The Franciscan Order; A Victim of its own Success Essay

The Franciscan Order; A Victim of its own Success Essay

Length: 3001 words (8.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Franciscan movement was a religious order that arose out of one man’s ideologies and beliefs. St. Francis of Assisi’s ideals of absolute poverty, obedience, humility, and simplicity were uncomplicated and basic, but during his life and even shortly after his death these ideologies were gradually shifting and causing a great amount of debate. The immense size of the Franciscan Order combined with the mass amount of popularity that the Order gained made changes in the ideology and objectives of Francis’ messages and teaching almost an inevitable necessity. Some could argue that in many ways the Franciscan Order’s original ideologies were a victim of the movement’s success. This is evident in the main rules of the Order, what the rules were initially like during the life of Francis, and what they became after his death.
     Saint Francis of Assisi was born in 1182 into a wealth family. His father was Peter Bernardone, a wealthy cloth merchant. Throughout Francis’ childhood he experienced many of the physical pleasures in life; however, gradually he began to have visions from the divine.
The first vision appeared when he was fighting with knights against Assisi’s enemies, the second during a night of merriment and celebration, and a third when he was praying at the ruined Church of San Damiano. During the latter vision, Francis heard a voice coming from the crucifix telling him to rebuild the Church. Francis sold many of his father’s assets and gave the money to San Damiano, but his father was unimpressed. Francis publicly denounced his father, striping naked and throwing his clothes at his father, saying that his only father from that point on was the divine.
For a time Francis wandered unsure of what to do, until he had his fourth divine vision on February 28, 1206. He realized that his true mission in life was the imitation of the life of Christ. Francis took to begging, and wandering from town to town, caring for those less fortunate than himself, and taking only what was necessary for his survival. After a time, Francis accumulated a small number of followers and soon realized that some rules would have to be formulated to govern his order. On April 6th 1209 the order began when Francis said, “He that will come after me, let him deny himself…This, my brothers, is our life and rule and that of all those who shall wish to join...


... middle of paper ...


... and also made the Order increasingly difficult to govern. This difficulty in governance often forced the Order to turn to the Pope for guidance, thus creating a dangerous reliance on the Pope and making the order submissive to a potentially oppressive and dogmatic power. Likewise, the popularity of the movement contributed to its size. The more popular the Order was the more people joined it. The popularity also contributed to the relaxing of the standards of poverty, humility and simplicity. Money and gifts were given to the Order, jobs with a degree of power and prestige were offered to members of the Order by the Pope, and many other circumstances. The Order itself had become a worldly institution rather than a wandering group of poor friars as Francis had intended. With such undermining of the original ideals and objectives of St. Francis, a split in the Order seems almost inevitable.

















Final Word Count: 2971     
Sources/ Works Cited
Burr, D. Olivi and Franciscan Poverty: The Usus Pauper Controversy. Philadelphia; University of Pennsylvania Press, 1989.

Moorman, J. A History of the Franciscan Order. UK; Oxford University Press, 1968.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

IF - a victim of its own success Essays

- IF it is true that familiarity breeds contempt, it would explain the contradictions that surround Rudyard Kipling's famous poem If-. On the one hand it is one of the most popular and best-known poems in the English language. On the other this enormous popularity has done it a disservice. For instance, despite appearing in many anthologies of verse, If- is excluded from The New Oxford Book of English Verse. Instead, editor Helen Gardner selects Kipling's Mandalay, Danny Deever, Cities and Thrones and Powers, The Way through the Woods, and the imperialistic Recessional....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
721 words (2.1 pages)

Success And Success : The Definition Of Success Essays

- Success can be distinguished in various ways based on an individual’s interpretation and experience. As Winston Churchill famously stated, "Success is walking from failure to failure with no loss of enthusiasm." The interpretation of success is not entirely achieving or overcoming a great feat, but it is also about the adjustments that you experience in order to reach such a stage. To obtain success, you must first understand what is crucial and significant in your life, and to seek for stability and new experiences while within the pursuit of personal growth....   [tags: Success, Mind, Spinal cord injury, Failure]

Powerful Essays
1070 words (3.1 pages)

