Qualitative Research Critique Essay

Qualitative Research Critique Essay

Length: 1821 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Article Citation
Gilmartin, J. (2003). Day surgery: Patients’ perceptions of a nurse-led preadmission clinic. Journal of Clinical Nursing 13, 243-250.

Initial Reaction
This research article is from the UK and the writer questions if the findings from this study will have heuristic relevance and applicability to nursing and healthcare in the United States (U.S.). Primary healthcare in the UK is provided through the National Health Service (NHS); this writer has little knowledge as to how it works and its impact on patient care and nursing. This limited knowledge may introduce bias in this critique.

Descriptive Vividness
The significance of this study is to determine if a preadmission clinic process can be developed and implemented to positively impact the physical, psychological, and social healthcare needs of patients undergoing day surgery. The purpose of this study is “to elucidate patients’ perceptions of the preassessment preparation prior to day surgery” (Gilmartin, 2003, p. 244).
This researcher identifies four themes related to patients’ perceptions of the preassessment preparation prior to day surgery; efficient functioning, assessment of patient suitability, the experience of information giving, and the problem of cancellation. Minimal excerpts are provided for three of the four themes; the fourth theme, the problem of cancellation is completely in narrative format. Although the emphasis of the findings was on the majority of excerpts, this researcher included negative case studies under two themes; efficient functioning and the experience of information giving. Efficient functioning was described by the majority of participants as being provided to in a timely manner, in contrast some (numbers not men...


... middle of paper ...


.... This study could have been improved by expanding the sample group from various preassessment clinics and to include diverse ethnicities and representation across various surgical specialties. In addition, another credible author would have increased trustworthiness of the entire study. This writer suggests the study be replicated in the U.S., with the suggested enhancements, for application in the U.S. healthcare system.






Works Cited

Burns, N., & Grove, S.K. (2009). The practice of nursing research: Appraisal, synthesis, and generation of evidence (6th ed.). St. Louis, MO: Saunders Elsevier.

Gilmartin, J. (2003). Day surgery: Patients’ perceptions of a nurse-led preadmission clinic. Journal of Clinical Nursing 13, 243-250.

Tappen, R.M. (2011). Advanced nursing research: From theory to practice. Sudbury, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Qualitative Research Critique Essay

- Article Citation Gilmartin, J. (2003). Day surgery: Patients’ perceptions of a nurse-led preadmission clinic. Journal of Clinical Nursing 13, 243-250. Initial Reaction This research article is from the UK and the writer questions if the findings from this study will have heuristic relevance and applicability to nursing and healthcare in the United States (U.S.). Primary healthcare in the UK is provided through the National Health Service (NHS); this writer has little knowledge as to how it works and its impact on patient care and nursing....   [tags: Advanced Nursing Research]

Term Papers
1821 words (5.2 pages)

Narrative Critique of a Qualitative Research Study Essay

- The study outlined in the article is well organized in its major parts, including introduction, literature review, methodology, results, and discussions. The introduction provides the research question and purpose, while the remaining parts provide sufficient data to help in justifying the hypothesis and rationale of the study. The introduction of the article explains all the important aspects of the study; the study is about using the bona fide group aspect to examine leadership. The introduction also explicitly indicates the aim of the study, which is to investigate the leadership process and success from a bona fide group’s perspective (Galanes, 2003, p....   [tags: introduction, review, results, discussions]

Term Papers
555 words (1.6 pages)

Mixed Methods Article Critique : Problem Situations Experienced By Urban Middle School Students With High Incidence Disabilities That Impact

- Mixed Methods Article Critique: Problem Situations Experienced by Urban Middle School Students with High Incidence Disabilities that Impact Emotional and Behavioral Adjustment Summary While a number of studies concentrated on difficult conditions involving a sample of middle class, European Americans, Sullivan, Sutherland, Lotze, Helms, Wright, and Ulmer aspired to focus on a diverse sample in relation to ethnicity and socioeconomic status. Therefore, the researchers conducted a mixed-methods investigation, researching problematic circumstances experienced primarily by African American middle school students with high incidence disabilities, possibly influencing their emotional and behaviora...   [tags: Qualitative research, Quantitative research]

