Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

Length: 2677 words (7.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

In this essay I am going to explain the similarities and differences
between 'The withered arm' and 'The monkeys paw'. Both of these texts
were written before 1914 by two different people. Thomas Hardy wrote
'The withered arm' and W.W. Jacobs wrote 'A monkeys paw'.

The withered arm is a short story about a milkmaid who had an affair
with a high class farmer. When the farmer gets a new wife, the
milkmaid becomes jealous.

In a nightmare, the milkmaid who is called Rhoda Brooks sees the new
wife she had been obsessing over for the past few days in a horrific
apparition gloats over her new husband. In this nightmare Rhoda grabs
the apparition and feels her arm as if it were real as she throws the
spectre to the floor. The ghost is gone when she looks down. The
farmers' new wife, the next day, finds a new mark on her forearm in
the shape of a hand in the same place that Rhoda had grabbed the
apparition. Rhoda and Gertrude, the farmers' wife soon become good
friends as her arm becomes increasingly more serious. Eventually
Gertrude persuades Rhoda to get her to take her to a conjurer called
conjurer Trendle who is a local magic man. Eventually Rhoda takes her
and conjurer Trendle gives her advice but does not give a solution to
her trouble. They return home to the village.

A year later after Rhoda and her son had left the village Gertrud's
arm is becoming steadily worse and she is using all types of potions
and magick on it but nothing seems to make it any worse so she goes to
see conjurer Trendle for one last time. This time he gives her a
solution, she must touch the neck of a recently hanged man while the
body is...

... middle of paper ...

in the rural setting of A withered arm.

The time frame for each story is also different, the monkeys paw all
takes place over a few weeks where as a withered arm has the story
lasting for over a year. The time frame they are set in gives them a
big difference as it distinguishes one from the other easily.

I think that the story which is most striking out of these two has to
be The monkeys paw. This story is a better length to not take a while
to read and the plot seems better as a whole. Each character seems to
have obviously different personalities that they use all the time and
these are distinctly separate from the characters of a withered arm. I
like the way that the ending of this story is a cliff hanging, we are
not told what Herbert looks like after he was brought back to life we
are just told about the sigh of dismay from Mr Whites wife.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparison and Contrast Essay

- Some people think that if they could only change one aspect of their lives, it would be perfect. They do not realize that anything that is changed could come with unintended consequences. “The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs and “The Third Wish” by Joan Aiken both illustrate this theme. They demonstrate this by granting the main character three wishes, but with each wish that is granted, brings undesirable consequences. The main idea of this essay is to compare and contrast “The Monkey’s Paw” and “The Third Wish.” Although the “The Monkey’s Paw” and “The Third Wish” are both fantasies and have similar themes, they have different main characters, wishes, and resolutions....   [tags: The Monkey's Paw, The Third Wish]

Powerful Essays
755 words (2.2 pages)

Story of The Monkey Paw Book Essay

- Throughout “The Monkeys Paw” by W.W Jacobs he uses suspense in numerous ways to draw the reader to the story. One of his many suspenseful tactics was the simple fact that the monkeys paw contained three wishes. I do not think I could live in this period the weather was cold and desert roads seems kind of spooky. It reminds me of a dark and gloomy place of sadness. I think that W.W Jacobs’s point of view is his own, and his stories are a great way to see life in another way. In my own words, this story could be told around a campfire a story you could teach to others generations....   [tags: monkey paw, w jacobs, wish]

Powerful Essays
850 words (2.4 pages)

Tragic Character Flaws in The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde and The Monkey’s Paw

- In the Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, the main character Dr. Henry Jekyll is a respectable doctor who experiments to separate his good and evil sides from each other. Dr. Jekyll eventually runs out of the contaminated potion and his evil side takes over. In The Monkey’s Paw the White family takes possession of a monkey’s paw that had a spell put on it granting three men three wishes. After not knowing what to wish for and the urging of his wife and son, Mr. White makes his wishes and realizes there are consequences for his choices....   [tags: The Monkey’s Paw Essays]

