Pluto: A Planet? Essays

Pluto: A Planet? Essays

Length: 1670 words (4.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Pluto: A Planet?

Many issues have arisen from the debate whether or not Pluto is a planet. Some astronomers say that Pluto should be classified as a “minor planet” due to its size, physical characteristics, and other factors. On the other hand, some astronomers defend Pluto’s planet status, citing several key features.
Indeed, most of the problem is that there is no formal definition of a planet. Furthermore, it is very difficult to invent one that would allow the solar system to contain all nine planets. I suggest that for an object to be classified as a planet, it must embody three characteristics. It must be in orbit around a star (thus removing the larger satellites from contention), it must be too small to generate heat by nuclear fusion (so dwarf stars are excluded) and it must be massive enough to have collapsed to a more or less spherical shape (which excludes comets, and most of the asteroids). These criteria would admit a few of the larger asteroids and probably some of the Kuiper belt objects as well, but adding a requirement for a planet to have a minimum diameter of 1,000 km would remove the larger asteroids from contention while retaining Pluto.
Below are some brief reasons as to why Pluto may not be considered a planet with my rebuttal.
Pluto is small compared to the other planets.
Pluto is about half the size of the next smallest planet, Mercury. However, there is no scientific reason whatsoever to pick the size of Mercury as being the size of the smallest object to be called a planet. Mercury itself is less than half the size of Mars, and Mars is only about half the size of Earth or Venus. Earth and Venus are only about one-seventh the size of Jupiter. Why not pick one-tenth the size of Jupiter as the size of the smallest planet, if the cutoff is going to be chosen arbitrarily? In that case, Mars, Mercury and Pluto would all have to be classified as asteroids. If the size-cutoff between asteroids and planets is going to be randomly chosen, the cutoff value should be agreed upon in open debate among interested scientists.

Pluto is smaller than 7 moons in the solar system.
Pluto is smaller than Earth's Moon, Jupiter's moons Io, Europa, Ganymede, and Callisto, Saturn's moon Titan, and Neptune's moon Triton. On the other hand, Pluto is larger than the other 40 known moons in the solar system. There is no scientific reason to arbitrarily dis...


... middle of paper ...


...Willem J. Luyten
Science, New Series, Vol. 123, No. 3203. (May 18, 1956), pp. 896-897.
Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0036-8075%2819560817%293%3A124%3A3216%3C322%3ATPP%3E2.0.CO%3B2-L
This site is very reliable. It is the Scholarly Journal Archive.

2. Letters
The Planet Pluto
Gerard P. Kuiper
Science, New Series, Vol. 124, No. 3216. (Aug. 17, 1956), p. 322.
Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0036-8075%2819560817%293%3A124%3A3216%3C322%3ATPP%3E2.0.CO%3B2-L
This site is very reliable. It is the Scholarly Journal Archive.

3. Research News
Planetary Scientists are Seeing the Unseeable
Richard A. Kerr
Science, New Series, Vol. 235, No. 4784. (Jan. 2, 1987), pp. 29-31.
Stable URL: http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0036-8075%2819870102%293%3A235%3A4784%3C29%3APSASTU%3E2.0.CO%3B2-L
This site is very reliable. It is the Scholarly Journal Archive.

4. This is a site about Pluto. http://dosxx.colorado.edu/plutohome.html It is reliable since it is a part of an established academic institution.

5. This is the NASA page for Pluto. http://pds.jpl.nasa.gov/planets/welcome/pluto.htm

6. Another site from NASA. http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/pluto.html

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Demotion of Pluto: Dwarf Planet

- From the time Clyde W. Tombaugh first discovered Pluto in 1930, it was viewed as an oddball planet leading up to its reclassification in 2006. For decades, Pluto was once used as a benchmark for the outer reach and size of our solar system. In recent years, new discoveries of celestial bodies within the vicinity of Pluto’s orbit have challenged its planetary status. The debate over Pluto’s classification was discussed throughout several media and news articles, leading to serious controversy amongst astronomers and the decision as to whether or not Pluto should be categorized as one of the planets in our solar system....   [tags: celestial body, Eris and Sedna, dwarf planet ]

Strong Essays
1120 words (3.2 pages)

Pluto as a Dwarf Planet Essays

- By definition from a Merriam- Webster Dictionary a planet is “any of the large bodies that revolve around the sun in the solar system which have a similar body to them”. This is not a very specific explanation and makes it hard to fully grasp what it means; at this you could easily say that in fact Pluto a planet. However if you look at a scientific encyclopedia the definition is much different and more specific. The Access Science Encyclopedia says a planet is “A) a celestial body that is in orbit around the sun B) has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it can assume a hydrostatic equilibrium shape C) clears the neighborhood around its orbit”....   [tags: solar system, size, sun, IAU, astronomy, orbit]

