The Question of Amnesty: Balancing Truth and Justice Essay

The Question of Amnesty: Balancing Truth and Justice Essay

Length: 3102 words (8.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Amnesties and the Views of Victims
For many victims of violence, human rights advocates and many others affected by human rights violations, amnesties represent the basest of pragmatic accommodations with former despots, murderers, and torturers. At first thought, amnesties do not give the impression of working at the victim’s favor but for the benefit of political leaders, elites and the perpetrators themselves. When societies accept amnesty, victims assume a position of forgetting the past actions of military and political power for the concept of forgiveness. Rights such as truth and justice are sacrificed for political stability. Where amnesties deny victims their rights to truth, justice, and reparations, they can potentially aggravate the victims’ suffering by shrouding the impunity cast by a blanket amnesty and denying victims full recognition of their suffering. The choice for transitional governments addressing past crimes is often framed in a false dichotomy: peace verses justice. This however, is not the case.
Treating peace verses justice as polar ends of a spectrum assumes positions in extremes of entirely forgiving and forgetting the past through blanket amnesty laws for the sake of reconciliation or pursuing retributive justice against every perpetrator of human rights violations at the risk of disestablishing delicate political transitions. This paper will argue that amnesties are proactive incentives toward peace, justice and truth, not simply exclusive toward one over another. Despite the potentially damaging consequences of amnesty laws for victims and the frequent condemnation of amnesties as a denial of victims’ rights, there are examples from countries such as Uganda of civil society groups lobbying i...

... middle of paper ..., Payam. "Are International Criminal Tribunals a Disincentive to Peace?: Reconciling Judicial Romanticism with Political Realism." Human Rights Quarterly 31 (2009): 624-54.

Cronin-Furman, Kate. “Managing Expectations: International Criminal Trials and the Prospects for Deterrence of Mass Atrocity” in The International Journal of Transitional Justice. Vol. 7, No. 3 (2013): 434-454.

Mallinder, Louise. "Can Amnesties and International Justice Be Reconciled?" The International Journal of Transitional Justice 1.2 (2007): 208-30.

McEvoy, Kieran. Journal of Law and Society: Amnesties in Transition: Punishment, Restoration, and the Governance of Mercy. 3. 39. New York: Cardiff University Law School, 2012. 243. Print.

Vinjamuri, Leslie. “Deterrence, Democracy, and the Pursuit of International Justice.” In Ethics and International Affairs 24:2 (2010): 191-211.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Balancing Justice and Rehabilitation Essay

- Ideally, everyone is safe from harm because people care for one another with compassion. However, most only care for themselves, and worse, some individuals actually jeopardize and disrupt the well-being of the public. It is easy to label them all as immoral, but circumstances differ when they are young offenders. While it cannot keep everyone on track, the multistep juvenile justice system determines adolescent offenders’ consequences to provide them a chance for change and rehabilitation, making it overall effective and fair to juveniles and the community....   [tags: The Juvenile Justice System]

Research Papers
547 words (1.6 pages)

The Theory Of Truth Determines A True Statement Essay

- A. Justice B. Definitions a. Elenchus is a method of questioning someone to test for how genuine and consistent they are in something that was said earlier. b. Lying is an act of deliberately deceiving or telling false statements with an intention c. BS is someone who acts like they know what they’re talking about but in reality either doesn’t or does not care d. Proposition is a statement that expresses a statement that is uncertain. It could be true or false. e. Correspondence theory of truth determines a true statement by seeing how it relates and corresponds with the world f. An argument is a discussion where individuals express their diverse sentiments about a topic....   [tags: Morality, Truth, Justice, Existentialism]

Research Papers
1886 words (5.4 pages)

Justice in The Republic by Socrates Essay

- In The Republic, Socrates tries to find the answer to a debatable question. What is justice. Throughout Book 1, he is given a couple of definitions that were at first incoherent to him and so he decided to clear them up by questioning Cephalus’s and his son Polemarchus’s definitions of “justice” . In Book 1, Socrates is about to leave from a religious festival when a group of men stopped him and convinced him to stay for the late night festivities. In the meantime, Socrates will be given a detour to Polemarchus’s home....   [tags: justice, truth, good]