Term Papers
1612 words (4.6 pages)

Qualitative Analysis Critique Essay

- Qualitative Research Critique There are many differences between quantitative and qualitative research. Such things like: quantitative research provides only variables that can predict specific results but it does not tell us very much about how the variables affect an individual’s life course. Qualitative research adversely provides an enriched understanding of characteristics, qualities, attributes, and environmental factors affecting life events. Qualitative analysis can give understanding to the meaning of a specific characteristic, entity, or phenomenon within a context, instead of only measuring how much is present....   [tags: Self Development]

Term Papers
1350 words (3.9 pages)

Business / Management Journals Focused On The Principle Qualitative Research Methods

- Introduction - This paper provides a review of five articles from business/management journals focused on the principle qualitative research methods. For each article review a brief description, guided by Myers (2013), and a critique, guided Pratt (2009), is provided. Table 1 provides a summary of the five articles identifying the research method, data collection technique, data analysis approach and key. The narrative descriptive review of each article coupled with figure and tables to organize and visualize thoughts (Pratt, 2009) follows the summary table....   [tags: Scientific method, Qualitative research]

Term Papers
1148 words (3.3 pages)

Critiquing a Qualitative Nursing Research Article Essay

- The purpose of this paper is to critique a qualitative research article in all phases of the report. For this purpose, the article that will be used is “Lamentation and loss: expression of caring by contemporary surgical nurses” written by Carol Enns and David Gregory. This paper will address the problem statement, literature review, conceptual underpinnings and research questions, research design/method, ethical considerations, sampling, data collection, data analysis, confirmability of the findings, interpretation and discussion of findings, additional considerations, and rating the scientific merit of a research report....   [tags: nursing, medical, medicine]

Term Papers
2368 words (6.8 pages)

Critical Analysis of Research Papers

- In this paper I will critically analyse the strength and weakness of using 'qualitative and quantitative' to a specific area of social work practice. The area of choice is children's services with focus on two research findings in the area of performance measurement within social work, with special emphasis on quality services and stability of placements for children looked after away from home. The two documents will be referred as Paper one titled 'Performance Targets and stability of Placement for children Long looked After away from home' Harriet Wardan and Tricia Skuse (2002) and Paper two titled 'Defining Quality care for looked After Children: Front line Workers Perspective's on Stand...   [tags: Research Methods, Qualitative, Quantitative]

Term Papers
1718 words (4.9 pages)

Qualitative vs Quantitative Research Essay

- The father of quantitative analysis, Rene Descartes, thought that in order to know and understand something, you have to measure it (Kover, 2008). Quantitative research has two main types of sampling used, probabilistic and purposive. Probabilistic sampling is when there is equal chance of anyone within the studied population to be included. Purposive sampling is used when some benchmarks are used to replace the discrepancy among errors. The primary collection of data is from tests or standardized questionnaires, structured interviews, and closed-ended observational protocols....   [tags: philosophy, rene descartes]

Term Papers
864 words (2.5 pages)

Research Critique : Nursing Research Essay

- Research Critique Tintu Thomas NRS-433 V Introduction to Nursing Research 09/28/2014 Problem statement In the recent past there have been a lot of concerns growing as regards support worker in healthcare. Most of them have been extending their practice towards tasks that should only be carried out by the registered professional nurses and midwives (Griffiths & Robinson, 2010). The support workers have been engaging in the midwifery and nursing tasks which involve direct clinical practices, posing serious health risks to the patients and themselves, as they are not trained in these fields....   [tags: Health care, Health care provider, Regulation]

Term Papers
1369 words (3.9 pages)

Quantitative Research Article Critique Essay

- Quantitative Research Article Critique This paper is an academic critique of an article written by Lautrette, et al. (2007) titled: “A Communication Strategy and Brochure for Relatives of Patients Dying in the ICU” and accurately reflected the content of the article and the research study itself. The abstract explained the article in more detail, while remaining concise. The type of research study, sample size, variables, intervention, measurement method, findings, and conclusion were all mentioned in the abstract....   [tags: Healthcare]

Term Papers
1647 words (4.7 pages)