Problems of Art Criticism Today Essay

Problems of Art Criticism Today Essay

Length: 818 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Is the concept of art criticism still valued in today’s society?
In this essay I am going to address the problems of art criticism today and whether it still has value in today’s society.
It has been suggested that the critics of today feel they have a lack of influence and a lack of audience. Why is this? James Elkins claims that art criticism is ‘booming’ whilst at the same time is out of the view of contemporary debates which means that art criticism is also dying. There is so much produced from galleries, such as when the gallery put an exhibition on: it will produce a card with a short essay about the artist and work however these forms of art criticism seem to be deemed as unimportant and are quite often ignored. James Elkins states “art criticism is massively produced and massively ignored” as Elkins suggests that most art historians take no notice of what is published in magazines they may follow them as a guide but do not cite from these sources. Art criticism that is taken more seriously by scholars is that which is historically informed and has come out of academic institutions.
There has been a major shift when it concerns art criticism where it concerns art criticism as; in the beginning of the twentieth century it was very different. Critics focused more on the history of art and the history of their own practice. Elkins view is that there were broader comparisons between art critics where as now the contemporary critics seem to just look at the work in the exhibition or just a piece of work, there does not seem to be a very wide view of things or comparison. Art criticism is so hugely funded and there has become so much of it however it has turned into a voiceless practice in some aspects.
The catalog essays pro...


... middle of paper ...


... as one half is motivated by art history and the other half the critics are trying not to judge so not to give prejudgements ruining the work for people who are seeing it for the first time.
As some aspects of art criticism has moved on in the later twentieth century to being more descriptive rather than judgemental. Quentin Bell argues in 1973 there has been a decline of authoritative art critics. He believed there was no ‘canon’ of art critic such as Baudelaire because instead of having a strong critical voice, there was more of a need of description among art critics. Bell claims that art criticism has become ‘weak and dispersed’. He states “while the literature of art is, in publisher’s terms, booming, it has in one respect suffered a loss” as it needs an authoritative voice. Rosalind Krauss says she had been ‘extremely frustrated by the vagueness of opinion’.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Plato's Criticism of Democracy Essay

- Plato's Criticism of Democracy Do not be angry with me for speaking the truth; no man will survive who genuinely opposes you or any other crowd and prevents the occurrence of many unjust and illegal happenings in the city. A man who really fights for justice must lead a private, not a public, life if he is to survive for even a short time. (Apology 31e-32a) These are the words of Socrates, who spoke before the Athenian jury in the trial that would, ultimately, condemn him to his death. Through works such as the Apology and The Republic, we can see Plato’s distaste of the concept of democracy....   [tags: Plato]

Strong Essays
1688 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about The Beauty of Art, Music and Literature in Modern Education

- The Beauty of Art, Music and Literature in Modern Education Art is the beauty of everyday life. Music is what makes us smile. Literature can keep us up all night. So why is it, that there are so much criticism of these three wonders, in education today. In today's society, literature is what is used regularly. In every subject, in science and in language, literature is used in varieties of writing, both in fiction and prose. We write in every subject, although it is not always the same genre. It can be a biography or thesis in a subject....   [tags: expanding the learning experience]

Strong Essays
852 words (2.4 pages)

Criticism on Lord of the Flies Essay

- Lord of the Flies reveals Golding as the supreme revoker, the most obvious abrogator in modern literature, employing the dark discoveries of our century to disclaim the vapid innocence of its predecessor. The target is R. M. Ballantyne's The Coral Island and Golding points up the ironic contrast by lifting even the names of his boys from the earlier work. Ballantyne's book could be used as a document in the history of ideas, reflecting as it does a Victorian euphoria, a conviction that the world is a rational place where problems arise so that sensible, decent men can solve them....   [tags: American Literature]

Strong Essays
3555 words (10.2 pages)

