Today, we live in a society faced with many problems, including crime and the fear that it creates. In the modern era, juveniles have become a part of society to be feared, not rehabilitated. The basis of the early juvenile justice system was to rehabilitate and create safe havens for wayward youth. This is not the current philosophy, although the U.S. is one of the few remaining countries to execute juveniles. Presently, our nation is under a presidential administration that strongly advocates the death penalty, including the execution of juveniles. The media and supporters of capital punishment warn of the "superpredator," the juvenile with no fear, remorse, or conscience. Opponents of this view encourage the idea that another death is only revenge, not deterrence. We will examine the rights allotted to juvenile offenders, and the punishments inflicted upon them for violations of the law.
Juvenile Transfers and Waivers
For those juveniles deemed dangerous, or those that have committed a serious crime, a different process would follow their initial contact with the court. This involves the removal of the offender from the juvenile system, to be transferred to the adult criminal court. These offenders are adjudicated as an adult if certain factors are present. The waiver to the adult court is often a critical step in receiving a harsh sentence for juveniles. Two Supreme Court cases have addressed the issue of juvenile waivers and transfers, Kent v. United States and Breed v. Jones. The two cases resulted in specific requirements for transfer hearings, including a) a legitimate transfer hearing b) sufficient notice to family and defense attorney c) right to counsel d) a statement regarding reason for the transfer. However, the waiver of juveniles is often criticized by experts for various reasons. "Minors are likely to be looked upon as special persons by prosecutors, probation officers, and judges in the criminal courts. They are younger than the main population of defendants before the criminal courts…while a minor may be looked upon as a hardened criminal in the juvenile court, (s)he may be viewed as a mere innocent youngster in criminal court." (Abadinsky 72). Some research has shown that the transfer of juveniles is a waste of both time and money. Why? Because the offender often receives the same treatment or senten...
... middle of paper ...
...ny high profile issue, and in this case we are dealing with the lives of young offenders, many of which claim their age excuses their "mistake." While society must recognize the issues that often fuel adolescent rage, we should be hesitant to withhold punishment. In death row cases, many inmates will reside on death row for more than ten years before being executed. During this time, they undergo many changes, both physically and psychologically and often feel like a different man, and certainly not a violent threat to society. Moreover, we are not executing men (and women) for the people they have become, but for the crime they committed. Their victims did not receive a second chance, so why should we as a society grant convicted killers the chance to live, love, and grow? However, the death penalty must be examined for flaws, including incorporating DNA technology whenever possible. Age has obviously been an important factor in the debate over the death penalty, but we must realize we live in an age of violent school shootings and declining alternatives for misplaced youth. Society should not advocate the death of innocents, but vindicate a willful and deliberate loss of life.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Sentencing of Juveniles Today, we live in a society faced with many problems, including crime and the fear that it creates. In the modern era, juveniles have become a part of society to be feared, not rehabilitated. The basis of the early juvenile justice system was to rehabilitate and create safe havens for wayward youth. This is not the current philosophy, although the U.S. is one of the few remaining countries to execute juveniles. Presently, our nation is under a presidential administration that strongly advocates the death penalty, including the execution of juveniles.... [tags: Juvenile Crime Criminal Sentence Essays]
2565 words (7.3 pages)
- The justice system is flawed greatly when it comes to sentencing juveniles who commit heinous crimes. In comparison to adults who commit the same crime, juveniles will be given a less harsh sentence mainly because of the fact that a juvenile is not considered an adult yet. Juvenile’s records are, in a sense, forgiven or put away, not for the public to have access to, unlike adults ' records. People under 18 years of age are capable of the same actions that someone over the age of 17 is capable of, including committing murders.... [tags: Murder, Prison, Life imprisonment]
1334 words (3.8 pages)
