suicide as one receiving help from a physician by means of a lethal dosage (Pearson 1), leaving it up to state legislatures to legalize such practice if desired. Only Oregon and Washington have since legalized physician assisted suicide. People seeking assisted suicide often experience slanted judgments and are generally not mentally healthy....   [tags: supreme court, mental disorder, suicidal]

Better Essays
1128 words (3.2 pages)