Is It A Victim Of A Crime? Essay

- There are many ways, where you can become a victim of a crime. In every crime, there is a victim. There is no required age limit in becoming a victim of a crime, from infant to elderly you can become a victim of any crime. In some instances you can be a victim of fraud, sexual abuse, mental and physical abuse. Victim advocates are and can be based on the type of crime victims (National Organization for Victim Assistance, 2015). But given in your time of need the government has giving us the resources of having victim advocates (U.S....   [tags: Police, Victim, Crime, Criminology]

Powerful Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

Crime Victimization And Victim Services Program Essay

- In this article, it discusses about how criminal victimization is a cause of the alleviation of psychological trauma in victims and discusses the main connections through their studies; but in the beginning paragraph, they discuss more about the programs for victims which is somehow redundant in this study since the reader may already know. From the article, there are various constructs they are discussing which are crime victimization, victim service programs, psychological functioning skills and support work but the main constructs they are trying to explain is crime victimization and victim services program....   [tags: Victim, Abuse, Bullying, The Victim]

Powerful Essays
1348 words (3.9 pages)

The Four Topics Method of Analysis: A Pregnant Accident Victim Essay

- The Four Topics Method of Analysis is a tool developed by clinical ethicists used to examine clinical encounters. This method provides a consistent, organized framework for gathering information regarding the encounter in order to perform analysis. The method is organized into four parts: Medical Indications, Patient Preferences, Quality of Life, and Contextual Features. We can organize information regarding this case study by using the Four Topics Method beginning with the Medical Indications. Maria, a 20-year-old female, has been involved in a motor vehicle accident....   [tags: unborn accident victim]

Powerful Essays
1099 words (3.1 pages)

Essay Victim Precipitation Is A Theory

- Victim precipitation is a theory in criminology that analyzes how a victim 's interaction with the offender may have contributed to the crime being committed. Variation of intent by the offender and how the victim may or may not have contributed to the crime, regardless of the actions. With some offenders looking for the right situation to commit a crime, others show little to no prior intent. The approach with assumption that all offenders are equal in their drive and desire to engage in criminal activity was untenable....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Victimology, Victim]

Powerful Essays
714 words (2 pages)

Essay on Success is Its Own Reward

- Ever heard of the say “success is its own reward”. Well, it is. Students should never get paid for good grades. First of all, where will the money come from. Secondly, money could go to waste, and that same money could be used for better things. Third, students are at school for their own will. Finally, students could cheat for money. Firstly, if we pay the students, where will we get the money from. As is, teachers don’t get paid a lot. One of the schools in Chicago enforced the policy to reward students based on their grades....   [tags: students, money, grades]

Powerful Essays
675 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Victim Interview Evaluation : Strengths And Weaknesses

- Victim Interview Evaluation: Strengths and Weaknesses This assignment will identify the strengths and weaknesses regarding the fundamentals of the interviewing, and whether the seven stages in the interview sequence were properly used by the detective in film Interviewing victims and witnesses. Many Successful victim and witness interviews use foundational knowledge to explore and evaluate the role of six key factors and seven stages have in successful interviews. I will carefully examine the effectiveness of the structure that was used by the detective, and identify the presence of proxemics, micro-skills involved in listening, the development of rapport, and p...   [tags: Victim, Interview, Nonverbal communication]

Powerful Essays
1467 words (4.2 pages)

Rape : A Victim Of Sexual Assault Essay

- In about the time it takes you to brush your teeth, someone is becoming a victim of sexual assault. In 2013 there were 334,297 reported cases of sexual assault , of those, 44% of the victims were under the age of 18, according to Rape, Assault, Incest National Network or RAINN. Over half, 68%, of sexual assaults are not reported to authorities, and because of that 98% of rapists will never see the inside of a jail cell. Sadly there is an even more shocking statistic, 4/5 victims know who their assaulter is....   [tags: Rape, Sexual assault, Sexual intercourse, Victim]

Powerful Essays
700 words (2 pages)

National Parks are Victims of Their Own Success as Locations for Leisure Pursuits

- National Parks are Victims of Their Own Success as Locations for Leisure Pursuits This subject has been a matter of much conjecture for many years as international tourism spreads to the most endangered and rare environments across the globe, it is evident that in terms of long term sustainability, National Park ecosystems are at serious threat from that posed by industrial tourism. Physical Degradation People come to national parks in order to experience the wildlife and the natural environment....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
827 words (2.4 pages)