Questioning the Fate of Antigone Essay

Questioning the Fate of Antigone Essay

Length: 914 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I chose to write my essay over a topic revolving around the question of whether Antigone’s death could have been saved or whether it was even changeable. The article The Death of Antigone wrote by Joseph S. Morgan gives opinions by the writer that suggests answers to these questions. Joseph explains the opinion of scholars that suggest that Creon could have chosen the fate of Antigone or Creon was unable to save Antigone. He does not seem to agree or disagree with the opinions being held, rather explaining why each opinion is not questionable.
Joseph Morgan’s article is based on opinions of scholars who question whether Creon could have changed Antigone’s fate. He starts his article off by stating few scholars question if Creon would have chosen to bury Antigone’s brother if her life would have been saved. “Yet scholars have shown surprisingly little concern for this question,” (Morgan 177). While many others do not show any interest and simply agree with the outcome of the play. (…by their silence, perhaps indicate a tacit agreement with Jebb, who believes that there is no way of ascertaining whether Antigone could have been saved,” (177). I would agree that Antigone’s fate was already chosen. If Creon would have chosen to bury Polyneices then Antigone would not have been able to show the evil that was Creon.
Joseph Morgan thinks that the scholars who believed Antigone could have been saved were just accusations rather than having any facts to back up their opinions. He suggests that their only fact was that Creon should have gone into the cave first and rescued Antigone before going to his son. His argument suggest that Creon did not have any backing information to let him know the ...

... middle of paper ...

... Creon led to the suicide of Haemon and Eurydice though fate had already been decided. Haemon wanted to support Antigone’s decision and he confronted his father which sparked outrage in Creon. Haemon commits suicide which results in Eurydice committing suicide after hearing the news. Creon is now left with the burden of his family’s death in his hands. He too wants his life to be taken but the Gods will not have it. He needs to suffer in order to know the pain he has caused others.

Works Cited

Morgan, Joseph S. “The Death of Antigone”. California Studies in Classical Antiquity , Vol. 3, (1970), pp. 177-183 . University of California Press. Web. 13 Nov. 2013.
Harrison, Gary, David M. Johnson, and John F. Crawford. "Antigone." The Bedford Anthology of World Literature. By Paul B. Davis. Compact ed. Vol. 1. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin's, 2009. 672-91. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Antigone: The Conflict of Hubris, Fate, and The gods Essay

- Antigone: The Conflict of Hubris, Fate, and The gods Sophocles, Antigone is a classic example of the role of the gods in the life of a Grecian. It is a story of the precedent set by the gods, versus the will and actions of the characters of Antigone. Creon deceives himself into believing that he is upholding the laws set by the gods. While he would like to think of himself as being above the gods, even he can not deny their power. The humans were to revere the gods above all else, despite any obstacles that tried to displace them....   [tags: Sophocles Antigone Gods Papers]

Better Essays
3094 words (8.8 pages)

Essay on Antigonem by Sophocles

- People are undisputedly faced with the challenge to grow and encounter headfirst all the unexpected changes life throws at them. Change, perhaps the solitary constant factor of life, drives people to make decisions that will be reciprocated with an unforeseen event. This principle of life is applied as an underlying web of the plethora of ironies throughout all of Antigone. Set in the age of reconstruction in Thebes, no doubt due to the aftershock of a war between brothers and their ongoing family curse, Sophocles’s constant use of irony in Antigone around Creon, the king of Thebes, indicates that the ironic nature of man contributes and lurks in their ultimate demise....   [tags: Play Analysis, Change]

Better Essays
972 words (2.8 pages)

The Tragic Downfalls of Creon and Antigone in Sophocles' Antigone Essays

- The hubris resonating throughout the play, ‘Antigone’ is seen in the characters of Creon and Antigone. Their pride causes them to act impulsively, resulting in their individual downfalls. In his opening speech, Creon makes his motives clear, that “no man who is his country’s enemy shall call himself my friend.” This part of his declaration was kept to the letter, as he refused burial for his nephew, Polynices. However, when the situation arises where it is crucial that Creon takes advice, he neglects the part of the speech where he says “a king......   [tags: antigone]

