Essay on Public Journalism vs. Traditional Journalism

Essay on Public Journalism vs. Traditional Journalism

Length: 2245 words (6.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview


There are two distinct sides to the debate of journalism, their journalists, and the consumers: traditional journalism and public journalism. In the current digital age there is a greater number of public journalism being practiced. However, journalists and their consumers run into several issues concerning that matter. To express more clearly, there are particular roles and characteristics in which journalism standards are being gauged.
The four dimensions of journalism, as mentioned by Don Heider, Maxwell McCombs, and Paula M. Poindexter in What The Public Expects Of Local News: Views On Public And Traditional Journalism, include good neighbor, watchdog, unbiased and accurate, and fast. (Heider, McCombs, Poindexter 952) With that said, traditional journalism strongly fulfills those attributes as opposed to public journalism.
Much is being discovered when the public, also known as the consumers and recipients of the news, share their views on journalistic practices. One might suggest that traditional journalism has, in due course, come to an end. Although, there are definitely problems that the public runs into with public journalism taking over. A few of those arguments include their content, the journalists, and the effects that it has on their public audience.
The idea that lies behind public journalism is that citizens that lack any formal experience are able to utilize the tools of modern technology alongside the limitless Internet to practice a form of journalism that allows the audience to inform one another. There is a sense of freedom with public journalism, also known as civic journalism. In this digital age, public journalism is easier to access due to laptops and cellular devices. It is true that public jou...


... middle of paper ...


...ports are being posted by anyone, both professional and unprofessional journalists. The public, being the unprofessional journalists, are not being demanded to state particular things when they are covering a story, they lose structure and focus.
To conclude, when public journalism is being practiced, a larger percentage of reports face an innumerable amount of issues that lie in their content, the journalists themselves, and their audience. What is being reported by professionals, traditional journalist, constitutes as “good journalism” because of their ability to maintain and provide accurate, unbiased reports, fulfill being a good neighbor and watchdog, while adjusting to our growing technological advancements with an newer and improved rapid reporting. Thus, traditional journalism holds the persisting dominance over their competitors, public journalism.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Is Journalism a Profession? Essays

- INTRODUCTION "Society demands that the men who minister to its health be in the highest sense of the word professional men − professionally trained, professional in their ethics, professionally responsible. Society demands professional training and professional conduct of the men who minister to its needs in legal matters. The fact that society demands less of the men who minister through news to its knowledge and attitudes is one of the great and dangerous inconsistencies that give shape to the twentieth century (Schramm, 1947, p....   [tags: Journalism Debate]

Research Papers
2831 words (8.1 pages)

Essay about The Rise Of Print Journalism

- In recent discussions of the decline of printed newspapers in the digital era, a controversial issue has been made in regards to the factors that contribute towards the recession. On the one hand, some argue that the increase usage of technologies resulted in the downfall of print journalism. From this perspective, it could be argued that the increase reliance on technologies influence in the depreciation of newspapers. On the other hand, however, others argue that it was the stoppage of advertisement for print publications that causes the downfall....   [tags: Newspaper, Mass media, Journalism, Advertising]

Research Papers
1314 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about What´s Citizen Journalism or Public Journalism?

- ... Therefore, this essay will argue that citizen journalism has apparently positive aspects in promoting democratization by removing corrupted regimes and being the first in providing media coverage. To some degree, citizen journalism has several disadvantages which may have negative impacts on the quality news provided. One of these disadvantages is the low level of credibility. Therefore, citizen journalists are usually not invited to attend any media conference or meeting because they do not have formal training and qualifications in the media field (Bruns 2010 p.3)....   [tags: quality, credibility, freedom of speech]

Research Papers
676 words (1.9 pages)

New Media, Old News, Journalism And Democracy Essay

- ‘New Media, Old News: Journalism and Democracy in the Digital Age’ is a book of essays written by authors James Curran, Des Freedman, Angela Phillips, Nick Couldry, Peter Lee-Wright, Tamara Witschge, Aeron Davis, Joanna Redden, Rodney Benson and Natalie Fenton, who also edited the book. These essays are based on a large scale multi-year investigation into the journalistic practices of news organisations in the present day where the internet has made access to news instantaneous and the competition for speed and accuracy is fiercer than ever....   [tags: Mass media, Journalism, Newspaper, News media]

Research Papers
1034 words (3 pages)

The Effects of Celebrity Centered Journalism Essay

- In our modern day society, media is dominated by celebrity centred journalism which has developed significantly in the last century. Journalism is often focused on people’s personal lives, mainly celebrities which include people from the film and television industry, models, musical artists and other well-known people in the entertainment business. It is clear that celebrities are a very popular topic to write about in the news as they create entertaining stories and this is what the public want to read....   [tags: debasing the public sphere]

Research Papers
786 words (2.2 pages)

Citizen Journalism Essay

- Joan Cornell notes that the Internet democratizes the journalism which was in the hand of the few people (2003). The Internet makes the public access to information; at the same time, it creates the public to be journalists, opening blogs to put something new around on the Internet. Many news websites like The Guardian, the Washington Post, CNN and MSNBC allows some personification. The journalism nowadays is facing challenges not only from media and technology convergence, but also from audience they serve (Bowman and Willis 2003)....   [tags: Analysis, Joan Cornell]

Research Papers
1575 words (4.5 pages)

Essay about Objectivity in Journalism

- Objectivity in Journalism Merriam Webster defines objectivity as expressing or dealing with facts or conditions as perceived without distortion by personal feelings, prejudices, or interpretations. Objectivity, as defined by the school of media ethics, means standing so far from the community that you see all events and all viewpoints as equally distant and important, or unimportant for that matter. It is employed by giving equal weight to all viewpoints--or, if not, giving all an interesting twist, within taste....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
653 words (1.9 pages)

Studying Journalism And Literature : An Undergraduate And Journalism As A Graduate

- ... What I learnt as an undergraduate has prepared me for coming up with those research ideas and present them in a conversational and fascinating way. My responsibilities also included the maintenance the ViDS Effect Laboratory of the Scripps School of Journalism, designing (theoretically and methodologically) and conducting the experiments with various media source with different equipment (e.g., Super lab) in different formats (e.g., Computer-assisted, pencil-to-paper). As well, I helped to conducted discourse and context analysis studies in gender study and environmental study, by retrieving first-hand journals from the websites....   [tags: Communication, Sociology, Mass communication]

Research Papers
1146 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on How to Improve Journalism Education

- How to Improve Journalism Education Media tycoons agreed that profound changes are taking place in the News media industry that pose challenges for journalists and the news organizations for which they work. Their advice can be clustered into three broad prescriptions. · Emphasis the basics of journalism craft along with analytical thinking and a strong sense of ethics. · Help the journalists to build a specialized expertise to enhance their coverage and help them to acquire first-hand knowledge of the societies, languages, religions and cultures of the world....   [tags: Media Teaching]

Research Papers
892 words (2.5 pages)

Ethics And Power In Journalism Essay

- What Roles Do Ethics and Power Play in Journalism. For the most part, journalists have power that can hurt, instead of help citizen autonomy. The ways journalists treat their subjects and sources have generated much concern. The ethics of these two endeavors share much in common, because both use people in various ways to reach each others goals. The well-developed guidelines in research designed to protect research participants' autonomy, to guard against needless deception, and to recognize the special needs of vulnerable research participants have direct application to journalism....   [tags: Ethics]

Research Papers
1450 words (4.1 pages)