Grigory Pechorin: The Superfluous Man Essay

Grigory Pechorin: The Superfluous Man Essay

Length: 1016 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Mikhail Lermontov's protagonist, Grigory Pechorin, belongs to that group of literary characters known individually as the 'superfluous man.'; Generally an intelligent, educated individual, the superfluous man would appear to be one who has been either unjustly treated or outcast by society in general. The superfluous man attempts to find a place for himself in the world, but perhaps due to the combination of his talents, upbringing, personality and intelligence, continually finds himself on the outs with his peers.
     If the above definition is accepted as valid, then Pechorin might appear to be the consummate superfluous man. From the outpouring of his tale of woe to Princess Mary, we may come to the conclusion that Pechorin has no concept of cause and effect, at least not as it applies to himself as the cause. Moreover, it becomes fairly apparent that he is of the belief that he is a victim of the world, which is more interesting, as one considers the culture of victimization that has become popular in recent years. Who has not heard the excuse, 'I did it because my (parents/state representative/dog) (harassed/bit/abused) me when I was a child.'; In my opinion, the growing interest in pop psychology and the related fields of social psychology and child psychology have greatly contributed to the decay of moral rectitude and the concept of taking responsibility for one's own actions.
     The translator attributes Pechorin's capriciousness to the lack of employment for his gifts. I do not agree with that assessment, as it has been my experience that only those who have made up their minds to lack direction will be unable to find an activity that occupies their mind and appeals to them. One possible pursuit would be some form of art. Skill matters little, if the activity is pleasing. Cultural appreciation, gastronomical excess, or sexual exercise would all be suitable endeavors. We see that Pechorin certainly takes pleasure in the company of women, though in his own words, 'I must confess I don't really like strong-willed women,'; (111), the female sex does not hold an unbounded appeal for him. But his relationship with Vera, and his reaction to Maxim Maximych's inquiry about Bela clearly show that he is capable of feeling some emotion for others, although he refuses to expressing it. This is entirely Pech...


... middle of paper ...


...given all it needs to survive and learn intellectually, but no moral boundaries, will come to be greatly like a sociopathic personality. They will most likely be incapable of relating to others, save as far as they are themselves effected. They will not display anything near the level of enlightened self-interest that enables society. For all intents and purposes, they will be a sociopath, and due to the initial lack of guidance, they will be at best highly resistant to change, and at worst, totally irredeemable.
     Pechorin is either a coward, in which case he should be pitied, if not despised for his unwillingness to change, or he is a sociopath, in which case he should be exterminated, without a spark of guilt or pity, for the benefit of society. He clearly does not fall into the sociopathic category, as his displays of emotion – faint though they are – prove. So he is a coward, unwilling to come to terms with himself.
     Pechorin is not merely the superfluous man of the 19th century, but rather a mirror held up for all of humanity. His insensitivity, fear, and self-loathing reflect us still to this day.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The literary Trope of a Superfluous Man in Russian Literature and Culture

- ... Born to an ancient and noble Russian family, Pushkin plays his part expertly. “The sly baseness, fit to throttle, of entertaining the half-dead: one smoothes the pillows down in bed, and glumly serves the medicine bottle, and sighs, and asks oneself all through: ‘When will the devil come for you?’” (Pushkin, I.I) The cyncism in Onegin reflects the unsatified and morbid curiosity of those of the well educated, which in Russian culture is a natural reaction as the cynical realism of life. From early on Pushkin studies at the Lycee where he excels at French, drawing, fencing and Russian, following the model of the superfluous man, Pushkin is a talented individual with no will to use such ta...   [tags: society, aristocrat, trope]

Strong Essays
863 words (2.5 pages)

A Hero of Our Time - Gregoriy Pechorin is No Hero Essay examples

- A Hero of Our Time  - Gregoriy Pechorin is No Hero Is Pechorin, the protagonist of Mikhail Lermontov's novella A Hero of Our Time an honorable man. Much of Pechorin's behavior proves him to be a cruel and insensitive man, who seems to bring only havoc and destruction to a situation. He is often aggravating, self-serving and insensitive to others. However in other instances, Pechorin proves himself to be the least reprehensible character. He shows himself to be a man with great self knowledge and knowledge of human behavior....   [tags: Hero of Our Time Essays]

Strong Essays
2897 words (8.3 pages)

Comparison Of Pechorin And Bazarov ' Fathers And Children ' A Very Intelligent Novel Written By Ivan Turgenev