Research Papers
519 words (1.5 pages)

The Second Truth About The Balancing Act Essay

- The second truth about the balancing act is all about learning the balance of saying ‘yes’ and ‘no’. You simply cannot say ‘yes’ to everything, whether it is children’s parties or work-related things. But the thing to remember is that saying ‘yes’ isn’t even necessary. First, you’ve already defined your goals in the above step. This means you have the plan to work towards your goals. If you are asked to do something, you need to think whether it helps you closer to your priority or not. If it doesn’t and you have ten million other things to do, just say ‘no’....   [tags: Thing, Mother, Want, Paisley Park Records]

Research Papers
778 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about Efficient Distributed Dynamic Load Balancing

- Introduction Load balancing is the strategy of load redistribution among the computational elements(CE) of a heterogeneous network where they work cooperatively so that large loads can be distributed among them in a fair and effective manner. Load Balancing strategies ensure that the workload is distributed over all CEs according to their processing speed and availability in such a way that the overall execution time is minimized. But there are a wide variety of issues that need to be considered for heterogeneous environment....   [tags: Distributed Load Balancing]

Free Essays
3035 words (8.7 pages)

Essay on A Brief Note On The Criminal Justice System

- In the Criminal Justice System, legal proceedings in court trials follow a systematic institutional structure, where the attorney or officer has control over the case. However, when dealing with “vulnerable witnesses”, differing linguistic development or comprehension levels interrupt these institutional roles. Children under the age of 17 undergo a different legalistic process in interviews, as well as the mentally disabled. Previously, interview procedures were conducted on any client, regardless of background differences....   [tags: Question, Interview, Criminal justice]

Research Papers
721 words (2.1 pages)

The Justice System : An Aspect Of The System Essay

- To get a more in depth look into the justice system I focused on an aspect of the system I find very crucial to society, Incarceration. I believe that people should serve time for the crimes they have committed and so does my interviewee, Terry Burroughs. Officer Burroughs is a corrections officer at NYSDOC (Queensboro Correctional Facility). This was a very informative process that I am elated to share. Terry burroughs has been a corrections officer for over 16 years. When I asked him about his typical day all he could really tell me was there is no “typical day.” Officer Burroughs job keeps him on his toes....   [tags: Prison, Criminal justice, Penology, Question]

Research Papers
1278 words (3.7 pages)

Truth, Justice and Reconciliation in Latin America Essay

- As the head of the national reconciliation commission in Latin America, I will be addressing the different pathways towards reconciliation. The different pathways towards reconciliation I will make my recommendation off of are the Truth Commissions, Justice, and Forgiveness. Additionally, to support my points and arguments towards the idea that Latin American should move forward with reconciliation is I will be discussing the case studies about Guatemala and Argentina. Drawing upon these case studies about Guatemala and Argentina will allow for me to back up the Truth Commissions, Justice, and Forgiveness pathways....   [tags: International Conflict ]

Research Papers
1550 words (4.4 pages)

The Fundamental Question Of Condition Essay

- Socrates was an insightful philosopher who had an opinion on all the basic fundamental questions. He had very strong beliefs that he willed others into believing through questioning and proving ignorance in others beliefs. He has particular views on every fundamental question and particular views on how people should live their lives. He says God has spoken to him about philosophy and says that it is his destiny and it is his calling in life. Through philosophy he searches for answers to the fundamental questions and gains wisdom and knowledge....   [tags: Soul, Socrates, Plato, Question]

Research Papers
1492 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on The Truth

- The “Truth”      Every thought that ever entered our mind is a consequence of our struggle to reach out for the truth. Since our early age we have been thought to believe that there has to be right and wrong and we continuously searched for the “correct” answer. Unlike school’s multiple choice tests, life thought us that there is more than one correct answer. At one point we learned that some questions don’t have answers at all, or they are way too complex for our mind to understand them. Yet we never stopped struggling to reach out for the ultimate truth....   [tags: Definition True Truth Philosophy Essays]

Research Papers
1282 words (3.7 pages)