In the dialogue between Barth and Tillich, Barth was more persuasive. The view of Karl Barth that God is revealed in Jesus Christ is more persuasive because that is what is written in the canonical scriptures. He says that theology is the study of god and it is not possible to study god by displacing him from the center. If we keep Christ in the center, then all our concerns will be resolved. Tillich’s method is very general, because if we derive questions from our experience then we will end up getting self-serving answers, rather than getting the answer that reveals god to us.
Barth’s views on revelation are also in accordance with the canonical scriptures. The God is a mystery and it is the God that reveals himself through Jesus Christ. There is no other way to know about the God. For Barth revelation is objective. He says that the revelation of God was a gift that is received by humans. Moreover, revelation is a surprise and it makes the humans inquire more about the God. But Tillich says that revelation is objective and subjective with strict interdependence. This means that the God has to reveal himself and the humans have to receive the knowledge from revelation. The knowledge can be accepted or denied by the humans. Tillich uses the analogy of accepting a...
... middle of paper ...
... revelation of God in Jesus Christ. This idea of Barth is more persuasive because deriving the truth of theology from ontology or anthropology would mean that our knowledge of theology comes from human experience and not from the God himself. We cannot know about the God unless the God reveals it to us through Holy Spirit. Rahner also states that grace is a “constituent part” of our existence. But then Barth correctly states that if we have grace then why do we have to look beyond ourselves to Christ to know about sin and salvation. Barth is also more persuasive about the rejection of the idea of “anonymous Christianity”. He says that in order to be Christian, in has to believe in Jesus Christ.
In conclusion, I think the views of Karl Barth are more persuasive than others because Karl Barth does not displace the God from center to understand the truth of theology.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- THEOLOGICAL PRIMER I) Theology proper is Theology which deals specifically with the being, the attributes and works of all mighty God. a) There are four proofs/arguments that God exists i) The Cosmological argument which is argument regarding cause and effect, (1) The term cosmological comes from the Greek word, cósmos, which means world. (2) The argument then can be defined as, because the world exists, it must have a maker (God), because something does not come from nothing. (3) It has to be either a divine being or chance.... [tags: God, Theology, Monotheism, Bible]
1000 words (2.9 pages)
- My reaction to the Holocaust was devastating. It is one example of bad things happening to great people. The mass murdering of so many Jews is just disgusting and also because it was done for basically no reason. As this was a true event many sources or witnesses are available to express their views, feelings and emotions of themselves and those who survived this terrible tragedy. I will demonstrate examples of Jews who have survived what they have been through and what they think about God. It is really hard to go through all of this and still believe that God exists.... [tags: Nazi Germany, Judaism, The Holocaust, Evil]
2093 words (6 pages)
- A Theological Response to Natural Suffering In his book, The Sacred Canopy, Peter Berger asserts that ``Religion has played a strategic part in the human enterprise of world building,`` and `` implies the farthest reach of his ( man`s) infusion of reality with his own meaning.`` (Berger, 1967, 27) Thus, theology, another term for religion, is the foundation of human sense of the meaning of life and closely related to our daily life. The 921 earthquake occured on September 21, 1999 that caused the most serious damage in Taiwan since 1935.... [tags: Earthquake Religion Suffering God Papers]
4544 words (13 pages)
- Introduction The Church as a whole debates many concepts that are in the Bible, in both theology and in practice. One of these debates surrounds the gifts that are spoken of in the Bible. In one corner are those who believe that charismatic gifts are alive and well in the church today. The Continuationist view believes that the gifts have continued on through Biblical times and are still relevant for today. In the other corner are those who believe that particular gifts have ceased to be used in the modern church and that they were only given for a particular reason in Biblical times.... [tags: Theology ]
2193 words (6.3 pages)
- Introduction The following pages are my best attempt at writing my very first major project. I pray that it will contain the truth of what God had me learn at the Churches of God retreat center in January of this year. Although my notes seem extensive, it’s virtually impossible to literate all that was taught and shared during this class. However, Dr. Statts, I have confidence that these pages may express at least a hint of your spellbinding teachings. Upon returning to my home church in Dover, Pennsylvania, I asked my senior pastor and my mentor, the worship pastor, for any input and / or materials they may have to help me with this final project.... [tags: essays research papers fc]
8319 words (23.8 pages)
- “The question of revelation in Christian theology is finally no less than the question of theology’s own ultimate source and norm… ” This statement serves as an excellent beginning point for our discussion of the Christian doctrine of revelation and its relation to the practice of theology. As these few words suggest, there is an intrinsically interwoven nature to the two ideas, more specifically, the dependency of Christian theology on revelation and, likewise, the comprehension of that revelation through the act of theologizing.... [tags: Theology ]
1684 words (4.8 pages)
- This paper will examine the argument put forward by William Paley in 1802, in his Natural Theology. Paley offers an argument from design that purports to show a clear and distinct reason why one should hold a belief in God, due to the inherent features of the world. It is attempted in this paper to firstly: show that the argument should be rejected on the grounds of lacking a rationally flowing set of premises and conclusions; and secondly: that the criticisms made by David Hume concerning the argument hold more weight than is generally granted by other philosophers, and should have convinced one even before the advent of Darwinian theory.... [tags: Natural Theology, William Paley]
2089 words (6 pages)
- There are various groups and individuals worldwide that interpret the Bible, the Koran, the Torah, the Vidas, and Buddhist scripture differently. The majority of these groups and religious actors will interpret their respective ‘holy books’ as being a beacon of peace with emphasis on a one-ness with their deity and their community. These same scriptures, though, can be read in another way: a way that condones the use of force under certain circumstances. The emphasis in the early 21st century has been primarily on the justification for violence by small minorities inside these major religions.... [tags: Religion Organizations]
2507 words (7.2 pages)
- The Islamic worldview instates a complete lifestyle of servitude and faith into its followers, thus granting both purpose and meaning as a Muslim's entire life is lived with the mission to submit to Allah's divine intendment therefore providing such regulation and guidance. (Al-Hariri Wendel, 2002 pg. 79). Submission to Allah's plan thus gives recognition to God's absolute authority, and reaches a conviction that God alone possesses all power. The natural effect of such a realisation is to devote one's worship and one's life absolutely to God alone.... [tags: Religion Muslim Islam]
1498 words (4.3 pages)
- The purpose of this paper is to explore Barth’s understanding of God’s being in act in order to posit its contribution to our Trinitarian understanding of the atonement. This paper is composed of two sections: the analysis of Barth’s understanding of God’s being in act and the contribution of Barth’s theology to our Trinitarian understanding of the atonement. In the first section, I present a brief historical background of Barth’s theology in order to engage his theology more in depth. I then analyze Barth’s understanding of God’s being in act.... [tags: Theology, God, Christian theology, Metaphysics]
1601 words (4.6 pages)