Should Children Be Allowed To Testify In Court? Essay

Should Children Be Allowed To Testify In Court? Essay

Length: 2260 words (6.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Should Children Be Allowed To Testify In Court?

     Over the past ten years, more research has been done involving
children's testimony than that of all the prior decades combined. Ceci & Bruck
(93) have cited four reasons for this :

- The opinion of psychology experts is increasingly being accepted by courts as

- Social research is more commonly being applied to the issues of children's

- More research into adult suggestibility in accordance with reason naturally
leads to more research into child suggestibility,

- Children are more commonly being used as witnesses in cases where they are
directly involved (i.e. sexual abuses cases), requiring the development of
better ways for dealing with them as special cases.

      Some psychologists deem children to be “Highly resistant to suggestion,
as unlikely to lie, and as reliable as adult witnesses about acts perpetrated
on their bodies” (Ceci & Bruck 1993). However, children are also described as “
Having difficulty distinguishing reality from fantasy, as being susceptible to
coaching by powerful authority figures, and therefore as being potentially less
reliable than adults” (Ceci & Bruck 1993). The suggestibility of child witnesses,
the effects of participation on children's reports, and the effects of postevent
information on a prior memory representation must be taken into account when it
comes to seeking answers to the reliability of their testimony, especially
because sexual abuse and sexual assault cases are a big part of children's
testimony and they are often the only witness.

     Those psychologists who feel that children can be rated as “Highly
resistant to suggestion....” etc. seem to have a good argument, whereas those
who take the opposite view also seem to have just as valid an argument. Which
psychologists are right? Maybe both. It seems that without outside influences,
social encounters, or other interference's, children's testimony has the
potential to be quite valid. This is under ideal situations, however, which
unfortunately rarely occur.

     One of the major problems when assessing the validity of child witnesses
is the suggestibility of the child. Ceci & Bruck (1993) define suggestibility
as “The degree to which children's encoding, storage, retrieval, and reporting
of events can be influenced by a range of social an...

... middle of paper ...

...t that no children should be allowed to testify
on account of the malleability of their recollection. However, children can
play a vital role in the legal system, and indeed there are many cases in which
a child is the only witness to a crime, but until the time that sufficient
research has been done to achieve a system of questioning that will eliminate
the suggestibility and social aspects of a child's testimony, all such
testimonies should be treated with caution.

Works Cited:

     Bernstein, D. A., Roy, E. J., Srull, T. K., Wickens, C. D. (1994)
Psychology, 3rd edition. Houghton Mifflin Company, MA.

     Ceci, S & Bruck, M. (1993). Suggestibility of the Child Witness: A
Historical Review and Synthesis, Psychological Bulletin. 113, 403 - 439

     Lefrancois, G. R. (1992). Psychology, 2nd edition. Wadsworth Publishing
Company. California.

     Luus, C. A. E., Wells, G. L., & Turtle, J. W. (1995). Child
eyewitnesses: Seeing is believing. Journal of Applied Psychology, 80, 317 - 326

     Rovee-Collier, C. et al. (1993). Infants Eyewitness Testimony: Effects
of Postevent Information on a Prior Memory Representaion, Memory and Cognition,
21, 267 - 279

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Should Prayer Be Allowed in Schools? Essay

- 1 Should Prayer Be Allowed In Schools With all the arguments on whether prayer should be allowed in schools, the history behind all the debate on this issue is back and fourth if they should have it or not. Prayer should be one of the main priorities in the day-to-day bases. This day and time, U.S. citizens don’t want to hurt any ones feelings such as; prayer or even reading scripture from the Bible. This great country that we live in was founded upon God and we have gone so far from it in the past two hundred years or more....   [tags: public education policies]

Term Papers
668 words (1.9 pages)

Should Gay Marriage Be Allowed? Essay

- On June 26, 2015, the US Supreme Court ruled that the US Constitution guarantees the right for same-sex couples to marry. Should gay marriages really be allowed. Has the Supreme Court ruled in error. In our society today, homosexuals are treated unconstitutionally, they are forced to live a secret life, they are forbidden to adopt and raise children and unable to marry the person that they love. This is just a few to the many inequalities that homosexuals face in everyday life. The constitution guarantees the right to free speech and the right to pursue happiness to everyone, although homosexuals do not get to live their life by their choice....   [tags: Homosexuality, Same-sex marriage]