The Arts Build Academic and Social Sills Essay

- It seems to be the impossible dream: to find a way to teach students valuable life skills in a way that is enjoyable. Teachers spend hours attempting to think of ways for students to learn that usually end with unwillingness to participate. Essays and worksheets can teach students a little about these skills, but they will not maintain their interest. Once the students get bored, they lose all motivation to learn, resulting in a less educated generation. Often overlooked, the arts provide an easy, fun way for students of all ages to learn these skills that use a student’s already present energy and creativity for learning....   [tags: Benefits of Art Programs]

Strong Essays
2078 words (5.9 pages)

Edmund Feldman and Art Criticism Essay

- Edmund Burke Feldman was an Alumni Foundation Distinguished University Professor of Art at the University of Georgia. He was an art educator as well as an art historian. He has written several books about art including The Philosophy of Art Education, First Edition, 1995. The primary focus of this paper is to inform and show what Doctor Feldman thought was important to art teachers by correlating the practices of teaching art to the issues of philosophy Doctor Feldman wanted to bring together both subjects of art education and art teaching....   [tags: Art Education ]

Strong Essays
1750 words (5 pages)

Engaging with Art Essay examples

- Johnny comes home from work late. He feels tired and decides to spend the night relaxing in front of the tv and entertain himself with some shows. His cable company offers him around a hundred tv channels. He taps the remote control until through the variety of programs he finds something familiar and appealing. He is soon engulfed by the plot to the point that the tv show provides a comfortable escape from his stressful life. There are many similar forms of passive entertainment he could have chosen from: internet browsing, gallery shopping, concert going, music, etc....   [tags: Art Criticism Essays]

Strong Essays
1539 words (4.4 pages)

The Art of Criticism Essay

- Plato’s republic is based, largely, on order and responsibility. The only morality in this society deals with the relative functions of the members of said society. For example: A man kills another man. Why is this a bad thing. In most societies, this would be considered bad or wrong because the societal morals dictate that one’s life is sacred and one’s body is one’s own etc etc etc. In Plato’s republic, the only reason people (namely, Plato) would be against a murder, is because, once a man has lost his life, he will no longer be able to function according to the provenance of the governing bodies....   [tags: Censorship]

Strong Essays
2401 words (6.9 pages)

Why We Should Read Great Literature Essay

- Why We Should Read Great Literature In Western culture, many literary works have been set apart from the rest by being termed great literature. What qualifies a work to be great literature, and why should we read it. An excellent source on this topic is Mortimer Adler, one of the premier American philosophers of the twentieth century and founder of the famous Great Books List. According to Adler, all great literature meets three criteria: the work is pertinent to contemporary life, is worth rereading, and contains "great ideas." Six of these "great ideas," defined by Adler, are three great ideas by which we judge--truth, goodness, and beauty--and three great ideas by which we live--...   [tags: Literature Essays Literary Criticism]

Free Essays
583 words (1.7 pages)

Violence Against Women In Music Essay

- Violence Against Women In Music Particularly distressing in today's society is the level of dysfunctional relationships. Values considered outdated and baseless, such as mutual respect, consideration for another person's feelings, and common courtesy, are becoming extinct human customs. Especially troubling are the violent misogynous messages infused in hard-core rock and rap music and their negative effects on today's youth. Healthy relationships of mutual love, respect, and compromise between men and women of all races and social classes are instrumental to a sane and stable society....   [tags: Feminism Feminist Women Criticism]

Strong Essays
993 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Problems of Art, Problems of Education

- Problems of Art, Problems of Education ABSTRACT: Some main postmodern ideas, such as the decay of totality or the dispersion of the subject, are too risky to introduce into the education of youth. However, there are some postmodern ideas — though not central ones — that could prove helpful in contemporary education. The hero of this paper is the prefix "inter-" which (especially in the French philosophers' writings) took a new and remarkable meaning by becoming one of the main metaphors of the human condition in the world of culture....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Essays]

Free Essays
2509 words (7.2 pages)