Comparing Love in the Film, Secrets and Lies and Toni Morrison's Beloved

Comparing Love in the Film, Secrets and Lies and Toni Morrison's Beloved

Length: 2154 words (6.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Possessive Love in Secrets and Lies and Beloved  

 
 The word “freedom” is subject to various degrees of interpretation in the sense that it can be used in more than one context.  One definition of freedom is the idea of having your own sense of self without the control of others.  On the other hand, a lack of freedom is the idea of feeling trapped and smothered in a situation one has no control over.  Freedom can relate to school, relationships, or even within oneself.  A lack of freedom can have nothing to do with other people but with the ball and chain that can be placed on by oneself.  Of course the outside world will be involved, but the pain of feeling trapped comes from the frustration that fills one’s soul.  A lack of freedom can result from a twisted circle of other events and other people.  In the novel Beloved and the film Secrets and Lies, the enslavement that Roxanne and Denver feel result from their mothers’ possessive love.  Sethe and Cynthia both have horrific pasts, leaving them in captivity and causing them to have unhealthy relationships with their daughters.  Sethe and Cynthia love the only way the know how, possessively and dependently, causing Denver and Roxanne’s mental enslavement.


 In the film Secrets and Lies, both Cynthia and her twenty-one year-old daughter Roxanne, live a life of captivity.  Cynthia’s is due to her unexplained past, while Roxanne’s is in result of her overbearing mother.  Cynthia’s lack of freedom does not result from another’s actions, but from her own past.  The trauma and lack of love she has experienced, has been blocked out and instead of dealing with it, she lives off of the attention of others.  When she meets her daughter Hortense, whom she had given up for adopt...


... middle of paper ...


...or a life as it is now under Beloved’s control, she chooses a life for herself.  By having support for the first time, freeing both of her daughters, and restoring her sense of self, Sethe is on her way to a life of happiness and trust, rather than dependence on others.


 Although their backgrounds are completely different, both Cynthia and Sethe battle the same demons.  Their pasts have consumed them and dependence on others, or complete isolation is the only way they know how to deal with it.  This causes the mental enslavement of Roxanne and Denver.   In order to overcome their emotional scars, they must learn to stand on their own two feet.  Only when they do this will they be able to release their daughters, and restore their own self worth and freedom for all.
 
 

Works Cited

Morrison, Toni.  Beloved.  New York: Penguin Books, 1998.
 

 

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing the Love in Beloved and Secrets and Lies Essay

- Overbearing Love in Beloved and Secrets and Lies Children are protected from the evil in the world from their parents, especially their mothers. An excerpt written by Kahilil Girbran, The Prophet, explains one view of the parent/child relationship. "And a women who held a baby against her bosom said, Speak to us of Children. And he said: Your children are not your children. They are the sons and daughters of Life's longing for itself. They come through you but not from you, And though they are with you yet they belong not to you....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Free Essays
1639 words (4.7 pages)

Essay about Love in Toni Morrison's "Beloved"

- Love is said to be one of the most desired things in life. People long for it, search for it, and crave it. It can come in the form of partners, friends, or just simply family. To some, love is something of a necessity in life, where some would rather turn a cold shoulder to it. Love can be the mixture of passion, need, lust, loyalty, and blood. Love can be extraordinary and breathtaking. Love being held so high can also be dangerous. Love can drive people to numerous mad things with it dangerously so full of craze and passion....   [tags: Love, Toni Morrison, Beloved,]

Powerful Essays
648 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on The Contrasting Nature Of Love Explored In Toni Morrison's Beloved

- In her novel Beloved, Toni Morrison explores the paradoxical nature of love both as a dangerous presence that promises suffering and a life-giving force that gives the strength to proceed; through the experiences of the run-away slave Sethe. The dangerous aspect of love is revealed through the comments of Paul D and Ella regarding the motherly love of Sethe towards her children. Sethe's deep attachment to her children is deemed dangerous due to their social environment which evidently promises that the loved one of a slave will be hurt....   [tags: Toni Morrison Beloved Love]

Powerful Essays
1381 words (3.9 pages)

Destructive Love in Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon Essay examples