- On Thursday, November 14, 2013, I attended a municipal court at Mario E. Ramirez Detention Center. From 1:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m., I saw my brother and other juvenile’s get sentenced for various reasons. Being my first time attending a juvenile court, I was in shock because of the parent’s reactions, the rulings of Judge Jesse Contreras, the judge’s impact, and the overall court situation. Before the court began, parents, some not all, talked among themselves about their children and other topics. In my case, my mother along with only about four other mothers were seated.... [tags: sentencing, probation, life classes, school]
553 words (1.6 pages)
- Sentencing to Service (STS) is a sentencing option available to most Courts where a convicted offender "works off” his/her fine by performing a specified number of hours of public service work under the supervision of a work crew leader employed by the state or a local corrections agency. Courts may also sentence offenders to STS rather than jail or workhouse time. STS was established in 1986 by the Minnesota Department of Corrections along with several County Sheriff’s Departments, community corrections, Courts and local governments.... [tags: Sentencing to Service, Juvenile delinquency, ]
898 words (2.6 pages)
- Laws regarding the age at which young people can be tried as adults must change because allowing juvenile offenders lighter sentences under juvenile court laws is only enabling their behavior and failing to teach them about real consequences to crime, yet not always in the best interest of the child such as alternatives are. It is necessary in some cases to send the juvenile to adult court for prosecution. But it is really hard to keep kids safe in an adult jail. Also by not giving youth their own separate facility they are not getting the proper education that they need to survive if they are ever released from prison (Gerdes 118-122).... [tags: juvenile offenders, light sentences, jail]
1165 words (3.3 pages)
- In most cases, the arrest of a juvenile will be handed over to the juvenile justice system. The juvenile justice system places an emphasis on rehabilitation, education, and treatment of the convicted offenders. Juveniles’ records are confidential and more easily esponged. This will hopefully allow these kids to turn their life around for the better. The adult justice system focuses on punishment, which does not emphasize sending convicts down the right path once, or if, they are released. Juveniles commit sixteen percent of violent crimes that lead to an arrest.... [tags: Prison, Crime, Capital punishment, Penology]
1494 words (4.3 pages)
- How would you feel if the police arrested kids all over our country to jail for just crossing the street the wrong way or pushing another kid on the playground. That is what is happening to many underage juvenile all over the United States; they are being sent to adult prisons for crimes that do not deserve such severe punishments. Why they were tried as adults is an enigma and we will explain why this is a terrible injustice. In 1899 children in between the ages of 7-14 were believed they were incapable of committing criminal intent.... [tags: Crime, Juveniles, Laws]
1189 words (3.4 pages)
- Juveniles and the Death Penalty It is cruel and unethical for children under eighteen to be sentenced to death row. Death Penalty, also called capital punishment is a sentence of death by a court. Children are not yet matured to receive such punishments. Also, children under the age eighteen should not be in adult prisons or trialed as an adult. Juveniles should not be sentenced to death, because they may be reasons why they commit those crimes. Not only that, children should have the right to trial if they have health issues that caused them to commit those crimes.... [tags: Capital punishment, Penology, Prison, Death row]
1046 words (3 pages)
- When juvenile are being sentenced life in prison for committing murder has always been an issue in many court cases. Some believe that they don 't deserve a second chance and that they should be sentenced life in prison but others do believe in second chances. There are many reasons to why juveniles should be given a second chance in life when they commit a crime such as murder. For example, the brain of these juveniles is not fully developed, the environment can influence them to do such crimes and there 's still ways for them to change and turn their life around.... [tags: Crime, Prison, Murder, Life imprisonment]
1079 words (3.1 pages)
- Juveniles and the Death Penalty Do you think juveniles should be held responsible for their actions. For many years, children have been sentenced to death without trial. Young people are not capable of making rational decisions. Hence, children are restricted from doing many things. For instance, children under the age eighteen are not allowed by law to vote, and work for a certain number of hours. However, when it comes to sentencing children as adults to the death penalty, it is not illegal.... [tags: Prison, Capital punishment, Penology, Death row]
718 words (2.1 pages)