The Problem Of Elite Regulation Essay

The Problem Of Elite Regulation Essay

Length: 1743 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


The Problem Of Elite Regulation
There is a long standing problem in political theory that can be best summed by the Latin phrase “Quis custodiet ipsos custodies?” which roughly translates to “Who will guard the guards themselves?” (Juvenal 347-8). This refers to the idea of any government-like body needing a certain set of rules that dictate how the body can function, thus keeping its members’ supremacy in control. Hence, the problem of elite regulation, in its bare form, is that while a subset of authoritative figures is essential for society to function, it is their very authority that can harm the society that they govern, and thus they need to be delimited in ways that have positive, rather than negative, effects on said society.
First, it is necessary to think about the framework and background of elite regulation. It can be thought of as the second level of proper order. It is not something that is unique to East Asian political theory, rather it transcends boundaries, even into supposedly purely democratic societies. The need for this sort of regulation was summed by Lord Acton, 19th century British parliamentarian, when he said, “The tendency of power is to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” Elite regulation deals with the reduction in motivation for this sort of corruption that can wreak havoc on socio-economic systems. Regulation in Acton’s world can take the form of an enforced constitution, the press, or even the power of public opinion. (Magagna 10/26)
From the East Asian perspective, questioning the elite can be traced to the times of Confucius and Mencius. Mencius, in fact, asked the king if the blood of the people killed by the government or due its inadequacies was on the king’s hands, since he...


... middle of paper ...


...and the difference between good and bad. They would not want to take advantage of the people, and they feel a responsibility towards society even though they understand that they ideally would not face much music for making the wrong decision.
The Confucian solution has multiple methods of implementation, such as civil service examinations, and the creation of an informal elite such as the Chinese Gentry. However, it also focuses on teaching morals to public leaders to build their character (Magagna 10/28). Since Confucians understand that for any society to function, the elite are necessary, they give a lot of importance to the fact that corrupt leaders can cause as much harm as model leaders can cause good. The elite then, must be regulated, because they are necessary, but without any checks, they can exploit the people and can cause society to collapse.









Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Social Organizations and Moral Regulation Projects: Governing Morals by Alan Hunt

- Moral regulation has been – and still is – a very heated topic for discussion. In chapters two and three of his book, Governing Morals: A Social History of Moral Regulation, author Alan Hunt speaks of various social organizations and their different attempts at moral regulation projects from the late 18th to early 20th century. Although the two chapters flow into each other, and time turns from one century to the next, various and complex societal changes, and in turn, approaches to moral regulation are noted....   [tags: victorian societies, moral regulation]

Strong Essays
1191 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The Problem of Internet Regulation in the U.S. Today

- Many Americans today rely on the Internet for two main reasons: information and connectivity. Some may consider it as the biggest library available because of the endless information it can provide. It further enhanced people’s knowledge of what’s going on all around the globe and has been proved to be a very powerful tool that is available for anyone to use. Communication improved not just here in the United States of America, but also in other countries thanks to social media. Despite of all this, there is still an evident problem for American citizens when it comes to Internet Regulation....   [tags: neutrality, privacy, piracy]

Strong Essays
2640 words (7.5 pages)

Indian Gaming Regulation Laws On Gaming Essay

- For this chapter, the topics of Indian gaming and regulations set for them are discussed in detail as it goes over the different kinds of gaming and the laws that are used or created to regulate them. Indian gaming has proven to be the most successful and largest generator for revenue but there are tribes that refuse or unable to take part in this because of moral or traditional reasons or that their geographic establishment makes it difficult to enable gaming. The main law that oversees this topic is the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act that allows states to apply laws to a limit....   [tags: Law, Regulation]

Strong Essays
1290 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on The Regulation Of Sexuality As A Social Problem

- Sexuality has long been the ultimate subject of moral regulation projects. In Hunt’s Governing Morals, the regulation of sexuality is introduced via Hunt’s description of the historical timeline of various phases of moral regulation campaigns. Conversely, in Kinsman’s “The Creation of Homosexuality as a Social Problem”, Marxist’s analogies, as well as the role social relations and are utilized to explain the regulation of sexuality. While there are commonalities between the two authors in their approach to the governance of sexuality, each provides their own unique twist on the topic of such regulation....   [tags: Sociology, Homosexuality, Marxism, Gender role]

Strong Essays
1056 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Public Benefit View Of Government Regulation

- In each of the three scenarios presented in the case, opponents and proponents have divergent views of government regulations. One view is on the public benefit, the other is on the cost to private industry. How can you decide which view to accept. Currently being a member of the public, I would side with the benefit viewpoint. I also must imagine that people in the private industry, albeit concerned with their company and its profits, also enjoy the world that they live in and don’t want to see it burned to the ground....   [tags: Cost-benefit analysis, Cost, Regulation]

Strong Essays
711 words (2 pages)

The Ethical Dilemma of E-Cigarette Regulation Essay

- Introduction Ethical dilemmas occur on many different scales. These dilemmas, and the complexity attached to them, range from personal to corporate conflict. Depending on the nature and structure of a particular situation and the values in conflict, personal definitions of what an ethical dilemma is may vary. Harold Gortner defines an ethical dilemma as “ a situation where two or more competing values are important and in conflict. If you serve one value, you cannot server another, or you must deny of disserve one or more values in order to maintain one or more of the others”....   [tags: Food and Drug Administration regulations]

Strong Essays
1912 words (5.5 pages)

Metacognition, Self Regulation, And Self Regulated Learning Essay

- Metacognition is a cognitive theory, defined as a leaner’s awareness of his or her own learning process. Grounded in constructivist theory, metacognition gained widespread prominence in the 1970s. Metacognition, or “thinking about thinking”, is not a clearly defined word. research on metacognition, self-regulation, and self-regulated learning must be firmly connected with theory. As Winters et al. (2008) note, the lack of clear guiding conceptual frameworks in research studies creates confusion in terminology and leads researchers to use terms interchangeably....   [tags: Problem solving, Educational psychology]

Strong Essays
1240 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Alumina Inc Regulation Case Study

- Introduction Alumina Inc. (AI) is a U.S. based international aluminum company with eight locations worldwide, worth of $4 billion. Its business markets include “automotive components and manufacture of packaging materials, bauxite mining, alumina refining, and aluminum smelting” (University of Phoenix simulation, 2008) and the company falls under the following regulatory agencies and acts: The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), and Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA)....   [tags: Environmental Business Regulation]

Free Essays
2215 words (6.3 pages)

RFID Standards And Regulation Essays

- While the potential benefits of RFID technology are clear and abundant, there is a definite need to regulate the development and implementation of the RFID technology. Not only must standards of regulation and operation be developed, but RFID technology raises privacy and security issues because of the passive and open nature of the technology. In order for the RFID tag industry to be successful in implementation there needs to be uniform standards and regulation so that tags and readers from different manufactures will be able to communicate with each other....   [tags: Business Regulation]

Free Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Business Regulation Case Essay

- The challenges that surrounded Alumina, Inc. could have been detrimental to the corporation. Areas the management team needed to concentrate on were the corporation's image to the general public as well as competitors, current customers and potential customers. Management's duty was to manage the crisis by preventing extensive losses to the company while at the same time preserving the image of the company and doing right by the community. As a team we agreed upon the strategies and recommendations to solve the challenges for Alumina, Inc., although the timing of how the events would play out was slightly different....   [tags: Business Regulation]

Free Essays
1996 words (5.7 pages)