The Quiet American By Graham Greene And For Whom The Bell Tolls Essay

The Quiet American By Graham Greene And For Whom The Bell Tolls Essay

Length: 1523 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

War, love, race, and the meaning of life all play huge roles in The Quiet American by Graham Greene and For Whom the Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway. The depiction of Americans intertwined with the themes of war, love, race, and the meaning of life are quite similar, but at the same time very different. In Greene’s novel the depiction of Americans is seen through Alden Pyle who is young, inexperienced, naive, and careless. Alternatively Hemingway’s American character Robert Jordan is Pyle’s complete opposite being that he’s experienced and aware of the actions he does. Whereas Pyle fights against the native people; Jordan fights among the people. While both novels portray a similar idea of American 's self-righteous duty, through these two characters this righteousness is displayed differently.
The Quiet American takes place during the Indochina war that took place during 1946-1954. It is set in Vietnam and is way more modern than the setting of For Whom the Bell Tolls, which takes place during the Spanish War in 1937. The setting of that novel takes place in the mountains and caves, whereas the quiet American takes place in a city.
In the Quiet American Fowler a British journalist introduces us to Pyle who is a young, naive American official and a frenemy to Fowler. There is a lot of conflict between Fowler and Pyle not only because Pyle wants Fowlers woman, but also because Fowler views Pyle as foolish and young; a typical American. Pyle represents the entitled American coming into to save the land; blinded by what he believes that this land needs he is ignorant to the fact that he may be hurting more people than he 's actually helping. “Yes. They killed him because he was too innocent to live. He was young and ignorant and sill...

... middle of paper ...

...he local people are background characters who are portrayed as inhumane and disposable. Although Americans are displayed similarly throughout both; Robert displays a self-aware resentful American, and Pyle displays an aloof, unsympathetic American. While they both believe heavily in the cause, Robert actually doubts what he is doing is right even though he is insistent on carrying out his American duties. This leaves a question on what good intentions are and if the end really justifies the means. While the Quiet American displays Americans walking against the local people For Whom the Bell Tolls represents the Americans walking with the people. Even though these two depictions are quite different in the end they both payed for the harms they had done as Americans through their deaths. At the end they both fought for the cause no matter who or what got in their way.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on `` For Whom The Bell Tows `` By Ernest Hemingway And The Quiet American

- Americans, Just Americans America the great, America the free, America the motherland of dreams. Do these words sound familiar whenever you hear the United States being portrayed. Most likely, right?, and indeed several might agree with those statements, especially Americans. Americans have a long historical trajectory built from political hardships and glories, which have been depicted in several ways. In the following two works, “For Whom the Bell Tows” by Ernest Hemingway and “The Quiet American” by Graham Greene, we can perceive the different roles that Americans are portrayed by....   [tags: Graham Greene, The Quiet American, Vietnam War]

Better Essays
1563 words (4.5 pages)

Graham Green's The Quiet American Essay

- Graham Green's The Quiet American The Quiet American by Graham Green is a story set during the Vietnam War before the United States became involved. The main character is Thomas Fowler, an English Reporter stationed in Vietnam. The story follows approximately six months of his life where he is faced with personal, professional, and ethical trials. The story also follows closely, the lives of two close friends, Pyle and Phuong. Each of the three main characters are from a different country, and they were used to represent it....   [tags: Graham Green Vietnam War Essays]

Better Essays
964 words (2.8 pages)

Essay The Quiet American by Graham Greene

- ... Suspecting that Pyle is already dead, Fowler goes back to Phuong as if nothing had ever happened. Later that evening, French officer Vigot pays Fowler and Phoung a visit to tell them that Pyle has been murdered. Vigot does not care about solving the case of Pyle’s murder and Phuong easily moves on after hearing her fiancée has been murdered. This makes Fowler wonder if he was the only one who actually cared about Pyle. When faced with the dilemma of Pyle and the bombing, Fowler is forced to reject his apathetic nature and full heartedly act in order to do what is right....   [tags: novel analysis]

Better Essays
1413 words (4 pages)

