Public Sentiments Concerning Chinese Immigration Essay

Public Sentiments Concerning Chinese Immigration Essay

Length: 1060 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Public Sentiments Concerning Chinese Immigration
In 1852, there were over 20,000 Chinese immigrants living in California (Franks). Americans reacted very negatively to this influx, and their negative sentiments were made apparent in the California Supreme Court’s People v. Hall verdict, which rendered Chinese testimony unreliable. Then, in 1882, President Chester Arthur signed the Chinese Exclusion Act, a law that prohibited Chinese laborers from entering the United States (Foner, 651). From the 1850s up to the Exclusion Act of 1882, Americans felt increasingly negative sentiments towards the Chinese. As illustrated through newspaper and magazine depictions along the Pacific Coast, the Americans perceived the Chinese as inferior and menacing and they felt threatened and invaded by their large numbers.
In the image “Chinese Candy Man” from Harper’s Magazine, a Chinese man is depicted selling “rock canuy” to white children. This image illustrates how Americans viewed the Chinese as an intellectually inferior race. The Chinese man’s alleged skin tone is a very important feature because his skin is black. The skin tone illustrates how the Americans viewed the Chinese as an inferior race by categorizing them with blacks; in their eyes, the Chinese were subordinate like the slaves. The People vs. Hall verdict also reinforced this categorization: the California Supreme Court ruled that a white man could not be convicted on the testimony of a Chinese witness. Black slaves did not have the right to testify in court; this restriction was now being applied to Chinese people as well. This verdict claimed that they were intellectually unreliable and inferior to the proper white man, which is also shown in the illustrated Chinese ...

... middle of paper ... with the first picture, it also depicts the Chinese as menacing and conniving people. These negative sentiments are also reinforced by events that occurred during the time, such as the previously mentioned Seclusion Act and the People v Hall trial. They also degrade the Chinese man by depicting him as a crawling creature and by categorizing them with the black slaves.

Works Cited

Franks, Joel. "The "Orient," Hawaii and Antebellum US to 1860." 29 Nov. 2011. Lecture.
“The Chinese Candy Man.” 1868. [database on-line] (The Chinese in California, accessed 2 December 2011) ; available, image ID cubcic brk5353.
“Amusing the Child.” 1882. [database on-line] (The Chinese in California, accessed 2 December 2011) ; available, image ID cubcic brk1522.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Challenge Of The 21st Century : Immigration Reform Essay

- Challenge of the 21st Century: Immigration Reform In 2013, nearly 1.7 million immigrants entered the United States -- a nation built with the blood and sweat of the millions of immigrants who came to it -- in search of a better life, one free from tyranny and oppression. However, only nine hundred thousand of these immigrants entered the country legally, vesting their time and resources into the legal residency “green card” program -- the very first step to full citizenship (Monger). The other seven hundred thousand immigrants entered the country illegally, exploiting security failures on the US southern border, and policy failures in Washington, DC (Morgan)....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Strong Essays
1628 words (4.7 pages)

Immigration Reform The Great American Melting Pot Or Just Tomato Soup Essay

- Immigration law and reform tend to be a major issue in American Society and Politics today. Numerous immigrants come across the border today into the United States seeking freedom, jobs and a better way of life which is not much different than what people were doing when this country was first established. The birth of the United States came from immigrants of various races, nationalities and cultures that developed the foundation of where it stands today. With all these various groups of individuals coming together a metaphor was coined from a 1908 play as America being the “Melting Pot” as all these groups broke from the segregation provided from their homeland into Communities where all...   [tags: immigration laws, discrimination, naturalization]

Strong Essays
920 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Immigration Policy Of The United States

- Throughout the United States, and many other places around the world, the name Donald Trump is easily recognizable. Trump, who is running in the 2016 presidential campaign, is famous for his desired immigration policy. Some people, mostly Republicans, support his view on immigration on the method in which way unauthorized immigrants should be dealt with. Others, mostly Democrats, believe he is wrong and unjust. Immigration policy has come to even more people’s attention lately because of its potential future if Trump is president....   [tags: United States Constitution, United States]

Strong Essays
1070 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Chinese Americans