- The comparison between Pechorin and Bazarov Fathers and Children, a very intelligent novel written by Ivan Turgenev, presents the conflicts between the generations. Generation gap is common in our daily life, for different growing up environment generates distinctive cognitions. However, when Turgenev adds in the specific social background of the times, when old romantic idealists meet with a young nihilist, the conflict sublimates and becomes more intense. Among all of the characters in the story, Bazarov is absolutely the one who is the most attractive and the most controversial....   [tags: Love, Interpersonal relationship, Ivan Turgenev]

Strong Essays
977 words (2.8 pages)

Perfection in Pope’s An Essay on Man

- Alexander Pope envisioned a universe perfect by definition. Every facet of this universe is designed solely for its place in the hierarchy of existence, and is in fact perfect for its particular station. This idea of perfection in completeness is encompassed in the famous concluding words of the first epistle of Pope’s An Essay on Man: “Whatever IS, is RIGHT.” This aphorism, however, belies the effort Pope took to solidify his assertion. In order to substantiate his idea of a perfectly structured universe, Pope delineates—in extremely structured and formal heroic verse—an argument positing the failure of human reason, fettered as it is by ignorance and pride, in obtaining a proper idea of ma...   [tags: An Essay on Man]

Strong Essays
1824 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about Russian Revolution Leaders: Grigori Rasputin

- ... (“Grigory Rasputin”) In Rasputin’s early days he had very little education, Rasputin left school at the age of eight and was unable to read and write. Grigori Rasputin found himself at the Verkhoturye Monastery. Rasputin was never a monk, Rasputin attended Verkhoturye Monastery, but left and returned home by the age of nineteen and never completed the training in time. Rasputin was known as “The Monk” and certainly “The Mad Monk” even though Rasputin never became a monk. Rasputin went to Verkhoturye to become a “strannik” which is a pilgrim or wonderer....   [tags: t sar, russia, siberia, holy man]

Strong Essays
829 words (2.4 pages)

A Man Should Not Cry Essay

- Introduction A man should not cry; a woman should want to be a mother. Men should strive to be smart and rich; women should strive to be beautiful. These are examples of gender roles present in today’s society. Gender roles are defined as set behavioral guidelines within which members of their respective gender are supposed to act. They are not written down per say, but they are engrained in the culture as a whole. This essay will focus specifically on gender roles as they are present in American society....   [tags: Gender role, Gender, Transgender, Man]

Strong Essays
1567 words (4.5 pages)

The Man Who Was Almost A Man Essay

- In “The Man Who Was Almost a Man”, the search of power and the coming of age is the key theme in the story because the main character Dave puts himself in a situation where he feels that’s he can’t stand up to the wrongs that he has done. Richard Wright father an uneducated farm worker left home when he was six, so he was raised without a father. Growing up he had a tough childhood due to his mother illness. He and his brother later moved to Mississippi where he was heavily influenced by his grandmother, therefore he displays the coming of age without a father figure in his poem “The Man Who was almost a Man”....   [tags: Man, Boy, Mother, Family]

Strong Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Man Who Was Almost A Man

- Throughout the short story “The Man Who Was Almost a Man”, Dave struggled to find his manhood, but it seems as that he had the wrong idea of what it took to actually become a man because of his poor decisions. Many people have heard that having a gun makes you a man, so Dave believes that purchasing a gun would help him become one. The gun represents power, masculinity, independence, and respect, which are all things that Dave wants. The idea of owning a gun is David’s outlet, a way to quickly become more powerful and manly....   [tags: Boy, Man, Short story, Responsibility]

Strong Essays
1777 words (5.1 pages)

The Man Who Was Almost A Man Essay

- Written by Richard Wright, The Man Who Was Almost a Man takes places in the 1960s. The text shows the economic differences between two social classes. The story revolves around Dave Saunders, a seventeen-year-old teenager, who wants the world, or in this case, the base, to recognize his manhood. Under Marxist lens of interpretation, the readers can see the consequences of commodity fetishism, and the effects of alienation. The economic base of The Man Who Was Almost a Man is a farming community where both the farm owner and the farm workers are dependent of each other....   [tags: Social class, Marxism, Man, Bourgeoisie]

Strong Essays
1010 words (2.9 pages)

The Man Who Was Almost A Man by Richard Wright Essay

- "The Man Who Was Almost A Man" by Richard Wright In life, there are many decisions that everyone must make. And with decision-making comes consequences, some that we are ready for , and some that we may not be ready for. The author of ' The Man Who Was Almost a Man,' Richard Wright, portrays a young man who wants to be a man, but shows that he is clearly unprepared for manhood and the consequences that come with that responsibility. Through decision making based on self interest, wanting to gain respect from his family, and wanting to prove his dignity, Richard Wright brings forth the main character, Dave, a seventeen year old boy, whose actions show that he is only 'almost a man.'    ...   [tags: The Man Who Was Almost A Man]

Strong Essays
601 words (1.7 pages)