Better Essays
712 words (2 pages)

Fate in Antigone, Beowulf, and the World Essay

- The concept of fate in the lives of men and woman is something that has been around for as long as history has been recorded. However it feels like fate works better as a tool for writers through the ages, than as a way to know the true path of people’s lives. Religion is something that has been interwoven with fate, however the concept can be too easily manipulated in the world for it to tell the story of an entire life. In the end, the only thing that all men and women are fated to do is die, and even that is not determined until the day that it happens....   [tags: religion, death, fame]

Better Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Reasons for Antigone as the Title Essay

- Antigone says of her decision: “I didn't say yes. I can say no to anything I say vile, and I don't have to count the cost. But because you said yes, all that you can do, for all your crown and your trappings, and your guards—all that your can do is to have me killed.” Whenever an object receives a title, some people will disagree with the name. Some people feel that certain songs should consist of different names, some books should possess alternative titles, and some plays would better represent their meaning under different names....   [tags: Titles, Antigone]

Better Essays
889 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about Fate, Loyalty, and Law in Antigone

- Fate, Loyalty, and Law in Antigone The play Antigone by Sophocles is a play like no other. There are three major themes or ideas which have a very important role in the play. The first major theme is fate, on how the play comes about and the turn of events that come about throughout it. Another main theme or idea is the pride the characters have and their unwillingness they have to change their minds once they are set on something. The last major theme is loyalty and the practical problem of conduct involving which is a higher law between the divine laws and those of the humans....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1568 words (4.5 pages)

The Death of Antigone Essay

- In Sophocles’ Antigone, Antigone saw her action of burying her brother as a just one. It may not have been just in the eyes of Creon and the people of Thebes, but she was not concerned with the laws that mortals had made. Antigone saw the divine laws of the gods to be much more important than those of mortals. She felt that if she died while upholding the laws of the gods, that her afterlife would be better than if she had not. Our lives on this earth are so short, that to see a good afterlife over the horizon will make people go against the laws of humans....   [tags: Essays on Antigone]

Free Essays
1198 words (3.4 pages)

charant Sophocles' Antigone Essays: The Character of Antigone

- Antigone    In the story of Antigone, two very headstrong people's beliefs are matched up against each other. Creon, the king, made it law that no traitor to the Kingdom shall have a proper burial, instead they will be left laying on the ground to rot and to be eaten by the animals. This was the case of Antigone's brother, Polyneices. Antigone's love for her brother was so great that she went against the law, even though she knew Creon's punishment for breaking the law was public stoning, which ultimately resulted in death....   [tags: Antigone essays]

Free Essays
865 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on The Tragedy of Sophocles' Antigone

- The Tragedy of Antigone In the story of Antigone, Oedipus has already died, his two sons. Polyneices and Eteocles, left to contend for the throne of Thebes. In their contention for the throne, the two brothers slay one another, leaving Creon once again to be the acting regent of Thebes. With this power, Creon declares that Polyneices must be left to rot on the battlefield, the highest disgrace to any Greek. Antigone, daughter of Oedipus, is left torn between state of family, and in the end, chooses family over state....   [tags: Antigone essays]

Better Essays
963 words (2.8 pages)

Fate Essay example

- Fate Webster defines fate as a “ a power thought to control all events and impossible to resist” “a persons destiny.” This would imply that fate has an over whelming power over the mind. This thing called fate is able to control a person and that person has no ability to change it. Its been proven time and time again that the human mind can over come any obstacle. An asset to the mind is a persons will. With the combination of a person’s mind and their will to decide their own destiny this thing called fate can be over come....   [tags: Fate Destiny Essays]

Free Essays
442 words (1.3 pages)