Essay Psychological Positions on Gender Identity

Essay Psychological Positions on Gender Identity

Length: 1903 words (5.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

In this paper I will be examining two different psychological positions on gender identity. These positions are; binary gender identity and diverse gender identity. After I have explained both positions I will analyze the two and put forth my argument that diverse gender identity captures a more accurate depiction of gender. This psychologically charged debate over gender identity and its presence in society has taken the form of intuitions over social necessity. In where one side is arguing that traditional binary gender norms are no longer relevant in today’s world, and that binary gender norms are damaging to the cultivation of a happy and healthy society. While the other side argues that traditional binary gender norms are paramount for a healthy family, for a proper social dynamics, and for the prevention of damaging individual’s lives. From both sides of the fence proponents have been using psychological analysis and statistics to bolster their claims. For the purposes of this paper I will begin with the pro binary gender identity theorists.

Binary Gender Identity
In order to properly unpack the position of proponents for binary gender identity I will first put forth a concept known as gender essentialism. Gender essentialism, in a nut shell, is the theory that a specific gender, let’s say female, holds a unifying quality that makes it that gender. For those arguing in favor for gender binary norms that unifying quality is biological. In other words, they argue, we are all born a specific gender and by benefit of this unifying biological quality we are concretely that gender. So in short, by this account, one's gender is determined by the sex they are born into. Furthermore, they argue that these...


... middle of paper ...


... doom ourselves to potentially keep striving for the unreasonable.



Works Cited

DiDonato, Matthew D. and Berenbaum, Sheri A. “The Benefits and Drawbacks of Gender Typing: How Different Dimensions are Related to Psychological Adjustment.” Archives of Sexual Behavior April 2011, Volume 40, Issue 2, pp 457-463 Web 21 Apr. 2015.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20364305

Eckes, Thomas. Hanns M. Trautner Taylor & Francis "The Developmental Social Psychology of Gender", May 1, 2000 Print.

Ehrensaft, Diane. "Boys Will Be Girls, Girls Will Be Boys" Psychoanalytic Psychology, Vol 28(4), Oct 2011, 528-548. Web 3 Apr. 2015.
http://psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/2011-12010-001/


Witt, Charlotte. "What is Gender Essentialism?" 2011 Web 12 May 2015.
http://pubpages.unh.edu/~cewitt/Site/My_Philosophical_Life_files/What%20is%20Gender%20Essentialism%3F.pdf

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Identity and Culture Essay

- When we think about our identity we often think about the way we look. Such features as hair color, eye color, skin tone, height and weight come to mind. Whilst these features are part of our identity, there are many more complex factors that make us who we are. Whilst psychological issues are paramount to the formation of our identity, I will be addressing the nature of our identity in relation to socio-cultural factors (Austin, 2002, p.9). During the course of this essay I will be discussing the term of Identity and some of the axes of identity, including Race, Class and Gender....   [tags: Cultural Identity Essays]

Term Papers
1522 words (4.3 pages)

Gender Between Female And Female Essay

- Gender also operates at an institutional level, which can be just as influential as the process of socialisation within the home. Inevitably, every individual will somehow be shaped by the institutions that they find themselves involved within, for example education and the workplace. Acker (1990 p146) provides a useful definition of the gendering of organisations. She explains how a gendered organisation or institution means that ‘advantage and disadvantage, exploitation and control, action and emotion, meaning and identity’ are all patterned in terms of distinguishing between male and female, as well as masculine and feminine....   [tags: Gender, Sexual orientation, Gender role, Sociology]

Term Papers
1116 words (3.2 pages)

The Sociological And Psychological Differences Of The Feminist Movement Essays

- Females have almost always been at a disadvantage to males, they hold little power, and are viewed as having little power. Women have been handed the short end of the stick throughout history, as men have been the ones who are in power and have continued to stay in power in modern society. Through the use of religion and traditions of ancient civilizations have men been able to maintain their position in power, while women have to continue to fight for equal rights in modern society. Gender has been a topic of debate for many years, but has increased in interest rapidly since the 1970s with the rise of the feminist movement....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Gender studies, Masculinity]

Term Papers
1331 words (3.8 pages)

