The two pro-slavery articles gave support to the idea that slavery was right and it benefited the economy. They backed up their argument by mentioning that the North paid the immigrants less money to grow their industries; they also gave them shelters that were in horrible condition. They believed that the way immigrants were treated was worse than slavery. The article “The Charleston Courier” by a Carolinian pointed out that when a Northerner buys indentured servants, they were not considered guilty of the same crime when a Southerner buys slaves. He also stated that a Northerner gave immigrants low incomes for their hard work although they knew that it was insufficient for their family. The bottom line of the author 's argument was that he believed the South’s labor system was a “re...
... middle of paper ...
...d that most slaves in the South were happy and treated well by their masters. He also believed that moral values were taught to the slaves in an attempt to keep the slaves grateful and happy. The other two testimonies were from the Northern immigrants who had a bad experience in the labor system. The two immigrants that moved to New York for labor were treated poorly by their employers. They moved to America because they heard there was a boom in the industries. They were paid less for their hard work and the industries did not care if it was not enough. The immigrants were not fed properly and they lived in homes that were in bad condition. As a result, the immigrants were disappointed because of the false accusation. All these testimonies supported the arguments of the pro-slavery authors. The authors were right about the immigrants treated horribly in the North.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Slavery was a dominant part of the political and social arenas of 1800’s America. However, it was not homogenous as it divided America into two distinct groups: those who supported it and those who did not. Traditionally, the states in the north had been anti-slavery while the states in the south had been pro-slavery. Southern life and economy depended on slavery and therefore staunchly supported the continued legal status of slavery. The northern states on the other hand recognized the inhumane nature of slavery and campaigned to establish equality for all citizens.... [tags: anti-slavery, pro-slavery, theology, equality]
1362 words (3.9 pages)
- The south was very passionate about slavery. They were willing to give up everything in order to keep it. This is something that seems crazy to me, because when we look back onto slavery and it seems so terrible. The south became extremely dependent upon slavery very quickly. Cash crops started becoming more popular which made the need for land rise greatly.Plantations, and farms were far too large for their owners alone to take care of. In the south the cotton industry was on an all-time high. As the cash crops were on the rise the needs for workers were also.... [tags: American Civil War, Slavery in the United States]
744 words (2.1 pages)
- Slavery was woven in to American traditions just as tightly as the laws abiding to the Constitution. A cycle of dependency had been created within slavery that made the process of transitioning from it, a difficult and long drawn out process. Slave owners had conditioned African Americans into believing they had no other option but to live under the control of their “masters” by the use of family ties and fear. Then the slave owners themselves had invested such a large amount of need for their slaves to help aid in their successes by doing their farming for them.... [tags: Slavery in the United States, Slavery]
1232 words (3.5 pages)
- Slave narratives were extremely important in gathering the support of the white northerners for the abolition of slavery. Former slaves such as Frederick Douglass, Harriet Tubman, Sojourner Truth, and many others gave speeches, published pamphlets, and wrote autobiographies depicting the horrific conditions under which they lived as slaves. The detailed stories of the living conditions and atrocities suffered by these former slaves helped gain support for the anti-slavery movement. Not everyone living in the North condoned slavery and even some of those living in the South were influenced by the stories told by former slaves as well as what they witnessed themselves firsthand.... [tags: Slavery in the United States, Abolitionism]
1288 words (3.7 pages)
- ... Samuel Cartwright was a physician and pro-slavery advocate during the 1800’s and is well known for his diagnosis of drapetomania, a supposed disease that made slaves runaway. He concluded that the reason African slaves sought to escape was because they were treated inadequately by their masters. Delving deeper in his writings it is discovered he too, like George Fitzhugh, approved of enslavement. Both men advocated the issue and have similar analyzes on how slaves are or should be treated. Cartwright expresses to his audience that slaves will most likely run (drapetomania) if they are treated poorly by their master; “according to my experience, the "genu flexit"--the awe and reverence, m... [tags: positions, goals, party, slavery]
1248 words (3.6 pages)
- Similar to any hotly debated topic, slavery was surrounded with many different view points. Many students are led to believe there were only two sides to the slavery debate: those who wanted slavery and those who did not. In general, this was correct. There were actually sub groups of people within these two sides. Different theorists had different ideas about why slavery needed to be upheld or why slavery needed to be abolished. These arguments persisted throughout the United States until they eventual led to the Civil War.... [tags: Slavery in the United States, Compromise of 1850]
901 words (2.6 pages)
- Slavery in the South A large majority of whites in the South supported slavery even though fewer of a quarter of them owned slaves because they felt that it was a necessary evil and that it was an important Southern institution. In 1800 the population of the United States included 893,602 slaves, of which only 36,505 were in the northern states. Vermont, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, New York, and New Jersey provided for the emancipation of their slaves before 1804, most of them by gradual measures.... [tags: Slavery Essays]
683 words (2 pages)
- Support of Slavery by the Christian Church The belief in some higher presence, other than our own, has existed since man can recollect. Religion was established from this belief, and it can survive and flourish because of this belief. Christianity, one of several forms of religion that exist today, began sometime during the middle of the first century. Christians believe in a higher presence that they call "God." This belief in God is based on faith, not fact; faith is "unquestioning belief that does not require proof or evidence." (Webster's New World College Dictionary, 1996, p.... [tags: Slavery Essays]
2850 words (8.1 pages)
- Slavery in Colonial America The first arrivals of Africans in America were treated similarly to the indentured servants in Europe. Black servants were treated differently from the white servants and by 1740 the slavery system in colonial America was fully developed. Slavery as it existed in America was a practice founded on the chattel principle. Slaves were treated as human chattel to be traded, sold, used, and ranked not among beings, but among things, as an article of property to the owner or possessor.... [tags: Slavery Essays]
791 words (2.3 pages)
- One of the most unique situations during the period of the Civil War in America was the involvement of the state of Texas in the Confederacy. Although it was once its own Republic separate from the United States of America through annexation, Texas was not entirely unique when it came to the institution of slavery. Just like in all other southern states, slavery, and the use of slave labor, was a major factor of the states agricultural economy. During the years around and through the Civil War, Texas became a home for many transient southerners in search of sanctuary from the almost enviable furthering of emancipation.... [tags: Slavery Essays]
2384 words (6.8 pages)