Protecting Society And Federally Convicted Women With Mental Health Concerns

Protecting Society And Federally Convicted Women With Mental Health Concerns

Length: 1142 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Protecting Society and Federally Sentenced Women with Mental Health Concerns: An Analysis
Social workers are guided by the Canadian Association of Social Workers ' (CASW) Code of Ethics. In accordance with the Code of Ethics, Social Workers share a set of values that include respecting the inherent dignity and worth of all persons and valuing the pursuit of social justice (Canadian Association of Social Workers [CASW], 2005a). In practice, Social Workers strive for the best interests of clients, encourage self-determination, and advocate for social change (CASW, 2005b). However, social workers are sometimes confronted with situations and policies that challenge these values.
For social workers assisting individuals involved in the criminal justice system, existing policies, procedures, and correctional culture can challenge these values. According to the Correctional Service of Canada (CSC) (2007), the paramount consideration in the corrections process is the protection of society. This macro-level criminal justice response addresses the needs of the larger community by ensuring safety from offenders. However, the CSC is responsible not only for the community, but also the needs of individuals in their care.
While protection of society from people who have been found guilty is important, this macro-level approach can have detrimental effects on individuals who are vulnerable, disadvantaged, or have mental health concerns. For those people who require extra support in a system designed for the needs of society, the resources do not always exist (John Howard Society of Ontario [JHS], 2015). It is in these instances when the protection of the individual may be more important than the protection of society. For professiona...


... middle of paper ...


...probation orders that can include conditions relating to mental health like participating in treatment, abstaining from illegal substances, or residing at an approved address (JHS, 2015). These conditions criminalize mental health because breaching any single one of them will result in a new criminal charge for 'failing to comply ' and will impact eligibility for release on bail again in the future (JHS, 2015). Most importantly, many people before the courts continue to agree to these conditions, despite the potential consequences because the only other alternative is to remain in custody (JHS, 2015). This results in a cycle of criminal involvement and illustrates that the criminal justice system does not recognize the unique needs of individuals with mental health concerns. Instead, the current system frequently embeds them into a cycle that they cannot escape.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Mental Health Legislation And The Criminal Legislation

- The Criminal Code is an example of legislation that is more aimed at protecting the public and obtaining justice, rather than ensuring psychiatric offenders are treated. That being said, mental health does not only become a legal problem if a mentally ill person enters the justice system. Law plays a large role in access to treatment in a general sense. In British Columbia (BC), the main legislation in this area is the Mental Health Act (MHA). It allows for the same treatment that is used in most jurisdictions – voluntary or involuntary treatment....   [tags: Psychiatry, Mental disorder, Mental health]

Better Essays
2250 words (6.4 pages)

Pro Rights Protecting And Bettering Prisoners Overall Health Essay

- Pro more rights protecting and bettering prisoners overall health It is within legal, ethical, social, and public health reasons why prisoners should be supplied with better health care and improve on those established rights. In the case of Gray v. County of Riverside, California State law conquers with the above statement. In this state, the law is obligated to appoint a grand jury to evaluate county jails every year. As for the 2012 Riverside county jail report, the jury had advised that the medical/mental health staffing levels needed to be raised up to state law standard....   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health economics, Prison]

Better Essays
1037 words (3 pages)

The Stigma of Mental Disabilities Essays

- The concept of desirability has divided society in two groups. One group has been categorized as the higher- achiever and the other group as the low-achievers. This comparison has been embedded into society for so many years. During the 50’s it was used to protect white middle-class students. Today is mostly used to described people who have mental or physical impairments. Sleeter and Longmore researched how the concept of disability has had a negative development through the US society. Sleeter tries to answer the question of why LD category was created....   [tags: stereotypes, discrimination, society]

Better Essays
759 words (2.2 pages)

