Essay on Thomas More: Preserving Self in Society in A Man for All Seasons

Essay on Thomas More: Preserving Self in Society in A Man for All Seasons

Length: 1076 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

     Some might say he’s a hypocrite. Others may adopt a Christian perspective to his moral struggle. Robert Bolt, however, would describe him as a man who exemplified an “adamantine sense of his own self” (Bolt xii). A Man for All Seasons, although non-theological in its scope, nevertheless presents a dramatic hero of no small interest to the contemporary Christian, but whose significance does not end there. Sir Thomas More, a well-known martyr and inspiration to those “moral” among us, is a man of inexorable integrity, whose steadfast adherence to his religious and ethical beliefs led to his tragic demise, and to the expanding popularity of his character. More’s struggle presents a morally blatant — and historical — example of man’s struggle to assert his spiritual self in a secular society.
     Perhaps a brief history of More’s struggle is needed. Sixteenth century England: Henry VIII’s brother, Arthur, dies. Arthur was to be king and had already married Catherine of Aragon. A husband must be provided, so at the prodding of the Spanish and English monarchies, the Pope threw out the doctrine that stated a man may not marry his brother’s wife and Henry and Catherine wed. They rule happily — for a while — until Henry falls in love with Anne Boleyn, finds out Catherine cannot bear him any sons, and desires to divorce her. The Catholic Church does not support his requests, and Henry attempts to persuade them otherwise, claiming the marriage should be annulled based on its original religious illegality. The Church and More do not buy this claim, considering Henry caused the problem in the first place. More was Henry’s Lord Chancellor and resigned the position when Henry split with the Church in 1531. In 1534, Parliament passed a bill requiring all subjects to take an oath (Oath of Supremacy) acknowledging the supremacy of England’s king over all foreign sovereigns — including the Pope. More refused, was imprisoned, and then executed in 1535. The play presents his dilemma to stay true to his friends, country, and God.
     In his preface, Bolt addresses the apparent contradiction between More’s realism and his continuing resort to legal and moral loopholes. He poses questions of why, if More believes so strongly that the divorce shouldn’t take place, does he hope to find a “way out” in...


... middle of paper ...


...not feel a connection to an “immortal soul, which [they] regard as absolutely inviolable” (xiv). Thus, that is why he portrays More as a “hero of selfhood” — a testament to his ability to stay true to himself (e.g. his immortal being).
     More placed a large amount of faith in a “patterned and orderly” society and the laws that governed it. More’s trust in the law was his trust in society, thus Cromwell’s shattering of “the forms of law by an unconcealed act of perjury” showed the fragility of that shelter More had created for himself. No doubt, More was given the opportunity to slide back into his safe zone of law and order. However, he remained resolute and continued with the decision he had made while under the comfort of that “shelter.” This is in stark contrast to other characters in the play, namely Will Roper, who would shift faiths based on high-minded ideals, each time convinced of his own righteousness. Bolt seems to imply, through his “tragic” hero, that one cannot comprehend all that is good and moral in the world — much less condense it into something “orderly” and “ideal” — and thus, should concentrate on oneself and one’s place in society.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Robert Bolt's A Man For All Seasons Essay

- Robert Bolt's "A Man For All Seasons" In the play, written by Robert Bolt, 'A man for all seasons' the Common Man is a very important character and also a very important part of the play, not in the plot but in the way the play has been presented, he is both a narrator and a role player who makes the play more interesting and separates it from reality. The Common Man also introduces some of the ideas from Bertolt Brecht's work. The idea of the Common Man is a rare and rather unusual one. Robert Bolt used him intentionally to be like no other character in his play....   [tags: Robert Bolt Man Seasons Essays]

Strong Essays
1056 words (3 pages)

Robert Bolt’s A Man for All Seasons Essay

- Robert Bolt’s A Man for All Seasons Robert Bolt’s A Man for All Seasons is a provoking historical drama. Thomas More, who is considered to be an honest man, is entangled in the politics of the day and having to decide between his own welfare and his personal conscience. Thomas is an absolute saint of the church, but now he had to choose between two different kinds of loyalty. The theme seems to be recurring, regardless of the age or setting. In fact, it is the Common Man who reminds the audience "The 16th century is the century of the common man....   [tags: Man All Seasons Bolt]

Free Essays
1345 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Values and Morals in A Man For All Seasons by Robert Bolt

- Values and Morals in A Man For All Seasons by Robert Bolt In the play A Man For All Seasons by Robert Bolt the audience learns about the extraordinary life of Sir Thomas More. Sir Thomas is faced with a moral dilemma that will determine the outcome of his life. More, chancellor of England , and a strong Christian believer is forced to choose between his close friend, King Henry VIII, and the supreme lord his God. More is a man of moral integrity because he refuses to submit to external pressures to sign the oath condoning the Act of Supremacy....   [tags: A Man For All Seasons Robert Bolt]

