Essay on The Problem Of Other Minds

Essay on The Problem Of Other Minds

Length: 1275 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In a world of over seven billion people, one can often feel alone due to factors such as social isolation, lack of intimate connections, and general stress. This feeling of loneliness is often times made worse by the presumed understanding that these seven billion people are alive and conscious. But why is it that humans assume anyone aside from themselves possess true consciousness and a developed mind? This idea that everyone has a mind is not, in fact, inborn. Children do not exhibit development of a theory of mind, the understanding that other humans possess thoughts, consciousness and intentionality, until around the ages of three or four. Past this age, those questioning whether others could have a mind are considered to be either philosophers or suffering from a mental abnormality. Focusing specifically on former, philosophers address this assumption by exploring the problem of other minds: a challenge that questions if one can only observe the behavior of others and is not privy to any potential inner workings, how can one attribute a mind to others? The objective of this paper is to explore interdisciplinary approaches to proving others do have minds similar to one’s own and weigh in on the credibility of the credibility of the problem of other minds.
As anyone who has taken a European history or general philosophy course can attest to, the famous philosopher René Descartes set the stage for using introspection as a measure of mental states. His famous phrase, “I think, therefore I am” supports the idea that humans are only capable of proving their own existence by confirming the presence of a mind. According to the New World Encyclopedia, “Introspection provides a foundation for knowledge of the physical world, and one...


... middle of paper ...


...lower of Freud, believed instead that the unconscious was divided into two categories, the first being the personal unconscious and the second being the collective unconscious. The personal unconscious, similar to Freud’s unconscious, is largely filled with material either suppressed or forgotten by the conscious mind. The collective conscious is an inherited reservoir of psychic structures and experiences. The collective conscious is shared by the entire human race and can explain phenomena such as innate fears that all or most humans share, such as fear of spiders. Aside from criticisms of Freud’s emphasis on sex, the unconscious mind is largely criticized for simply being a misunderstanding of experiences of which we are unaware. Some critics state that there is no unconscious mind at all. After all, how can humans have concrete thoughts without registering them?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Problem Of Other Minds

- In “The Problem of Other Minds” Carruther 's argues that we as humans, cannot have knowledge of other people 's mental states other than our own. It is possible that when one calls an object red, it may appear green to another person. Thus, both members could possibly have the same or completely different experience without ever noticing, as we call those experience by the same names. Carruther 's arguments shouldn 't be taken seriously, as I believe the the problem could be looked at from analogy....   [tags: Perception, Psychology, Meaning of life, Knowledge]

Better Essays
1029 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Problem Of Other Minds

- In a world of over seven billion people, one can often feel alone due to factors such as social isolation, lack of intimate connections, and general stress. This feeling of loneliness is often times made worse by the presumed understanding that these seven billion people are alive and conscious. But why is it that humans assume anyone aside from themselves possess true consciousness and a developed mind. This idea that everyone has a mind is not, in fact, inborn. Children do not exhibit development of a theory of mind, the understanding that other humans possess thoughts, consciousness and intentionality, until around the ages of three or four....   [tags: Mind, Consciousness, Psychology, Unconscious mind]

Better Essays
1275 words (3.6 pages)

The Argument From Analogy For Other Minds Essay

- The problem I hope to expose in this paper is the lack of evidence in The Argument from Analogy for Other Minds supporting that A, a thought or feeling, is the only cause of B. Russell believes that there are other minds because he can see actions in others that are analogous to his own without thinking about them. He believes that all actions are caused by thoughts, but what happens when we have a reaction resulting as an action of something forced upon one’s self. Such as when a doctor hits your patellar tendon with a reflex hammer to test your knee-jerk reflex....   [tags: Logic, Thought, Cognition, Psychology]

Better Essays
1146 words (3.3 pages)