Innocence in In Graham Greene's The Quiet American Essay

- Innocence, Ignorance, and Idealism In Graham Greene's The Quiet American, the themes of naivety and innocence are in constant and direct conflict with the reality and crudeness of the Vietnam War. Sometimes Greene sees innocent people as helpless victims of the devastation others wreak, like the soldiers who are killed when Fowler and Pyle shelter in their tower. More often though, he regards innocence as a kind of pre-moral condition. There are frequent references to the ignorance of the innocent character of Alden Pyle....   [tags: War, Vietnam, Ignorance]

Better Essays
925 words (2.6 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' The Quiet American Phuong Acts ' By Graham Greene

- The Indochinese war revolved around the end of French colonialism in Vietnam and the start of Ho Chi Minh’s communist reign. By the end of the war Vietnam was split into two parts the North, communist, side and the South, democratic, side. The French fought to maintain their power over Vietnam while the United States fought against communism there. In Graham Greene’s book The Quiet American Phuong acts as a symbol of Vietnam, while other characters like Pyle represents the United States and Fowler, Britain....   [tags: Vietnam War, Ho Chi Minh, United States]

Better Essays
1152 words (3.3 pages)

Personal Battles within Characters in a Novel Essay

- In Graham Greene's The Quiet American, Greene uses the characters Alden Pyle, Thomas Fowler, and Phuong to represent a greater picture and show how the characters all work through mental obstacles. Their political doctrines actively collide and merge with the cultural customs they bring with them to the novel. The result is that these characters have a double meaning. They become allegorical for the larger world events around them, symbolizing Greene's opinions of the politics of empire-building....   [tags: graham greene, quiet american]

Better Essays
950 words (2.7 pages)

The Quiet American Essay

- "The Quiet American" How long can you sit on the fence and not get involved. How long before you're forced to choose sides. Thomas Fowler learns the answers to this dilemma the hard way. Fowler at the onset of our story, describes himself as being an objective observer, purposely not taking sides, just telling over the facts. "My fellow journalists called themselves correspondents; I preferred the title of reporter. I wrote what I saw, I took no action- even an opinion is a kind of action. (20)" He even goes to the extent of frequently using opium so as not to have an opinion about his own well being....   [tags: Graham Greene]

Better Essays
1281 words (3.7 pages)

The Quiet American Essay

- Lois T. Stover (2001), a prominent academic in the field of young adult literature, states that, "Good young adult literature deals with the themes and issues that mirror the concerns of society out of which it is produced.” Graham Greene's novel, The Quiet American, complexly reflects upon the role of bystanders in society, who resort to apathy in difficult circumstances which do not affect them. Through the character of Fowler, the novel demonstrates that no one can remain uninvolved because his or her morals or feelings will inevitably be impacted by events around them....   [tags: young adult readers, message]

Better Essays
1048 words (3 pages)

The Characters of For Whom the Southern Belle Tolls Essay

- The Characters of For Whom the Southern Belle Tolls      For Whom the Southern Belle Tolls is Christopher Durang's hilarious 1994 parody of The Glass Menagerie, a 1945 play by Tennessee Williams. In both plays, the main characters must deal with several serious problems, including isolation, fear of the outside world, and the need for understanding. Whereas the characters in The Glass Menagerie handle their problems in a relatively serious manner, those in For Whom the Southern Belle Tolls take a more farcical approach....   [tags: For Whom the Southern Belle Tolls Essays]

Better Essays
1235 words (3.5 pages)

The Quiet American Essay

- The Quiet American The film The Quiet American takes place during the 1950’s in Vietnam. The movie illustrates the atmosphere of Vietnam previous to the Vietnam War and during the French occupation of the country. The main plot of the movie revolves around three characters: Fowler played by Michael Caine, Pyle played by Brendan Fraiser, and Phoung played by Do Thi Hai Yen. For the duration of the movie the three main characters are involved in a semi love triangle. This triangle and the emotions that the male characters feel towards Phoung begin to characterize the way they feel about the country of Vietnam itself....   [tags: Films Movies Vietnam War Essays]

Better Essays
756 words (2.2 pages)