What Role Should The Government Play in Gun Control? Essay

What Role Should The Government Play in Gun Control? Essay

Length: 1801 words (5.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

What Role Should The Government Play in Gun Control?

A well regulated Militia,
being necessary to the security of a free State,
the right of the people to keep and bear Arms,
shall not be infringed.

     Gun control is a real issue with Americans today. Many people have different opinions about how to handle our growing dilemma concerning guns. There are those who believe we should ban guns altogether and those who believe we should not ban or restrict the people's right to own guns at all. Both sides have valid arguments, but neither side seems to know how to compromise because of their very different opinions. I personally believe guns should be banned. However, those against gun control have very good arguments.
     The Second Amendment was written because of the colonists' fear of an all-powerful central government taking over, but there are many interpretations of how the Second Amendment reads. The court has never found the Second Amendment to clash with the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process clause which states that, "No state shall...deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law" (McClenaghan 522). This gave each state the right to set up their own rules and regulations, which I believe, is one reason why we have the problems that we do.
     There have been four major cases heard by the Supreme Court which found that the fire-arm control laws are constitutional; United States v. Cruikshank (1986), Presser v. Illinois (1886), Miller v. Texas (1894), and the United States v. Miller (1939) (Strahinich 41). United States v. Miller was the most important. It supported a section of the National Firearms Act of 1934, basically stating that it is a crime to ship sawed off shotguns, machine guns, or silencers across state lines unless registered with the Treasury Department (McClenaghan 522).
     The United States already has more than twenty thousand gun laws, but they do not seem to be making an impact. The first American gun control laws were written before the Revolutionary War. The most effective and more recent laws have been the Gun Control Act of 1986 and the Brady Law. The Gun Control Act of 1986 has a lot of impact on our rights concerning firearms today. It requires federal licensing and inspection of dealers with new and stricter guidelines. It restricted the sale of ammunition and firearms betwe...


... middle of paper ...


...on of law enforcement officials and military. We might not be able to stop all of this gun violence but at least we can close loopholes that control the sale and distribution of guns in America. Next to automobiles, guns are the second most deadly consumer product on the market. There are over two hundred million guns in circulation today, compared to the mere fifty four million in 1950 (Roleff 142).


Works Cited

Dolan, Edward, Margaret Scariano. Guns in the United States. New York, New York: Moffa Press, Incorporated, 1994. pp.. 29-30, 55.

Lott, J.R. More Guns Less Crime. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press,      1998. pp.. 1-2.

McClenaghan, William. American Government. Needham, Massachusetts:      Prentice Hall, 1993. pp.. 489, 522.

Netzley, P.D. Issues in Crime. Sandiego, California: Lucent Books Inc., 2000. pp.. 32

Roleff, T.L. ed. Gun Control, Opposing Viewpoints. Sandiego, California:      Greenhaven Press Inc., 1997. pp.. 22-23, 25, 45, 47, 65-67, 76, 85, 117, 142.

Strahinich, Helen. Guns in America. United States: Walker Publishing Company,      1992. pp.. 41, 48, 51.

http://www.alphadogweb.com/firearms/gun_control_is_a_nice_phrase.htm

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Rights Of Gun Control Essay

- ... It is very interesting how the branches of our government are so different when looking at a very debatable subject like gun control. There is a long history of guns in our country, whether it be supporting or opposing them. The 2nd Amendment which was passed in 1791 has been the glue to keeping gun rights intact. It reads, “A well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a Free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed”. The 2nd Amendment helped gun control activists to create a collective rights theory, that citizens don’t have an individual right to possess guns, and that local, state, and federal legislative bodies possess the authorit...   [tags: Gun politics in the United States, Firearm]

Powerful Essays
1658 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Gun Control Is A Good Thing

- ... Groups against gun control, the most important being the NRA (National Rifle Association), are fearful that harsh gun control is the first step in outlawing guns. James Wilson, a professor and an author of several crime books, states that “How could or would we ever get rid of the hundreds of millions of guns that are already in the US?” (Wilson). Also he takes the stance that banning guns is pointless and that everybody already has one, “The genie is out of the bottle.” (Wilson). Though the government is trying to help, they aren 't working out any of the problems; they are just making it more difficult for the average citizen to obtain a gun for their own safety and pleasure....   [tags: Firearm, Gun politics, Handgun, Gun]

Powerful Essays
1453 words (4.2 pages)