- Destructive Love in Toni Morrison's Song of Solomon When an emotion is believed to embody all that brings bliss, serenity, effervescence, and even benevolence, although one may believe its encompassing nature to allow for generalizations and existence virtually everywhere, surprisingly, directly outside the area love covers lies the very antithesis of love: hate, which in all its forms, has the potential to bring pain and destruction. Is it not for this very reason, this confusion, that suicide bombings and other acts of violence and devastation are committed…in the name of love....   [tags: Solomon Toni Morrison]

Powerful Essays
1770 words (5.1 pages)

Essay About Tough Love in Toni Morrison's Beloved

- Tough Love in Beloved What kind of mother would cut her child's head off with a hacksaw. This is a question Pulitzer and Nobel prize winner Toni Morrison explores in Beloved, a novel with a chilling metaphor about the legacy of slavery and which finds echoes in another current question, Why is the leading cause of death among young African American men murder by another black. Sethe, the novel's main protagonist, is an escaped slave and mother of four a few years after the end of the Civil War....   [tags: Toni Morrison Beloved Essays]

Free Essays
804 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Secrets and Lies

- Secrets and Lies Throughout our lives we are shaped and molded by our friends and family. They have a lasting affect that can shape our mind and our self. Self is determined by the combination of selves that surround a person on a daily basis. From the childhood friends that we try so hard to hang on to as we journey farther and farther into the real world, to the hated boss and teachers that haunt our mind as we lie awake in our beds at nighttime, we are a product of all those selves....   [tags: Secrets and Lies Essays]

Powerful Essays
1403 words (4 pages)

The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison Essay

- The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison Beauty is dangerous, especially when you lack it. In the book "The Bluest Eye" by Toni Morrison, we witness the effects that beauty brings. Specifically the collapse of Pecola Breedlove, due to her belief that she did not hold beauty. The media in the 1940's as well as today imposes standards in which beauty is measured up to; but in reality beauty dwells within us all whether it's visible or not there's beauty in all; that beauty is unworthy if society brands you with the label of being ugly....   [tags: Bluest Eye Toni Morrison]

Free Essays
1122 words (3.2 pages)

A Comparison of Love in Beloved and Secrets and Lies Essay

- The Absence of Love in Beloved and Secrets and Lies   Love is arguably the most powerful emotion possessed by mankind; it is the impalpable bond that allows individuals to connect and understand one another. Pure love is directly related to divinity.  Without love, happiness and prosperity become unreachable goals.  An individual that possesses all the desired superficial objects in the world stands alone without the presence of love. For centuries love has been marveled by all that dare encounter it.  Countless books and poems have been transcribed to explain the phenomenon of love, but love surpasses all intellectual explanations and discussions.   Love is not a definition, but rather...   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Powerful Essays
2599 words (7.4 pages)

Essay about A Comparison of Love in Secrets and Lies and Beloved

- Suffocating Love in Secrets and Lies and Beloved   Each person in today’s society has a different definition of love.  One’s idea of love is determined by his or her experiences, emotions, and influences.  This definition is pondered and revised an infinite number of times throughout one’s life.  The meaning changes as he or she experiences different relationships based on love: parent-child, priest-parishioner, teacher-student, pet-owner.  These relationships alter perspectives on the meaning of love.  Oftentimes, an experience causes a person to incorrectly, or unhealthily, define love;  however, my experiences have caused me to have a healthy and positive definition of love....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Powerful Essays
2465 words (7 pages)

Comparing Two Love Poems, Our Love Now and To His Coy Mistress Essay

- Comparing Two Love Poems, 'Our Love Now' and 'To His Coy Mistress' Poetry has been around now for many decades, it is a form of writing that can be expressed in many different forms of style, context and language. The majority of poetry is love or war poetry, this is because love and war have many different view points form every individual person therefore no love or war poem can be the same due to this emotion involved. I.e., in a love poem you are writing your own personal feelings about or for a loved one, no other person can have these exact feelings, it is a way of opening out your heart....   [tags: Compare and Contrast Comparing]

Powerful Essays
1001 words (2.9 pages)