Do Non Human Animals Understand Other Minds? Essays

- Do non-human animals understand other minds. ‘Theory of mind’ is the concept used to define this question (cited in Hewson et al, 2015, p.83). This essay will describe research studies which have addressed the issue of whether non-human animals have a ‘theory of mind’. To begin with, this essay will describe Premack and Woodruff (1978, cited in Hewson, 2015) research based on their research question ‘does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind?’ (cited in Hewson et al, 2015, p.86). Then this essay will go on to explain what psychologists Call and Tomasello (2008, cited in Hewson, 2015) have concluded with regards to this issue....   [tags: Human, Psychology, Mind, Chimpanzee]

Better Essays
920 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Scott Russel Sanders' The Men We Carry in Our Minds

- Scott Russel Sanders' The Men We Carry in Our Minds In "The Men We Carry in Our Minds," Scott Russel Sanders tries to show how his views on men are completely different from the views that some women hold. He traces the problem to the country surroundings of his youth. He explains that the men he observed as a child were completely different from the men whom most women might observe. The differing viewpoints between him and the women he met in college caused him some grief. However, it was not so much an issue of gender, but an issue of class....   [tags: Sanders Men We Carry Minds Sanders Essays]

Better Essays
716 words (2 pages)

The Problem Of Evil, And The Belief Of God Essay

- The Problem of Evil, and its role in the belief in God For hundreds of years, many philosophers have found themselves left with the uncertainty on a very simple question; “Does God exist?” and if God does or doesn’t exist how can one prove as such. Many arguments from the wording of the question to arguments from analogy are often discussed, but this essay will be centered on the argument of The Problem of Evil, which states a valid argument against the belief in God from the existence of many forms of evil presented in the world....   [tags: Free will, Problem of evil, Omniscience, Evil]

Better Essays
1208 words (3.5 pages)

Use of Problem-based Learning (PBL) in Medical Education Essays

- Introduction: Day after day, the medical education is evolving in many aspects. In order to match this development, this requires changing the traditional methods of learning into a new modern one that embraces the requirements of Knowles' theory of adult learning. This theory states that adults are independent and self-directed, have a great deal of experience, interested in problem-centered approaches and get their learning motivation from internal drives. Moreover, the new way of learning should be student-centered and enable students to obtain knowledge in an accessible, efficient and integrated way.1ASSIGNMENT1 In the 1970s, a new way of learning arose at the medical school of McMaster...   [tags: Problem-based Learning]

Better Essays
1283 words (3.7 pages)

International Personality Conflict Resolution By Different Minds Tackle The Same Problem

- International personality relates to dispute resolution by different minds tackle the same problem. Bringing in many different points of view can make for a product of a new lenses to solve a problem. Having nations with different past experiences that could apply and have had levels of previous success that shows the most productive reasoning in the solution. Different international organization plays a key role in controlling the international personalities in disputes that may arise. Trade relations often involve conflicting interests and end up in arguments that are not productive....   [tags: United Nations, Human rights, Law]

Better Essays
1332 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about The Theory Of Mind And The Minds

- Current research has suggested that until the ages of four, children are unable to recognize that other people’s knowledge are different from theirs because they find it hard to distinguish between reality and the beliefs and knowledge in their minds (ref). They think these are a representation of their current reality. Theory of mind enables one understand that reality can be misrepresented by the mind thus beliefs can differ from reality .The possession of theory of mind enables an individual influence the behaviour of others by manipulating their beliefs....   [tags: Mind, Psychology, Philosophy of mind, Perception]

Better Essays
1697 words (4.8 pages)

Medicating Young Minds Essay

- Medicating Young Minds In the article, “Medicating Young Minds”, which was published in Time magazine, dated November 3, 2003, it is stated that using stimulant medication on the youth is harmful. The article's author, Jeffrey Kluger, states that society must find alternative ways to treat young people for problems such as; ADD, ADHD, depression, anxiety, etc. Jeffrey Kluger's argument is not very persuasive for various reasons: their ill-logical beliefs, their sarcastic tones, their opinion and lack of fact based information, and their tendency to be biased in their writing....   [tags: ADD ADHD Depression Anxiety]

Better Essays
1322 words (3.8 pages)