Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman Essay

Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman Essay

Length: 983 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman.

The two stories we were asked to compare had one common themes which
were the building of fear and suspense throughout.

One clear difference between the stories was the function of fear in
the stories. In the 'The Red Room' the author does not only use fear
as a means of evolving the story but also places it at the centre of
the story. 'The Signalman' uses fear of the supernatural as a means of
making the story more believable as done in 'The Red Room'. Although
both stories are equally frightening, I feel that 'The Red Room'
contains much more suspense than 'The Signalman', I think that the
excess of suspense in 'The Red Room' is due to it having more
characters and actions.

Both stories are written as first person narrative, however, in 'The
Red Room' the horrific events happen to the narrator himself, while in
the 'The Signalman' the events are witnessed by the narrator while
they actually happen to the Signalman.

Both narrators seem to be well-educated, scientific men, which is
typical of victorian times. Neither of them seems willing to believe
in the supernatural. In 'The Red Room' the narrator does not believe
the warnings of the inhabitants of the house concerning the
supernatural content of the room, his over- confident belief in
science makes him aroogant and he is then proven wrong. As for 'The
Signalman' the narrator assumes that the Signalman is hallucinating,
due to his life of solitude and depressing routines, when he hears of
his visions of the spectre, he is similar to the narrator of 'The Red
Room' as he is also arrogantly confident that there is a scientific
explanation to his visions, and like him he is aslo proven wrong.

Using t...


... middle of paper ...


...suitable atmosphere for the supernatural visitations which
haunt the Signalman. This setting emphasises the solitude and
uneasiness, making it ideal for the mysterious and dreadful events
that follow. This helps prepare the reader for the catastrophe with
which the story ends.

A final similarity is how neither story ends with a proper scientific
explanation, therefore neither of the narrators can use science as
'the answer' because what has happened through out the two stories has
no scientific explanation. In my opinion, this leaves the readers with
an uneasy feeling about the supernatural and the chaos it may cause. A
fear of the supernatural lives deep inside some people, and not so
deep in others. But stories such as these can cause even the most
rational of people to wonder if there are things in the world which
can not and should not be explained.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman Essay

- Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman. The two stories we were asked to compare had one common themes which were the building of fear and suspense throughout. One clear difference between the stories was the function of fear in the stories. In the 'The Red Room' the author does not only use fear as a means of evolving the story but also places it at the centre of the story. 'The Signalman' uses fear of the supernatural as a means of making the story more believable as done in 'The Red Room'....   [tags: English Literature:]

Strong Essays
983 words (2.8 pages)

A Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman Essay

- A Comparison Between The Red Room and The Signalman These two stories, though different, have in common their writers intentions which is to keep the reader in suspense. We can see this in many places in the stories, and an example of this relates to the settings and surroundings throughout. The Victorians were very interested in Gothic Literature and this is shown especially in the ‘Red Room’, where Wells borrowed applications such as ghosts, castles and supernatural beings. Furthermore we can see that the settings have been adapted and chosen to suit the character of the story....   [tags: English Literature]

Strong Essays
976 words (2.8 pages)

A Comparison of The Signalman and The Red Room Essay

- A Comparison of The Signalman and The Red Room The Signalman and the Red Room are well known examples of nineteenth century ghost stories. Write a critical comparison of these two stories. What do you consider to be their strengths and which of the stories do you enjoy the most. Charles Dickens and H.G. Wells were both living during the Victorian era. The many radical changes in this era tainted their writing. Both Wells and Dickens were against the social situation at the time, this is evident in their writings....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
861 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on Comparison of The Red Room, The Signalman and The Ostler

- Comparison of The Red Room, The Signalman and The Ostler A gothic story is a type of romantic fiction that existed in English Literature in the last third of the 18th century and the first two decades of the 19th century, the setting for which was usually a ruined gothic castle of Abbey. The gothic novel or gothic romance emphasised mystery and horror and was filled with ghost haunting rooms, underground passages, and secret stairways. The stories I'm looking at are The Red Room, The Signalman and The Ostler....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
2383 words (6.8 pages)

Free College Essays - A Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman

- A Comparison of The Red Room and The Signalman I prefer ‘The Signalman’ story because I like stories with a mysterious ending to them or any mystery in the story itself. Just like in the beginning of ‘The Signalman’, the signalman thinks the narrator is a ghost and the narrator thinks that the signalman is a ghost too. It is like you don’t know who to trust anymore and what is right or wrong. Not like in ‘The Red Room’ when the three old people stayed together when the hero went out of the room, looking at him at an eerie way....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
1685 words (4.8 pages)

A Comparison of The Signalman by Charles Dickens and The Red Room by H.G. Wells

- A Comparison of The Signalman by Charles Dickens and The Red Room by H.G. Wells ‘The Signalman’, Charles Dickens and ‘The Red Room’, H.G. Wells are two gothic stories written in a nineteenth century style. In a century when life seemed to be explaining itself by the means of science, the notion of what we don’t know gives the story fear. The gothic style was very popular in this era and gothic stories were read as popular entertainment, the way gothic novels where written infringed fear into the hearts of mid-nineteenth century citizens....   [tags: Free Essays]

Free Essays
393 words (1.1 pages)

A Comparison between 'The Signalman' by Charles Dickens and 'The Red Room' by H.G. Wells

- A Comparison between 'The Signalman' by Charles Dickens and 'The Red Room' by H.G. Wells How do Dickens and Wells create a sinister and supernatural atmosphere in the opening of The Signalman and the Red Room. Dickens and Wells both create a sinister and supernatural atmosphere in the opening of The Signalman and The Red Room by using the Gothic features, such as the presence of grotesque characters, haunted rooms, superstition and previous deaths....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
2355 words (6.7 pages)

A Comparison of The Signalman by Charles Dickens, The Red Room by H.G. Wells and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

- A Comparison of The Signalman by Charles Dickens, The Red Room by H.G. Wells and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs Works Cited Missing All these stories were written in the Victorian era and ghost stories were popular. The reasons that ghost stories were popular was because people were learning to read and write, there was not much entertainment and people had a fascination of supernatural events....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1560 words (4.5 pages)

Comparing the Settings in The Signalman, The Adventure of the Speckled Band and The Red Room

- Comparing the Settings in The Signalman, The Adventure of the Speckled Band and The Red Room Three different stories, all of mystery trying to keep the reader gripped until the ending, each story keeps the reader in suspense by using what is called a 'Hooking Device', to keep the reader reading, the author needs to use a successful 'Hooking Device', and a brilliant question to keep you reading to find the mystery answer. The Red Room, I believe was not a solution, the main character treks off to find the rumoured ghosts, but unfortunately wasn't successful....   [tags: compare, contrast, comparison]

Free Essays
735 words (2.1 pages)

The Signalman and the Red Room are well known examples of nineteenth Essays

- The Signalman and the Red Room are well known examples of nineteenth century ghost stories. Write a critical comparison of these two stories. A critical comparison of "The Signalman" and "the Red Room" which are well known examples of nineteenth century ghost stories The Signalman" and "the Red Room" are well known examples of nineteenth century ghost stories. Write a critical comparison of these two stories. "The Signalman" by Charles Dickens and "The Red Room" by H.G.Wells are both well known examples of pre-twentieth century ghost stories and are based on the supernatural....   [tags: English Literature]

Strong Essays
704 words (2 pages)