Strong Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

Pluto: A Planet? Essays

- Pluto: A Planet. Many issues have arisen from the debate whether or not Pluto is a planet. Some astronomers say that Pluto should be classified as a “minor planet” due to its size, physical characteristics, and other factors. On the other hand, some astronomers defend Pluto’s planet status, citing several key features. Indeed, most of the problem is that there is no formal definition of a planet. Furthermore, it is very difficult to invent one that would allow the solar system to contain all nine planets....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Strong Essays
1670 words (4.8 pages)

Demotion of Pluto Essays

- The controversy of Pluto can be observed from two different perspectives, the scientific way and from the eyes of the public audience. Towards scientists despite that the solar system is exactly the same as it was in 2006, the demotion of Pluto resulted into a less vague definition of the word "Planet" and lead to a step forward in the life of science and technology. Although Pluto has many characteristics that make up a planet, it did not meet the requirements of the new definition of the word "Planet" that was proposed by the IAU....   [tags: orbits, planet, astronomers]

Strong Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

Demolition of Pluto Essay

- The Demolition of Pluto During a period of seventy years, it was believed that the existence of planets occupying the solar system consisted of: Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto. Once Mike Brown and his team officially discovered the tenth planet, Xena, later renamed Eris, being slightly larger than Pluto, many scientists were skeptical as to whether Eris and Pluto should truly be considered a planet. The lingering question of Pluto’s planetary status was suddenly untenable....   [tags: dwarf planet, solar system, schools]

Strong Essays
1391 words (4 pages)

Pluto 's And Its Effects On The World Essays

- Pluto’s Plight It all began in 1930 when Clyde Tombaugh discovered number nine (Cowen, par. 5). The definition of a planet before the IAU, International Aeronautical Union, conference in 2006, was, "a cloud of dust and gas that, at a high enough temperature is able to fuse hydrogen nuclei into helium nuclei inside its core” (Long, par. 8). Essentially, this means planets are capable to live a full life course: forming by burning to dying by burning. As Pluto aged, it could not withstand the test of time due to the technological advances in the scientific world....   [tags: Planet, Solar System, Dwarf planet, Neptune]

Strong Essays
1009 words (2.9 pages)

Pluto’s Unforeseen Future Essay

- Pluto was given its planet hood in February 18th 1930 and was thought to be the ninth planet in the solar system for over 70 years. Pluto was discovered by coincidence while Clyde W Tombaugh was in search for planet X. In the article “When is a planet not a planet?” by David H. Freedman it goes in debt about how Pluto went from being a planet in the solar system to being a dwarf planet after extensive argument on what a planet was. The definition for the word “planet” has not always been so clear especially for scientist....   [tags: planet, solar system, IAU]

Strong Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

The Planet Is A Planet Essay

- Throughout history the definition of planet has changed greatly. The Greeks defined a planet as an object that was a “wanderer” in the sky. This was to say that a planet was an object that changes position relative to the background stars.[3] This included the 5 planets visible to the human eye (Earth was not considered a planet) and sometimes included the Sun and Moon. The definition of planet was changed and reworked until 2006, when the current official definition was created. This definition is as follows: “A planet is a celestial body that (a) is in orbit around the Sun, (b) has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibri...   [tags: Planet, Solar System, Dwarf planet, Neptune]

Strong Essays
862 words (2.5 pages)

The Discovery Of The Planet Cornbread Essay

- Quite a while back in the solar system, there was numbered to have 10 Planet; Mercury!, Venus!, Earth!, Opilus!, Mars!, Jupiter!, Saturn!, Uranus!, Neptune!, Pluto!, and Cornbread!!. This planet was unique to us, we would remain absolutely determined to get its compound and components to fashion our weapons. We needed the Planet for to ourself as a result of what the Planet Cornbread is comprised of; vitality, gas, electric atom, Ununbium, and Lutetium these sorts of compounds are may together and having gives people weapons as though it was given by the Almighty God, no man could envision how much power can be in their grasp....   [tags: Earth, Solar System, Planet, Sun]

Strong Essays
1038 words (3 pages)

Pluto Essays

- In the outer limits of our solar system there is a planet unlike any other, Pluto. Pluto was discovered in February of 1930 by an American astronomer, Clyde Tombaugh. It is the only planet to have been discovered by an American. All though we have known of the existence of Pluto for over thirty years now, there are still many mysteries surrounding this celestial body. Being the farthest planet has made it difficult to study Pluto, Adding to the obscurity of this strange planet is that the capability to send spacecraft such distances has never been achieved....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1523 words (4.4 pages)