Strong Essays
545 words (1.6 pages)

A Man For All Seasons Essay

- English Essay Essay Question: Is it possible to stay true to oneself in a world of corruption. The literary piece A Man for All Seasons, the infamous painting Death of Socrates, and a Oscar award winning film Schindler’s List have the same underlying theme of staying true to oneself in a world of corruption. Robert Bolt criticizes society by commenting on the corruption in the political and religious systems, which are supposed to be tools to provide justice for all individuals. Similar to Thomas More, Socrates is accused by Athenian government for corrupting the youth and is sentenced to death....   [tags: Nazi Germany, The Holocaust, Political corruption]

Strong Essays
2272 words (6.5 pages)

Play: A Man for All Seasons, by Robert Bolt Essay

- Beliefs are a core aspect of life, but a true test of one’s principles is how far one is willing to go to defend and preserve those beliefs. In A Man for All Seasons, Sir Thomas More exemplifies just how strong his ethics are. A Man for All Seasons is a historical play, written in 1960 by Robert Bolt, which recounts the events of the 16th century surrounding Sir Thomas More, leading up to his death. In A Man for All Seasons, Sir Thomas More becomes Lord Chancellor of England during the time that King Henry VIII divorced his wife, remarried, and declared himself head of the Church of England by the Oath of Supremacy....   [tags: Character Analysis, Ethics, Virtue ]

Strong Essays
1051 words (3 pages)

Essay on Self-Determination in Arab Society

- Self-Determination in Arab Society Since World War Two, much of the developing world has been in transition. One such idea that saw a re-birth was that of self-determination-- be it on the national level or on the personal level. Self-determination on a national level means the independence of a country; on a personal level, it is the determination of one own fate. This can be seen in various ways with our five women characters, Maha, Um Saad, Nadia, Yusra and Suad. In the forward of Daughters of Abraham, Karen Armstrong notes that Islam is "adamantly opposed to the subjection of one human being by another," "insist that men and women were created by God image" and "both sexes have equal...   [tags: Arabic Culture Cultural Essays]

Free Essays
5933 words (17 pages)

Television And Its Impact On American Society Essay

- Television has played and continues to play a huge role in American society, from the entertainment influence to the influence of crime and the repercussions of criminal activity. A large portion of Americans rely on television media for information about public policy, criminology, and the criminal justice process. Fortunately and unfortunately public opinion is established by what the public views on television whether factual or fictional; therefore making what is presented on television important....   [tags: Criminal justice, Police, Crime, Law]

Strong Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

Sir Thomas More's A Man For All Seasons Essays

- Sir Thomas More's "A Man For All Seasons" A Man For All Seasons was written about Sir Thomas More and his relationship with the more powerful members of the country in the sixteenth century. It is a recreation of history, dramatised to enhance the experience. Written in the 1960's in a world coming out of global depression, a time of peace, love and drugs, it was a thorn amongst the rose coloured glasses. When people were used to a more relaxed establishment, with much more equality than the decades leading up to it, A Man For All Seasons confronted an immoral, strict and spineless monarch that was Henry VIII....   [tags: Sir Thomas More Man All Seasons Essays]

Free Essays
5332 words (15.2 pages)

Essay about A Man for All Seasons: More’s Moral Stature

- A Man for All Seasons:  More’s Moral Stature                        In some literature, a character’s moral stature plays an important role.  In the play, A Man for All Seasons, by Robert Bolt, no other character comes close to More’s moral reputation.  Thomas Cromwell and Richard Rich do not compare to More’s moral stature because both Rich and Cromwell lie, while Rich accepts bribes and Cromwell does anything King Henry VIII tells him to no matter what it is, and they will do whatever it takes to get what they want.  More on the other hand, would not lie no matter what the consequences would be, he would not accept a bribe under any circumstance and he would never go against his morals...   [tags: Man for All Seasons Essays]

Strong Essays
1956 words (5.6 pages)

Essay about T.s. Eliot And Society

- Modernism was the time period between 1865 and 1950 that consisted of a change in the perspectives of how Americans examined themselves and their role in society. Many things occurred during these eighty five years that accounted for a great social change. Among these things were World War I, the Civil Rights Movement, prohibition, women suffrage, and the Great Depression. Particularly after World War I and during women’s suffrage, society’s standpoint on certain issues changed dramatically. After World War I, people’s attitudes swung with high expectations for themselves but were soon lowered after the economy’s fall....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Strong Essays
1467 words (4.2 pages)