Essay on The Privilage by Journalists to Resist Criminal Process

Essay on The Privilage by Journalists to Resist Criminal Process

Length: 1617 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I. BOTH THE FIRST AMENDMENT AND FEDERAL COMMON LAW RECOGNIZE A QUALIFIED PRIVILEGE BY JOURNALISTS TO RESIST CRIMINAL PROCESS.
Both the first amendment and federal common law recognize a qualified privilege by journalists to resist criminal process. This brief first analyzes both the Supreme Court’s holding and reasoning in Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665 (1972), and its interpretation by lower circuits for the reporter’s privilege under the First Amendment. The brief then examines Fed. R. Evid. 501 and the evolution of federal common law related to the reporter’s privilege.
The Tenth Circuit reviews a district court’s order granting a motion to quash a grand jury subpoena for an abuse of discretion. See In re Grand Jury Proceedings, 616 F.3d 1186, 1201 (10th Cir. 2010). “A district court abuses its discretion when it commits an error of law.” United States v. Commanche, 577 F.3d 1261, 1266 (10th Cir. 2009). Whether the First Amendment or the federal common law recognizes a qualified privilege by journalists to resist criminal process is a pure question of law. The Tenth Circuit reviews purely legal questions de novo. See In re Grand Jury Subpoenas, 906 F.2d 1485, 1488 (10th Cir. 1990).
A. The District Court Correctly Recognized a Qualified Reporter’s Privilege Arising under the First Amendment That Protects Against Disclosure of Confidential Source Information in a Criminal Context.
The district court correctly held that, “based on Silkwood, . . . the Tenth Circuit would recognize a qualified privilege by journalists to resist criminal process.” R. at 3. This holding is consistent with both the Supreme Court’s reasoning in Branzburg and with the interpretation of Branzburg by a vast majority of circuits.
1. The Supre...


... middle of paper ...


...tronger than in Jaffee”).
Further, strong public policies exist in favor of protecting journalists from making compelled disclosures. Protection for the press serves the private end of encouraging individuals to provide journalists with truthful, newsworthy information anonymously. Such protection also serves the important public function of keeping the public informed, and providing essential information for making governing decisions in a democracy. See Ashcraft, 218 F.3d at 287. Indeed, confidentiality is essential for journalists to sustain their relationships with sources and to obtain sensitive information from them. Without it, the press cannot effectively serve the public by keeping it informed. Therefore, public policies also strongly favor shielding journalists from involuntary disclosures of confidential news sources, including in criminal cases.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Criminal Justice System and Process Essay

- Introduction According to Morrison (2008) crime is a salient fact which is an integral part of many adverse risks humans are susceptible to, today. On the other hand a crime which is a wrong doing can be classified as a felony or a misdemeanor; this is because it is against a public law. A felony can be defined as a serious crime that is punishable by at least a year’s jail-term whereas a misdemeanor is a crime whose punishment is either a fine or and up to a year in jail (Smith, 2008). Crimes are therefore defined as well as punished by statutes and the common law....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Powerful Essays
1346 words (3.8 pages)

Criminal Justice Process Essay

- When a crime is committed against another person, then justice must be served to those who committed the crime. In some cases the crimes involve sexual attacks on grown adults while some offenses are against minors. In these examples the underling connection is the committed crimes of sexual abuse or sexual assault on adults and minors. When these crimes are brought before the justice system they are processed and the convicted are given a sentence to carry out but sometimes those sentences may not provide efficient time to produce the required outcome of correcting the individual or may be determined that there is no fixing the convicted disorder....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Powerful Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Process of Criminal Investigation and Evidence

- “The investigation of [a]crime encompasses the collection of information and evidence for identifying, apprehending, and convicting suspected offenders” (Osterburg). Many things may come to mind when an investigation is mentioned, such as TV shows of Law and Order, CSI and Criminal Minds. The realities of an investigation though differ from these TV shows immensely. In reality, there are certain responsibilities an investigator must go through to achieve the evidence needed to prosecute the offender and close the case successfully....   [tags: crime scene, investigator, case evidence]