Powerful Essays
2380 words (6.8 pages)

A Sense of Foreboding in 'The Monkey's Paw' Essay

- How Does W.W. Jacobs Create a Sense of Foreboding in ‘The Monkey’s Paw’. From the outset, it is clear that ‘The Monkey’s Paw’ by W.W. Jacobs is driven by an increasing sense of foreboding. Firstly, the setting of the story takes place in a very isolated and lonely place, far away from civilisation in a deserted area. This makes it a bit scary and starts to introduce tension for the reader in the story. Right from the start of the story W.W., Jacobs creates a very foreboding scene. He starts the story with pathetic fallacy, ‘the night was cold and wet’....   [tags: Literary Review]

Powerful Essays
908 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about The Theme of Greed in "The Monkey's Paw"

- Greed is a sin of excess that every single human being has at least a little bit of. When someone has the opportunity to get as much of something as they possibly can, they will go to great lengths to get everything out of it. In the story “The Monkey’s Paw,” by W. W. Jacobs, the White family experiences a big test of greed, and they even tamper with their fate to get it. Before the Whites even knew about the paw, they were living a normal, but decent, lifestyle that got them by day-to-day without any troubles....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Powerful Essays
2343 words (6.7 pages)

Essay about The Monkey's Paw and The Red Room

- The Monkey's Paw and The Red Room During the time of the 19th century that "The Monkey's Paw" and "The Red Room" were written, many unusual events occurred and which could not be answered or explained because science and human minds had not developed enough to answer questions or prove any unusual events that occurred. The society would try to come up with answers and explanations to the paranormal events that occurred. In some cases, they were able to come up with answers, which in our time we would think are incorrect and idiotic because we all ready know the answers to a lot of them....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
4209 words (12 pages)

The Effectiveness of The Monkey's Paw Essay

- The Effectiveness of The Monkey's Paw The Monkey's Paw was written in the turn of the century which was the time of industrial revolution. Great industries and cities were building up all across the country but not everyone was involved in this change. Older and less educated people were getting left behind by the new technologies and education. This story reflects these changes in the society and shows us how an innocent world could be destroyed by the power of greed. The Monkey's paw would have been this effective of a story in its time because I think it had everything that needs to be in a horror story of anytime and I am going to show that in my essay....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
3013 words (8.6 pages)

Comparing The Monkey's Paw and The Signalman Essay

- Comparing The Monkey's Paw and The Signalman In these two short stories both authors write gothic tale stories. Both authors use gothic tale features e.g they use darkness, isolation and use of senses. Both authors’ u similar methods to create tension e.g. they both use repetition and short sentences. They both use their senses e.g. in the monkeys paw they use their sense of hearing and feeling, for example they hear the door knocking and use a lot of sight through Mr.White cant see where the monkeys paw is and he use his sense of feeling to try and find it on the floor....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1421 words (4.1 pages)

Tension and Suspense in Monkey's Paw Essay

- Tension and Suspense in Monkey's Paw The writer is able to create tension and suspense through various ways. In the opening sentence of the story we are given a brief description of the surrounding area. In gothic stories, they are usually set in a remote and isolated area, as in the ‘Monkey’s Paw’ it is set in a remote village were there is only 2 houses inhabited. ‘Without, the night was cold and wet’ sets the scene of the story. A gloomy background has been given to set the atmosphere....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
557 words (1.6 pages)

The Monkey's Paw: Time Structure Essay

- "The Monkey's Paw" is a short story which moves around the edges of a ghost story and the uncanny. In general terms, the narration immerses the reader into a frightening atmosphere in which the reader can realise that there are certain elements that make the reading something more than a spooky tale; for example the way time is treated in the structure of the story. It is peculiar the way W.W. Jacobs manages to create a rather concrete story by making the reader fill so many gaps. In our opinion, that is due to the fact that there is a complete focus on the development of the story since the arrival of the monkey's paw, and that there are several omissions of facts in the beginning and in th...   [tags: Book Reviews]

Powerful Essays
452 words (1.3 pages)