Stalinism and Jews Essay

Stalinism and Jews Essay

Length: 2747 words (7.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Modern World History

Joseph Stalin led the Socialist Soviet Union in the “Revolution from Above,” a movement to centralize the government and transform society without popular participation . Because Stalin’s radical goals were destructive for the populace to attain, his legitimacy was based on the credibility of his ideological authority . In protection of that conviction, Stalin was in constant fear of competitive initiative and philosophy. Stalin subjected society and culture to strict party surveillance and control, issuing pro-socialist, xenophobic propaganda, censoring literature, art, and media, and launching anti-religious campaigns . In addition to his confiscation of religious property and denunciation of belief, Stalin was a contemptuous anti-Semite, using Jewish people as symbols of a corrupt capitalist ethic. However, in 1941, Stalin discontinued his Jewish intolerance and supported the formation of the Jewish Antifascist Committee (JAC) in 1942, contradicting practiced Stalinism and amending his previously categorical policy. Even after WWII, Stalin collaborated with the United States and supported the creation of a Jewish State in Palestine. Soviet Jews raised great hope for future friendship and cooperation with the government . Suddenly, in 1948, Stalin changed his position again, dissolving the JAC, arresting prominent Jews, and beginning the “Black Years” of refreshed repression and anti-Semitism. Although drastic doctrinal oscillations were completely out of character for the inflexible dictator, the changes in Jewish administration were not the only exceptions in his etiology that Stalin made from WWII to his death. The effects of Stalin’s inconstancies were dangerously close to destructive of his legitimacy and authority. What compelled a fanatically unyielding and calculating dictator to alter his policy -- self-preservation, miscalculation, composite guilt, or deteriorating mentality?
     “Stalin owed everything to Lenin.” Stalin’s oppressive rule was legitimized by the “imprimatur of Lenin’s creation and succession.” Marx’s theory became Lenin’s doctrine and Stalin’s creative justification. Lenin’s Bolshevik (“Majority”) party was formed in 1903 with the objective of a stagiest societal evolution of Europe and Russia in the gradual progression from feudalism, to capitalism, to socialism, and to eventu...

... middle of paper ...

...ed up. Stalin worked with the US to build an Israeli state, “striving to win support among Western public opinion,” while anti-Semitism grew among the populace from blaming the Jews for the Nazi invasion. The JAC was dissolved in 1948, and many of its members killed by the NKVD in “deliberately staged accidents.” In victory, “a product of [the new] fierce Russian nationalism was the re-emergence of an age-old anti Semitism.”
The sudden inconsistencies in Stalin’s principles were blatant. Stalin’s rule was based primarily upon the consistency of his theory, and changes in his normally dogmatic method would have been destructive, had it not been for the recent victory over Germany. Stalin’s fluctuations in policy from 1939 until his death in 1953 and the resulting losses in ideological authority were forgotten in the victory celebrations. . By the time the post-war excessive Russian chauvinism had worn off, Stalin’s policy was again stabilized in anti-Semitic xenophobia. Stalin feared contradicting his ideology, but with the onset of World War II, he compromised the dangers to his dictatorship. Stalin’s risky changes in etiology had strong motives in calculated self-preservation.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Stalinism Essays

- Stalinism How far was Stalinism the outcome of Leninist political practice. The political system which existed in the Soviet Union under Stalin was a system of terror. The purges of the 1930s sent millions of Russians to their deaths or to the Gulags, the population was scared of the secret police, the NKVD, the forced collectivization of agriculture had wiped out a part of Russian society, the Kulaks. The show trials of the thirties had firmly established Stalin as the leader of the Soviet Union....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1993 words (5.7 pages)

The Jews in Auschwitz Essay

- The Third Reich sought the removal of the Jews from Germany and eventually from the world. This removal came in two forms, first through emigration, then through extermination. In David Engel’s The Holocaust: The Third Reich and the Jews, he rationalizes that the annihilation of the Jews by the Germans was a result of how Jews were viewed by the leaders of the Third Reich-- as pathogens that threatened to destroy all humanity. By eliminating the existence of the Jews, the Third Reich believed that it would save the entire world from mortal danger....   [tags: The Third Reich, Jews, Germany, Nazi]

Powerful Essays
1413 words (4 pages)

Law And Practices Of Jews And Muslims Essay

- When reading the Siete partidas, the main differences between laws and practices in the treatment of Jews and Muslims that Nirenberg and Barton failed to explain were the conversion laws for these non-Christians. These laws carefully explain the way in which to persuade a non-Christian to convert; “by means of the texts of the Holy Scriptures, and by kind words, for no one can love or appreciate a service which is done him by compulsion” (49). In regards to Jews, if a Jew or Jewess wishes to convert to Christianity, “all persons in our dominions shall honor them”, no one was allowed to insult or harm any convert for formerly being a Jew....   [tags: Judaism, Religion, Persian Jews, Jews]