The Principles Of Confidentiality Of The Health Care Essay

- 1. The principles of confidentiality in the health care government the principles of confidentiality are that patients have the right to expect that you will not disclose any personal information, unless given permission. Also it’s up to the nurse that the patient’s information is effectively protected, transmitted or received. Also patients/carer is to be informed at all times concerning them or the family. (GP-Training.net 2006) 2. The types of small groups and work teams that a nurse is likely to be involved in are Team nursing, Allied Health teams and Medical Teams....   [tags: Nursing, Health care, Health informatics]

Better Essays
1172 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Confidentiality And The Moral Effects On The Health Profession

- In today’s society with the blogs, the gossip sites and the other forms of social media, confidentiality is a thing of the past. However, for, physicians and other health professionals, they are held to a higher standard to maintain a level of ethics and confidentiality for their patients. Confidentiality is a major duty for a health professional, but is there ever a time to where it is okay to tell what a patient says in confident. What if the patient is a minor, or a senior citizen or someone who is mentally challenged....   [tags: Medicine, Health care, Patient]

Better Essays
1333 words (3.8 pages)

Post Partum Depression and Mental Health in Maori Women in New Zealand Essay

- 1. Introduction  Mental health concerns such as depression and anxiety are very common before, and after childbirth. Depression is experienced by up to 15% of all women in the postpartum period, although these rates may be as high as 20% for New Zealand women (McGill, Benzie-Burrows, Holland, Langer & Sweet, 1995; Johnstone, & Read, 2000). The risks associated with delayed/lack of treatment for postnatal depression can have significant adverse effects on early mother-infant attachment and interaction, and can negatively impact the emotional, cognitive, and behavioral development of the child (BPAC, 2010)....   [tags: Depression, Nursing, Childbirth]

Better Essays
2417 words (6.9 pages)

Essay on The Government 's Five Year Strategy For Protecting Public Protection

- In youth justice, there are many principles that are considered when young people break the law. Public protection is a principle that assesses and manages the risks of often violent and sexual offenders, to prevent future harm to the public. The government’s five-year strategy for protecting the public and reducing re-offending introduced in 2006, explains that children and young people should be kept out of prison if possible. Prison sentences should only be considered when there is a great threat to public protection....   [tags: Criminal justice, Crime, Prison, Punishment]

Better Essays
823 words (2.4 pages)

Parents, Be Aware of Health Education for Your Children Essay

- ... Consumer and community health is being aware of the laws of healthcare around you and aware of what healthcare can offer you as a consumer. Next is environmental health, which is to be protecting the environment by recycling and conserving. Lastly is injury prevention and safety, which shows about how to reduce the risk of unintentional injuries by following rules or guidelines. There are six categories of risk behaviors in today’s students. The first one is behaviors that contribute to unintentional and intentional injuries, both of these injuries are very common in young people, and are the leading cause of death....   [tags: health, development, behaviors]

Better Essays
646 words (1.8 pages)

Mental Illness in the United States and Government Policies Essay

- While the U.S. government has passed many bills and laws protecting the rights of the mentally ill and the people around them, there are many aspects of the mental health program that point to the fact that there is still much work to be done. A government-funded program, the National Alliance on Mental Illness or NAMI, insists that despite its $978.4 million budget, the world of mental illness is still remarkably underfunded[1]. This as well as a recent study from the New England Journal of Medicine shows that mental illness is among the most underfunded conditions in comparison to the burden that it takes upon society[2]....   [tags: Policies, Programs, Gun Control]

Better Essays
2980 words (8.5 pages)

The Role and the Relationship Between Professionals and Lay Persons in the Process of Civil Admissions Under the Mental Health Act 1983

- The Role and the Relationship Between Professionals and Lay Persons in the Process of Civil Admissions Under the Mental Health Act 1983 The process of civil admissions under the Mental Health Act (MHA) 1983 may be viewed by civil libertarians as a violation of the individual’s freedom. The state’s justification for such a ‘violation’ is for the need to protect the individual concerned or to protect others in society. The Mental Health Act 1983 does not explicitly require that an individual would have to be ‘dangerous’ in order for that individual to be admitted to hospital....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2046 words (5.8 pages)