- The Lost Ones – Young Chinese Americans Due to harsh immigration laws, in American history, Chinese have often relied on illegal means of entering the United States. For example, in 1882, the Chinese Exclusion Act (Chinese Exclusion Act, Documents on Anti-Chinese Immigration Policy.) was passed, the first and only act that restricted immigration from one particular ethnicity. This act restricted immigration of Chinese labourers. In 1888, this act was extended to all Chinese immigrants except for officials, teachers, students, tourists, and merchants....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Strong Essays
2191 words (6.3 pages)

U.s. Department Of Homeland Security Essay

- The U.S. Department of Homeland Security deports more than 1 million nonresident aliens annually, including about 150,000 to 200,000 "formal removals." A formal removal occurs when an alien is decreed deportable in an administrative proceeding within the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. Deportability may be due to undocumented entry, visa overstay, or criminal conviction. More than two thirds (69.5 percent) of formal removals in 2005 were Mexican nationals, with nationals of Honduras (7.0 percent) and Guatemala (6.0 percent) a distant second and third....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]

Strong Essays
988 words (2.8 pages)

The History of Chinese Immigration Essay

- Many cities throughout the United States have a distinct neighborhood known as Chinatown. Chinatowns are ethnic enclaves, which are defined areas in a city with a high concentration of an ethnic group and thus a unique culture set apart from the larger city. To the inhabitants of the city, these ethnic enclaves may exist without much thought of the historical, or modern, reasons for their presence. However it is important to look at the reasons behind their existences and how these areas, like Chinatowns, relate to broader ethnic and race issues in the United States....   [tags: ethnic, culture, Chinese Americans, immigration]

Strong Essays
1969 words (5.6 pages)

Chinese Exclusion Act and Immigration Problems in the United States Essay

- In 1882 the Chinese Exclusion Act was passed by Congress. This act exiled Chinese laborers from arriving in the United States. This was the first time ever that a specific ethnicity was banned from immigrating to the U.S.A. Racism against the Chinese was strong, so the ban remained for ten years, but was eventually made “permanent”. However, China soon became a war ally in World War II, so the ban was repealed in 1943. There are many issues concerning immigration and racism that still plague the United States today....   [tags: Chinese Exclusion Act, Immigration, USA, discrimin]

Strong Essays
1520 words (4.3 pages)

Essay about Multiculturalism in a Pluralistic Society

- In this signature assignment, I will discuss my understanding of multiculturalism in a pluralistic society. Furthermore, a portion of this essay will focus on Constitutional Right’s protecting basic educational freedoms as well as factors that affect public education in America. Lastly, I will conclude the assignment with suggestions for delivering a multicultural education in the future. I studied the meaning of multiculturalism earlier, but in a less general setting. As cited in a previous assignment, Gollick and Chinn (2009) believe that a multicultural education is defined as an educational strategy in which students’ cultures are used to develop effective classroom instruction and scho...   [tags: Public Education, Freedom]

Strong Essays
2405 words (6.9 pages)

Chinese Immigration Essay

- In many aspects, the motivations for the Chinese to come to the United States were similar to those of most immigrants. Some came to "The Gold Mountain," and others came to the United States to seek better economic opportunity. Yet there were others that were compelled to leave China either as contract laborers or refugees. The Chinese brought with them their language, culture, social institutions, and customs. Over time they made lasting contributions to their adopted country and became a vital part of the United States population (Immigration Station)....   [tags: Anti-Chinese Immigration Policy]

Strong Essays
2993 words (8.6 pages)

Chinese Immigration to United States Essay

- There were many reasons for the Chinese to come to America. Overcrowding, poverty, war, and other catastrophes in China were all reasons (push) for traveling to America, as well as effective external influences. The discovery of gold was a major pull for Chinese peasants in coming to the West Coast. America's labor needs were the most important external catalyst for immigration. However, there were very few ways of traveling to the United States. With loans from the Six Companies, Chinese were able to afford fare to America, and they traveled here to work primarily as gold miners, fishermen, or agricultural workers; later settling into laundry services and restaurant work (Tsai, China over...   [tags: Immigration]

Strong Essays
1810 words (5.2 pages)