Powerful Essays
1064 words (3 pages)

Hungarian Jews and the Holocaust Essay

- “There is a place on earth that is a vast desolate wilderness, a place populated by shadows of the dead in their multitudes, a place where the living are dead, where only death, hate and pain exist,” said Giuliana Tedeschi, a holocaust survivor (Tedeschi). The Hungarian Jews assumed they were the safest of all the Jewish groups and in the end suffered the most. Hundreds were shipped in cattle cars without supplies for days to concentration camps. Auschwitz, one of the furthermost used death camps was going under colossal change to prepare for the arrival of the unfortunate Hungarian Jews....   [tags: nazi, jews]

Powerful Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about Jews, Christians, And Muslims

- In this week 's reading, we read about how Jews, Christians, and Muslims interacted with one another in Barcelona, Toledo, and Granada. Elka Klein 's book on Jews, Christian Society, and Royal Power in Medieval Barcelona gives context to Jewish/Christian relations in Barcelona, while also defining the Jewish "community" in terms of acculturation. Barcelona was still a frontier society ruled by the Counts of Barcelona after Louis the Pious captured the city from the Moors in the ninth century, and it became a vital commercial center in the 12-13th centuries under Ramon Berenguer VI....   [tags: Judaism, Jews, Israel, Persian Jews]

Powerful Essays
971 words (2.8 pages)

Anti Semitism, A Hatred Of Jews Essay

- Anti-Semitism, a hatred of Jews, has been present for centuries in many places. However, the term ‘Anti-Semitism’ itself only came into use in the nineteenth century, and along with it came an ideology which fuelled this deep psychological hatred to develop into a political movement which culminated in Nazism. Throughout history, the reasons for Anti-Semitism have differed and in Imperial Germany, it was a combination of religious, racial and political factors which led to such hostility toward Jews....   [tags: Antisemitism, Jews, Judaism, Germany]

Powerful Essays
1763 words (5 pages)

Martin Luther and The Jews Essay

- Martin Luther’s actions and intentions have puzzled historians for centuries. Some believe that Luther was in fact, a beneficial character towards the Jews; however, based on various historical proofs, Luther was not favourable towards the Jews in history. Contrary to some opinions of Luther’s kindness towards the Jews, his propaganda and extensive efforts to punish the people deem him to be a deceitful man. Although Luther appeared to be inconsistent in his emotions towards Jews, he was ultimately an anti-Jewish character in his era....   [tags: history, christians, jews]

Powerful Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Was Stalinism Inevitable? Essay

- Was Stalinism Inevitable. Introduction "Let's replace Long Live Leninism with Long Live Stalinism!” This declaration by a communist leader and staunch Stalin supporter Lazar Kaganovich perhaps best summarizes the popularity and personality cult of Joseph Stalin which overtook and in some cases, replaced the precepts of Marxism-Leninism. Although many see Stalinism as the natural heir and iteration of Leninism, others see it as a gross deviation from the principles of Marxism-Leninism, deeming Stalinism as all those steps and policies that lead to the formation of a society based on the vision, principles and ideals of Joseph Stalin, while maintaining a threadbare association or even using as...   [tags: communist leaders]

Powerful Essays
2701 words (7.7 pages)

Everyday Stalinism Essay

- When most people hear the name Joseph Stalin, they usually associate the name with a man who was part of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union and was responsible for the deaths of millions of people. He was willingly to do anything to improve the power of the Soviet Union’s economy and military, even if it meant executing tens of millions of innocent people (Frankforter, A. Daniel., and W. M. Spellman 655). In chapter three of Sheila Fitzpatrick’s book, Everyday Stalinism, she argues that since citizens believed the propaganda of “a radiant future” (67), they were able to be manipulated by the Party in the transformation of the Soviet Union....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Sheila Fitzpatrick]

Free Essays
546 words (1.6 pages)

The Role of Jews in American Politics Essay

- Since our country was established, immigrants from all over the world have come to America seeking a better life. As they progressively become more acquainted with the American life style they tend to become more involved in the daily interest of their new country. Specifically, Jews have been in the United States for centuries, but for a long time anti-Semitism and discrimination have made it very difficult for them to participate in politics. Jews have become a more active part of American politics due to Senator Lieberman’s candidacy for Vice President....   [tags: Jews in Politics, 2015]

Powerful Essays
1677 words (4.8 pages)