Privatizing The Foster Care System Essay

Privatizing The Foster Care System Essay

Length: 1236 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Garrett Therolf said “Children in foster homes overseen by private agencies are one-third more likely to be physically, mentally, or sexually abused than children in homes overseen by the state” (qtd. in White). The debate on whether or not to privatize the foster care system is ongoing and is an excellent source for debate. While privatizing the foster care system does seem to have its advantages, such as the convenience, they are heavily outweighed by the many negative aspects of a privatized system. Privatizing the foster care system is an overall negative idea due to the fact that it turns desperate children into business pawns putting them at higher risk for many kinds of abuse. Privatization increases abuse and neglect among helpless children for the sake of convenience in the foster care system. In addition, the privatization, when put into practice, has failed leaving states at a loss for money. These reasons add up to support why to avoid privatization and why the foster care system should remain on a government operated basis.
To begin, the largest and most easily found argument made in support of privatizing the Foster Care System is that of convenience. Factors supporting this privatization include: private agencies providing prompter responses, faster completion of home studies leading to faster placement of children into homes, and private agencies typically work with children classified as easier to place (“Differences Public Private”). While these points sound like valid reasons to support privatization, in reality they provide more support against it. Private agencies may provide prompter return of calls to clients, which is mainly due to the smaller outreach of these agencies compared to state agencies. The small...


... middle of paper ...


...n is not the simple solution to the foster care system that many people seem to hope that it is and Nebraska serves as a cautionary tale to other states warning them against rushing into the idea of privatization. (“Privatization Child Welfare”; O’Hanlon).
Overall, the supposed benefits of privatizing the foster care system are misleading and are heavily outweighed by the many negatives leading to the conclusion that the foster care system should remain under the control of the government. Many example of abuse, neglect, and bankruptcy in privatize homes support the grounds that a government run system is for the best interest of the children as well as the state. Maintaining these state run systems will help to improve the lives and futures of the children in the foster care system by providing them with better care and better chances of finding permanent families.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Foster Care System And Adoptions Essay

- Foster Care System and Adoptions can be very beneficial to children, but it can also be a huge risk. It is very beneficial needed in the community; otherwise where would some children be. Although it’s also huge risk because it’s taking someone’s child away and one may never know how the biological parent may react. However, the beneficial portion outweighs the risk portion. There are many children in the world; every child has a parent. However, some parents are more mature than others. Some people are meant to be parents and, some people start out good parents but engage in some bad habits along the way....   [tags: Family, Adoption, Foster care]

Better Essays
1014 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Children Of The Foster Care System

- As of 2014, there were over 415,000 children in the foster care system. Foster care is the raising and supervision of children in a private home, group home, or institution, by individuals engaged and paid by a social service agency (Legal Dictionary, 2016). Care givers can be of kin relationship to the child, or may not know the child at all. Group homes are run by a social worker and can house multiple children at a time. These homes are usually regulated by the state and/or government. Children of all ages go through many emotions when their lives revolve in foster care....   [tags: Foster care, Family, Attachment theory]

Better Essays
799 words (2.3 pages)

The Foster Care System Essay

- How have you ever wondered what it 's like to be in the foster Care System. There are so many scary stories that people throw out there and yes, some may be true but there 's not always the case. There are homes where the parents and the rest of the family is very kind hearted and beautiful. I mean I can 't say I 've been in the foster care system where the house parents are so terrible. I had experiences at bad homes before, but never in a crazy way. I know it is hard to have other people you don 't know try to be in charge of you....   [tags: Foster care, Family]

Better Essays
1855 words (5.3 pages)

Essay on The Failures Of The Foster Care System

- The Failures of the Foster Care System To many outsiders, the foster care system may appear to be a safe haven for those children that are abused or abandoned by their birth family. This is correct, but the system with which it is based, has many flaws. A background check is mandatory for all foster parents, but a test to see if a child 's temperament matches that caregiver 's parenting style, is not. Now, this is seen as a minor issue, but there is not enough evidence to support this. Plus, there are many other, much worse reasons, why the system is not perfect....   [tags: Foster care, Family, Adoption, Aging out]

Better Essays
1255 words (3.6 pages)

Children Of The Foster Care System Essay

- More than likely the title was alarming to most people because how can one be “too old” for food and a place to say. Imagine being somewhere from the time you were a toddler, then all of a sudden your eighteenth birthday comes and suddenly you are kicked out of the only place you have had to call home for 18 years. That’s how it is for a teenager in the foster care system. It doesn’t matter how good you thought your life was, good behavior, or love, for some turning 18 means freedom, cigarettes, army, voting e.tc however, for children in the system 18 means homeless, hungry and alone....   [tags: Foster care, Fosterage, Attachment theory, Youth]

Better Essays
930 words (2.7 pages)

I Am The Foster Care System Essay

- Before I entered the foster care system, I thought that I would walk in the same footsteps as my sisters. I would probably get pregnant at the age of fifteen or be on the streets, but everything changed when I met my foster parents. I experienced the support of a caring family, the importance in making good decisions for the future, and learned about college. At the age of sixteen, I moved into my foster parents’ home, that it was my second foster home in one year. I thought, "Oh man, here we go again....   [tags: Family, Foster care, Fosterage]

Better Essays
1023 words (2.9 pages)

The Foster Care System Is A Federal Service Essay examples

- The foster care system intervenes and places youth in substitute homes when biological or primary caregivers are unable to deliver adequate care for their children. The foster care system is a federal service that aims to ensure safety, stability, and wellbeing to such vulnerable children (Valdez, Lim, & Parker, 2015). One study on former foster youth adults found that 90% of the participants had experienced at least one form of childhood maltreatment before entering the foster care system. Most participants experienced more than one kind of abuse....   [tags: Foster care, Child protection, Abuse, Ward]

Better Essays
897 words (2.6 pages)

Child Welfare Within Our Foster Care System Essays

- When I think of the social problems that we face here in America there is one issue that weighs heavy on my heart, it is also the reason that I decided to go into the Social Work profession. The social issue that I am talking about is child welfare within our Foster Care System. In 2005 The Economist (Nov. 26, 2005) reported, more than 500,000 American children were in the foster care, most of them being children of ethnic minorities. However, according to The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services recent studies have shown that number has declined, in 2013 402,378 children were living in foster care....   [tags: Foster care, Family, Foster Care Independence Act]

Better Essays
1692 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on How Do Children Enter The Foster Care System?

- How do children enter the foster care system. Usually children and adolescents enter foster care because the court or their family has decided the child needs a safe place to stay for a while (Kristen Humphrey, 2007). For example, sometimes parents have to work on using a different way of getting their kids to do what they want them to do; they might work on doing this without hurting their child (Kristen Humphrey, 2007). The removal of a child from a home occurs after a caseworker has gathered evidence and presented this evidence to a court along with the recommendations that the child be removed (DeGarmo, 2004)....   [tags: Family, Adoption, Foster care, Need]

Better Essays
1092 words (3.1 pages)

Psychological Stresses Of Kids On The Foster Care System Essay

- PSYCHOLOGICAL STRESSES OF KIDS IN THE FOSTER CARE SYSTEM Is the foster care system so bad. Why is it always portrayed in movies and books to be a horrible system. Foster care was designed to keep children safe, and help children get back to their parents. Sure, it can’t be all rainbows and glitter; but why is it that the first thing you might think of when someone mentions “foster care” is most likely, “Oh, that’s so sad”. Why is it, though, that every time it’s mentioned in movies or books that it is portrayed terribly....   [tags: Foster care, Child protection, Child abuse]

Better Essays
1067 words (3 pages)