Essay on Adam Smith and Karl Marx

Essay on Adam Smith and Karl Marx

Length: 1265 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The task of political economy, Marx argued, was to understand all the presumptions within productive and social relations which made social life in a given form possible at a particular time.(Peterson,17). In some nations, as Hobbes states, the lives of the poor are "nasty,brutish and short", by contrast in other nations , the poor do better within same levels of wealth. The aim of political economy is to understand the processes that produce these differences. The two historical figures that analyzed capitalism were A.Smith and K.Marx. Their philosophy differ in the way each viewed the human conditions and the role of the individual. It could be argued that history has shown Smith to be right and Marx to be wrong but the fact is that each of these men understood capitalism on different terms although both had similar material aims.

The main difference between Marx's and Smith's thoughts is found in the values that each concerned. Smith suggested that the economic process can be forever unchangeable in its natural stage as individuals seek their own advantages.If people are left free they will try to improve the quality of their lives.This can be achieved in two ways : by individual effort or at someone else's expense. Most individuals will search for or make something that others will pay for rather than live at someone else's expense. On the other hand, Marx noticed a growing consciousness among the working class of society which he believed was formed by economic development and that would create a transformation of the whole social system: He asserts that "it is not the consciousness of men that determines their existence , but their social existence that determines their existence.At a certain stage of development , the material productive forces of society come into conflict with the existing relations of production...Then begins the era of social revolution ." (Marx,140) Marx is talking about consciousness and the development of the society.He believes that the wealth produced by the industrial system develops the introspective thought in all people, more importantly among working class.

The individual comes to a self-realization through creative labor and develops a self -identity through relations with other members of the society . He considers the potential for intellectual growth as a way to take society to a new level of equality.(Everli...

... middle of paper ...

...laborers since all must use effort to create their industry,thus final profit for themselves.He believes that all men are capitalists in a free economic society. Smith suggests that those who possess wealth have an interest in increasing it and such increase could never be motivated by giving society free exercise of all individual interests. He states " The sum of individual private fortunes makes up the wealth of the nation; there is no wealthy person who does not strive to become richer; let him do as he pleases; he will enrich the nation by enriching himself" (Sismondi,53) Each of these philosophers had valid points to make but they are focused on different targets. They in fact agree that the production of wealth in society is good but they would not agree on the conditions of the workers. If Smith possibily ask who stop the workers leave their profession and to join another,Marx response would be the social conditioning. That is among the valid answer for the failure of the communism.People need to believe that if they had made right choices ,or worked hard enough ,they would have gone to the top of society .But in communist plan there was no top to reach to motivate people.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Great Minds Of Adam Smith And Karl Marx Essay

- The two great minds of Adam Smith and Karl Marx have just as many similarities as they have differences. Both want to help the general populous by reducing poverty. Both have a distaste for big business and elitists. Both believed that the most valuable entity in an economy was labor and the ability to produce goods. Both were philosophers and economists that put great thought into the morals of their economic systems. Despite having common goals and beliefs, they differed in how to achieve an economy that worked for everyone, not just the über wealthy....   [tags: Economics, Capitalism, Adam Smith, Karl Marx]

Strong Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

A Comparison of the Economic Philosophies of Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill, and Karl Marx

- As far back as man has been on earth, he has been driven towards building a community among his peers. Whether that is a community of hunters and gatherers who share whatever the day has brought to them within their tribe, or a larger community which within its structure lie the inner dwellings of division of labor and societal classes. Adam Smith (18th Century), John Stuart Mill (19th Century), and Karl Marx (19th Century) are of the same cloth, but in modern terms their community is referenced as a government, and they each have their own distinct opinions on the 'drive' instilled within human nature that shape their personal economic theories....   [tags: Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill, Karl Marx]

Strong Essays
1775 words (5.1 pages)

Karl Marx And Adam Smith Essay examples

- Many historical figures have different views on how a country should be governed. Two in particular are Karl Marx and Adam Smith. Both men are best known for their opinions on how a country’s economy ought to be run. Adam Smith believes in capitalism, while Karl Marx would rather have a socialist economy. They expressed entirely new ideas that nations still follow today. These two men have completely different views on the class system, economy, and government of a nation. Adam Smith was a Scottish economist and is known as the “father of modern economics”....   [tags: Marxism, Socialism, Capitalism, Karl Marx]