Gender Discrimination And Its Effects On Women Essay

- Specific Aims Although our nation is becoming increasingly more progressive, gender discrimination still exists for many women. The specific aim of this experiment is to measure the ability of women to complete a focus and attention task after having been questioned about stereotype threat, gender discrimination, disadvantage and privilege. Guided by previous research, this proposed experiment hypothesizes that there will be a significant difference in attention task scores for female participants in male dominated areas of study and attention task scores for female participants in female dominated areas of study....   [tags: Gender, Stereotype, Discrimination, Stereotypes]

Term Papers
1543 words (4.4 pages)

Binary Sexuality Categories Is Useful For Understanding How Heteronormativity Impacts Identity And Influences Anti Marriage Equality Sentiment

- binary sexuality categories is useful for understanding how heteronormativity impacts identity and influences anti-marriage equality sentiment. Judith Butler (1990, 1993) argues against the binary categorisation of gender, asserting that gender materialises from a set of forced repeated actions that constitute a normalised performance. Butler’s conceptualisation of gender is not static; gender is made fluid through constant renegotiation and variance of performance (1990, 1993). Using the example of women, Butler argues that women cannot be thought of as a homogenous unified group because categorisation based solely on sex does not explain variations such as class or race (1990)....   [tags: Gender, Feminism, Transgender, Gender role]

Term Papers
857 words (2.4 pages)

Gendered Spaces Are Socially Constructed Locations Essay

- Gendered spaces are socially constructed locations commonly defined by their utility to service a particular gender. They are founded by historic common and continual performative usage upon which specific designs are built and a collective understanding and expectation is attached and is shared. Just as these identifying markers have come to legally and socially define a space as gendered, through signifying dynamics (i.e. - unfettered access, physical interaction with its utilities) the spaces themselves reciprocally identify their users as a particular gender....   [tags: Gender, Transgender, Gender identity, Sociology]

Term Papers
796 words (2.3 pages)

Psychological Theories On Binary Gender Identity Essay

- In this paper I will examine different psychological theories on binary gender identity and diverse gender identity. My intention is not to argue which set of theories is more accurate but more to provide information and let the reader decide for themselves in the light of their own experiences what theory makes the most sense to them. The psychologically charged debate over gender identity and its presence in society has taken the form of intuitions because of social necessity. On one side, diverse gender identity argues that traditional binary gender norms are no longer relevant nor an accurate reflection of the society that we live in today....   [tags: Gender, Gender identity, Third gender, Transgender]

Term Papers
1387 words (4 pages)

Sociology of Sex and Sexuality Essay

- Sociology of Sex and Sexuality Introduction Gender, Sex and Community is dedicated to improve our knowing of the variations among groups of women and groups of men - as well as between women and men - in an era of globalization Gender, Sex and Community provides learners to be able to improve their knowing of gender and sex-related variations between groups and people in an era of globalization and migration. It is dedicated to improve knowing of variations among groups of women and men - as well as between women and men - in an era of globalization....   [tags: globalization, gender, identity]

Term Papers
1774 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on Gender Is The Most Powerful Predictor Of Roles For Men And Women

- Gender is the most powerful predictor of roles for men and women in our society. In many cultures women are seen as frail, weak and passive. The gender stereotypes are recognized as normal understandings of men and women should behave in the world. When you look at gender based violence and women are the main victims how could you deny that it stems from their subordinate identity in society. Gender based violence is defines as any act or threat by men or male dominated institutions that inflict physical, sexual, or psychological harm on a woman or girl because of their gender....   [tags: Domestic violence, Child abuse, Abuse]

Term Papers
1291 words (3.7 pages)

Gender And, Gender, And Social Identity Essay

- Gender and sex are commonly used as interchangeable terms yet when applied to interchangeable lifestyles, history has shown there are great delineations and disparities between individuals who overlay their biological and social identities. Sex is referred to as a person’s biological status comprised of internal organs, external genitalia, and chromosomal composition. (American Psychiatric Association, 2013) In contrast, gender refers to feelings, thoughts, and behaviors of cultural gender-normative, expectations, and congruent conformity between sex and gender roles (American Psychiatric Association, 2013)....   [tags: Gender, Transgender, Gender identity, Sex]

Term Papers
1008 words (2.9 pages)