Gun Control Should Be Legal Essay

- ... Placing individuals in a position where they’re uncomfortable pushes them to shoot first and asks questions later. Carrying a gun would make it too easy settle an argument with violence. Every single life lost due to gun violence can cause a ripple effect throughout communities. Guns can stop a person’s life in seconds and leave families damaged for a lifetime. Gun fanatics should also have to report to each state the numbers of weapons (guns), classes of weapons, and where firearms are stored as well....   [tags: Firearm, Gun politics, United States]

Powerful Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Gun Control Around The World

- ... The normal citizen shouldn’t even have a weapon if it isn’t needed, but if they feel like they need it then they should be required to have a permit for it, which requires a course with a test at the end to pass the class. The illegal hunting should be stopped overall, if we keep letting people kill animals they are all going to become extinct and animals play a huge role in our environment. Taking away the second amendment is evidence of the solution of gun control. More handguns in the world equals more crimes, owning a handgun increases a persons risk of being killed, keeping guns out of the hand of criminals or ex criminals prevents crime....   [tags: Firearm, Gun politics in the United States]

Powerful Essays
1190 words (3.4 pages)

Why Is Anti Gun-Control Necessary? Essay

- The banning of firearms in America is an illegal act, and degrades the values this country was founded on. They not only play a vital role in many people's lives, but are useful tools, fun to use, and can protect people from harm. Our founding fathers wanted us to have them to protect ourselves from the government, and would be disgusted at our government's current abuse, and overall disregard of the constitution of the United States. A lot of people argue that guns kill people; this is untrue. Guns in the hands of a negligent person have potential to kill people, just as anything else....   [tags: Bear Arms, Gun Control, Argument]

Powerful Essays
712 words (2 pages)

The Gun Control Debate in America Essay

- GUN CONTROL DEBATE IN AMERICA Gun control has become a very hot topic of contention in America today. What seems to echo here are two words: “guns” and “crime”, in a sense that are these words mutually exclusive to each other. Does the use of guns ultimately lead to crime. On the flip side, have the laws in America restricting firearm use been effective enough to protect the lives of the citizens. These are some of the questions that strike the hearts of many when the gun control debate music is played....   [tags: guns, crime, laws, firearms, weapons]

Powerful Essays
1171 words (3.3 pages)

Media and Gun Control Essay

- Gun Control Gun control has always been a fairly important matter in American society, yet has be-come a much larger concern within the past few years. Our founding fathers felt gun control was an imperative enough issue to create the second amendment. As society has shifted from the freedom of English rule to the diverse, technologically advanced nation it is today, new situa-tions have greatly influenced public opinion to bring about adjustments to current policies. The issue overwhelming America is whether or not gun control will positively affect the safety of citizens as a whole....   [tags: stricker laws, right to bear arms]

Powerful Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Gun Control and Regulation Essay

- Gun Control and Regulation The idea of gun control and regulation is becoming more and more popular throughout the U.S., although it may still bring up resistance among some people. Guns are sort of a foundation of American culture. This country's freedom was won over bloody and "heroic" wars with guns. Guns are portrayed throughout television, movies, and video games. Guns are a popular symbol of power, control, authority, dominance, and can be associated with security and defense....   [tags: Second Amendment The Right To Bear Arms]

Powerful Essays
1729 words (4.9 pages)

Informative Essay: The Debate Over Gun Control

- Crime and guns. The two seem to go hand in hand with one another. But are the two really associated. Do guns necessarily lead to crime. And if so do laws placing restrictions on firearm ownership and use stop the crime or protect the citizens. These are the questions many citizens and lawmakers are asking themselves when setting about to create gun control laws. The debate over gun control, however, is nothing new. In 1924, Presidential Candidate, Robert La Follete said, “our choice is not merely to support or oppose gun control but to decide who can own which guns under what conditions.” Clearly this debate still goes on today and is the very reason for the formation of gun control laws....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays]

Free Essays
2111 words (6 pages)

Essay Settling for Half in Arthur Miller's Play a View From the Bridge

- Settling for Half in Arthur Miller's Play a View From the Bridge In this essay I will look at the idea of settling for half. In the play, A View From The Bridge, the idea of settling for half is used many times. This idea makes the play more tragic especially when a certain character doesn't settle for half. To understand what settling for half is we will have to establish what it means. Settling for half is a sort of compromise. Most people would rather settle half than get into trouble like the character Eddie Carbone should have done so therefore people see settling for half as a good thing....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)