Strong Essays
1015 words (2.9 pages)

Karl Marx And Adam Smith Essay

- Business and Society Ryan Malloy Adam Smith vs. Karl Marx Professor Kushner 9/17/15 Both Karl Marx and Adam Smith were greatly respected economists during the 18th and 19th centuries. They both viewed society, the economy and politics in different ways. Smith viewed capitalism and the free market as a necessity to society while Marx believed that the bourgeoisie and the proletariat were the two classes that would constantly be fighting between each other. Marx believes that the government needs to intervene to help the working class and that the class system needs to be taken down completely....   [tags: Marxism, Working class, Karl Marx, Socialism]

Strong Essays
1095 words (3.1 pages)

The, Wealth Of Nations By Jean Jacques Rousseau, Adam Smith, And Karl Marx

- Throughout our history as a western civilization, we have made technologic advances and innovations that have furthered ourselves as a society and benefited us greatly by improving the quality of life. However, with these advantages there are also the disadvantages; these advances have also integrated injustice and inequality into our society. Through the writings of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Adam Smith, and Karl Marx, it can be shown how our western society has spiraled into a system of inequality amongst its communities....   [tags: Karl Marx, Capitalism, Jean-Jacques Rousseau]

Strong Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

Comparing Adam Smith and Karl Marx Essay

- Comparing Adam Smith and Karl Marx Smith and Marx agree upon the importance of capitalism as unleashing productive powers. Capitalism is born out of the division of labour... that is, it is made possible by dividing jobs up into simple tasks as a way of increasing efficiency. By increasing efficiency, then everyone can produce more than they personally need. The extra produced can go towards the accumulation of capital, (machines, more land, more tools, etc) which will allow for even more increased efficiency and production....   [tags: Politics Political Essays]

Strong Essays
562 words (1.6 pages)

Karl Marx and Adam Smith Essay

- Karl Marx and Adam Smith Karl Marx and Adam Smith wrote in the same time period – during the industrial revolution, where the bourgeois had risen to power by oppressing and exploiting the proletariat. The term bourgeois refers to the people in the class of modern capitalists, owners of the means of social production and employers of wage labor. The proletarians are the people in the class of modern wage laborers who, having no means of production of their own, are reduced to selling their labor power in order to live....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1390 words (4 pages)

Economic Theorist : Adam Smith, Karl Marx, And Milton Friedman Essay

- Economic Theorist Many prominent economists have connected with society and made significant impacts to the economic scope of resourcing financial interest and embarking in independent productivity and innovation. Some major economic theorist includes Adam Smith, Karl Marx, and Milton Friedman. However, Alan Greenspan is one that in recent views made some impactful moves that changed the way the economy is seen and run. The changes made in earlier years, have affected higher education through today and the institutions need to review its financial framework in order to maintain its level of effective operation....   [tags: Economics, Monetary policy]

Strong Essays
717 words (2 pages)

Essay on Adam Smith and Karl Marx

- The task of political economy, Marx argued, was to understand all the presumptions within productive and social relations which made social life in a given form possible at a particular time.(Peterson,17). In some nations, as Hobbes states, the lives of the poor are "nasty,brutish and short", by contrast in other nations , the poor do better within same levels of wealth. The aim of political economy is to understand the processes that produce these differences. The two historical figures that analyzed capitalism were A.Smith and K.Marx....   [tags: Economics Political Economy Capitalism]

Strong Essays
1265 words (3.6 pages)

Adam Smith v. Karl Marx Essays

- Adam Smith v. Karl Marx Being reared in the typical capitalist community in the United States, it is much easier for me to relate to the thoughts of Adam Smith. This is not to say that I do not agree with some of the precepts of pure Communism, but like the old adage says, "Communism looks good on paper, but in practice, it is completely ineffective." Historically, this form of government does not tend to succeed because of many factors. Some of these include basic economic differences, individualism, and technology and how it advances or serves as a detriment to the state....   [tags: Papers Capitalism Communism Essays]

Strong Essays
2228 words (6.4 pages)