Powerful Essays
1315 words (3.8 pages)

The Crime Control Model and the due Process Model in The Brothel Boy Essay

- There are two main models in the criminal process, the crime control model and the due process model. The crime control model focuses on repression of crime in a speedy and conclusive way. The use of “presumptions of guilt” speeds the process up because very little evidence is needed against the suspect for them to be considered guilty. In this model, it is believed the laws should be stricter, the police force should be increased, and the sentences should be more intense. The due process model has more steps and is more dependable....   [tags: criminal process, crime, brothe boy]

Powerful Essays
563 words (1.6 pages)

Procedures in the Criminal Justice System Essay

- “The criminal process is part of the State’s response to crime, part of the mechanism which the State applies substantive criminal law to its citizens”. (Ashworth & Redmayne, 2005, p.2) Within this essay, I will be looking at the procedures in the Criminal Justice System. Before laying the foundations of this work, I will briefly dedicate a few lines on what the Criminal Justice System is about. A Criminal Justice System is a set of legal and social establishments for carrying out the criminal law in agreement with a definite set of procedural regulations and restrictions....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Powerful Essays
1038 words (3 pages)

Criminal Justice: The Goals of Sentencing Essays

- Sentencing is the imposition of a criminal sanction by a sentencing authority , such as a judge. Schmallger & Smykla, 2009, pg# 71) There are seven goals of sentencing including revenge, retribution, just deserts, deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation and restoration. Revenge refers to a retaliation to some kind of assault and injury. Revenge can be a type of punishment for the criminal justice system. The jury, sometimes, basis there choices on emotions, facts and evidence. It is considered revenge in some cases because the victim's looks at it that way when they feel justice has been served....   [tags: criminal justice]

Powerful Essays
725 words (2.1 pages)

Criminal Justice Trends Essay

- The criminal justice system is a group of institutions that work together to protect a society, prevent and control crime, and maintain justice; enforcing the laws regulated by society. As the years have gone by and society has evolved; so have the criminal justice system and its methods to accomplish its role in society. This short analysis will evaluate the main facts that have been affecting the criminal justice system for decades and have influenced the evolution the justice system is enduring in a changing society (Muraski, 2009)....   [tags: Criminal Justice]

Powerful Essays
1561 words (4.5 pages)

Criminal Trial Process Paper

- Criminal Trial Process Paper Introduction: In Canada, our criminal trial process is based around an adversarial system. What this means is that the disputants are represented by professionals in the field of law. These professionals are called lawyers. The lawyers work so that the truth of the trial is brought forward and justice is served for the greater community. In the adversarial system it is believed that the search for truth is best served by the parties themselves, through their lawyers and not through the judge....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
2017 words (5.8 pages)

Criminal Procedure Essay

- The due process and crime control models, both created by Stanford University law professor Herbert Packer, represents two opposing method of principles functioning within criminal justice system. Although the models describe the important facets of the politics and practice of criminal justice, both have been criticized since presented by Packer in 1964. Presently both models are acknowledged as imperfect standards to explain the politics and law of criminal justice. The crime control ideal represents traditional principles, whereas the due process belief reflects moderate values; therefore generating conflict evident throughout the years....   [tags: Criminal Justice ]

Powerful Essays
1407 words (4 pages)

Criminal Sanction Essay

- Introduction The high level of activity in the criminal justice system and the resultant productivity arise from a range of interconnected beliefs that the implementation of criminal sanctions to offenders is an essential and useful means of holding up the existing moral and political order. That is to say, the criminal sanction can be deemed to be a reinforcer of the moral beliefs and social order. This paper, however, will look at both sides of the application of criminal sanction. ‘Used providently and humanely it is a guarantor of human freedom; used indiscriminately and coercively, it is a threatener.’ (Packer, 1968:366) Professor Packer uses his knowledge and understanding of the nat...   [tags: Criminal Justice, Crime Control Model]

Powerful Essays
2392 words (6.8 pages)