Their data consisted of multiple groups, to include four groups of police officers. One group was comprised of homicide detectives, another group comprised of new detectives in training, new police recruits, another group comprised of senior detectives, a group of people simply interested in this sort of material, and a final group which was comprised of chemistry students. Each group though, had no idea of any additional details about the crime committed, other than what was provided to them, and the crime had already been cracked and closed, so their responses could be compared to the actual answers and outcome of the crime and the offender they were attempting to profile.
All of the groups received the same information and questions. The first group of information was about the crime scene, to include pictures. The second group of information was actually questions asked about the possible past of the offender, habits, and behaviors. There was a third group but that was simply to make sure that none of the participants had any other information than what was provided to them.
The outcome wasn’t what was expected, and that was the data pointing to the chemistry students having the most accurate profiling of the offender, ov...
... middle of paper ...
...certain guy. These articles do not discount the value of profiling though, and that is not the purpose. The purpose was simply to see what attributes it lends to criminology and what can be improved upon, and what it lacks. Three factual groups that are addressed in the two articles, despite the reasons for the articles, they both came to the same point about profiling: the difficulties, the accuracy, the bias components, and the future possibilities.
Farrell, A., Keppel, R., and Titterington, V. (2011). Lethal Studies: Revisiting What We
Know About Female Serial Murderers. Homicide Studies, Vol. 15, 228-252. DOI:
Kocsis, R., Hayes, F., and Irwin, H. (2002). Investigative Experience and Accuracy in
Psychological Profiling of a Violent Crime. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, Volume 17, 811. DOI: 10.1177/0886260502017008001
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Issues In Psychological Profiling Historically, crime and criminals have always caught the attention of law-abiding citizens. Whenever there is mention of serial killers or unsolved murders or abductions, psychological profiling, floats to the top of the list of concerns (Egger, 1999). Psychological profiling is an attempt to provide investigators with more information about an offender who has not yet been identified (Egger, 1999). Its purpose is to develop a behavioral composite that combines both sociological and psychological assessment of the would-be offender.... [tags: Psychology]
1339 words (3.8 pages)
- Historically, crime and criminals have always caught the attention of law-abiding citizens. Whenever there is mention of serial killers or unsolved murders or abductions, psychological profiling, now a household term, floats to the top of the list of concerns (Egger, 1999). Psychological profiling is an attempt to provide investigators with more information about an offender who has not yet been identified (Egger, 1999). Its purpose is to develop a behavioral composite that combines both sociological and psychological assessment of the would-be offender.... [tags: Criminology]
694 words (2 pages)
- Psychological profiling of offenders and their motives has been a growing practice, especially throughout homicide crimes. The main issue with profiling is the accuracy that it can provide or does provide or doesn’t provide. It isn’t an exact science, it is probably thought of more of as an intuitive ability. In the article, Investigative Experience and Accuracy in Psychological Profiling of a Violent Crime, Kocsis, R., Hayes, A., and Irwin, H actually empirically assess the accuracy of criminal profiling.... [tags: crime investigation, serial killers]
1054 words (3 pages)
Journal Article Review on Using Psychological Skills Training to Develop Performance by Richard C. Thelwell
- Review of Journal Article: Using Psychological Skills Training to Develop Soccer Performance Richard C. Thelwell , Iain A. Greenlees & Neil J. V. Weston (2006) Using Psychological Skills Training to Develop Soccer Performance, Journal of Applied Sport Psychology,18:3, 254-270 Improving the performances of athletes has always been of utmost importance to many stakeholders of the sporting industry, such as the athletes’ coaches, sport psychologists, sports scientists. Many factors during a competition can affect athletes physically and mentally and these can negatively affect their performance abilities.... [tags: performance, profiling, psychological]
1953 words (5.6 pages)
- ... Being abandoned at birth, then reclaimed approximately a month later, then proceeding to being told that his sister was his mother, and other traumatic events that occurred in the early formative years of his life may have possibly contributed to his eventual voyeurism, murders, and even necrophilia. Due to the traumatic stress this man had endured, the areas of his brain implicated in the stress response showed evidence that due to the harmful effects of stress and eventful childhood experience, it greatly affected the outcome of the murderous man.... [tags: violence, criminology, psychological profiling]
1115 words (3.2 pages)
- The world is living in a post 9/11 era. Since that September day, security measures have heightened and extra precautions are in place to prevent something of that nature from happening again. The terrorists involved in 9/11 appeared to be shockingly similar to a typical American Citizen. However, their behaviors from that week prior were alarming. Examining the terrorists who have become more prevalent in the last twenty years, there are several things in common with all of them. Their profiles all have similar characteristics, not necessarily racial but largely behavioral.... [tags: Racism, Prejudice, Racial Profiling Essays]
1626 words (4.6 pages)
- Many studies have been made in the field of criminology, concluding that profiling is a necessary means for discovering and apprehending criminals. There are many different types of profiling and many people think of profiling differently; however, all types of profiling does work and is proven to help stop crime. This paper will explore the following: profiling and different forms of it, the closely related stop and frisk policy, different cities that have proven statistics that profiling does work, how airports are now profiling, and different serial killers that have been apprehended due to work from profilers.... [tags: criminology, racial profiling, terrorism]
1196 words (3.4 pages)
- Introduction In the modern world, all kinds of oppressions involve a dominant cultural psychology that causes different communities to be suppressed on diverse social, racial grounds. There is usually a hierarchy of oppression in which some communities are perceived to be less valuable than others. However, stereotypes are usually utilized to rationalize this domination and to label individuals on certain type while marginalization is the social process of being demoted to the lower social standing.... [tags: racial profiling, sociological analysis]
968 words (2.8 pages)
- The process of inferring the personality characteristics of individuals responsible for committing criminal acts has commonly been referred to as criminal profiling. (Turvey) Criminal profiling can also be referred to as, behavioral profiling because when a profiler creates a profile they refer to the behavior of the offender. The general term criminal profiling can also be referred to as crime scene profiling, criminal personality profiling, offender profiling, psychological profiling and criminal investigative analysis.... [tags: Criminology ]
1821 words (5.2 pages)
- One area of psychology and investigation, (an occupation. or shall I say craft?), many ways to refer and interpret it, with a complex past intermingling various areas of study, Profiling, like any other area of study, has both its advantages and disadvantages. Yet, how useful is it as an investigative tool. It certainly isn’t considered as a hard science, however this does not mean that is should be discarded and not taken seriously. Or does it. I say advantages and disadvantages, because whilst my personal position is towards profiling in general, it can only be used in conjunction with other, more deeply studied police work.... [tags: Legal Issues, Ethics]
2032 words (5.8 pages)