Term Papers
1110 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Undocumented Children Should Attend College

- As Americans, we believe that our great country is a land of milk and honey, of open windows and opportunities, and of rights and privileges. With that being said, we all strive to live the American Dream, with some if not most of us, leaving not only our mother country in the process but our comfort zone. The question to ask is, “Is everyone in this nation, legal or illegal, entitled to these blessings bestowed to us by this country?” After all, according to the Declaration of Independence, we as human beings are granted life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness (US 1776)....   [tags: Children in Immigrant Parents]

Term Papers
2230 words (6.4 pages)

Why Religion Should Not Be Allowed in Public Schools Essay

- Religion should be prohibited in public schools. There’s no reason for allowing religious displays to destruct the public education system. The involvement of religion in public schools is distracting and unnecessary. The removal of religion, except for educational purposes, is essential to providing a stable and effective learning environment for every student. Without religion, students could be provided with a better chance of succeeding in the classroom. Only the school board officials and members of congress can take religion completely out of the public school systems....   [tags: distracting, religion free environment]

Term Papers
1604 words (4.6 pages)

Essay about Prayer Should Not be Allowed in Public Schools

- Prayer Should Not be Allowed in Public Schools School prayer is a very controversial issue in today’s society. This issue has been a problem since America was first founded, in that the country was founded on religious beliefs. The Pilgrims wanted to be able to express their beliefs freely, but in England this freedom was not found, so they decided to come to the Americas, where their beliefs could be expressed freely. As time passed they realized that having this kind of freedom caused problems between different belief systems....   [tags: Religion in Public Schools]

Term Papers
1052 words (3 pages)

Should Abortion Be Allowed? Essay

- Abortion is when you end a pregnancy so it does not result in a birth. It is defined as the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy, most often performed during the first 28 weeks of pregnancy. It is a greatly debated topic and many people have fought for both sides of the argument. Another term for it is a miscarriage. Although many disagree keeping abortion legal there are many strong reasons to support its legalization. When looking at the reasons of making abortion legal you must first take a look at the opposing side....   [tags: pregnancy, legal, choice]

Term Papers
1307 words (3.7 pages)

Essay Why should Homosexuals be allowed to Adopt.

- Several people are opposed to the idea of homosexuals adopting. Nonetheless, homosexuals have an abundance of privileges as many other couples do. Sexual orientation doesn’t have any relevance on your entitlement to adoption. Families are usually the central source of socialization. When we define the word family, a numerous of people would include a mother, father, and at best two children, possibly one child. Truly speaking of a nuclear family, but realistically families take different appearances and are represented in other ways....   [tags: homosexuality]

Term Papers
2032 words (5.8 pages)

Argumentative Essay: Women Should Not Be Allowed To Go Topless In Public

- Argumentative Essay: Should Women Be Allowed To Go Topless in Public      In the summer of 1996 Gwen Jacobs enjoyed a topless summer stroll during which she was seen by a local O.P.P officer, was apprehended and subsequently charged with indecent exposure. Gwen Jacobs pleaded not guilty in court and won the right to go topless in Ontario. This incident brought up an excellent question: should women be allowed to go topless on public beaches and in other public areas. The answer is strictly no, women should not be allowed to go topless anywhere outside of their own home....   [tags: Public Nudity Nude essays research papers]

Term Papers
869 words (2.5 pages)

Atwater vs. Supreme court Essays

- I selected the case of Atwater vs. The city of Lago Vista Gail Atwater was stopped by a police officer for not having her children seatbelted. Instead of issuing a minor misdemeanor ticket, as is normally done, the officer arrested Atwater The city of Lago Vista removed the suit and sent it to the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas, Which gave ruling to The city of Lago Vista. The court said that Atwater had failed to present proof that any constitutional right had been violated....   [tags: essays research papers]

Term Papers
454 words (1.3 pages)

Supreme Court Cases Essay

- Supreme Court Cases First Amendment- Case Facts: Students wore anti-war bands to school, which in turn got them suspended from school. The students sued the school for impeding upon their free speech. Students Arguments: 1st and 14th Amendment-free speech, they weren't hurting anyone. School Arguments: 10th Amendment-allowed the school to suspend the kids in fear of endangering other student's health and academic well being Supreme Court Decision: The students won. "Students do not shed their 1st Amendment rights at the school gates"....   [tags: Law Legal]

Free Essays
1043 words (3 pages)